Pages

Wednesday, February 6, 2019



FEBRUARY 5 AND 6, 2019

NEWS AND VIEWS

GOTCHA. CAN THE NATURE AND THE TIMING OF THESE THREE EVENTS BE COINCIDENCE?

https://www.npr.org/2019/02/06/691989587/virginia-ag-says-he-dressed-as-a-rapper-and-wore-brown-makeup-at-a-1980-party
NATIONAL
Virginia AG Says He Dressed As A Rapper And Wore 'Brown Makeup' At A 1980 Party
February 6, 201912:03 PM ET
AMITA KELLY

PHOTOGRAPH -- Virginia Attorney General Mark Herring speaks at a press conference in Richmond, Va., in 2014.
Zach Gibson/Getty Images

With Virginia's top two politicians mired in their own controversies, the state's attorney general, Mark Herring, has revealed a racial incident in his own past. In a statement released Wednesday, he said he and friends attended a party in 1980 dressed as rappers they admired, including wearing wigs and "brown makeup."

"In 1980, when I was a 19-year-old undergraduate in college, some friends suggested we attend a party dressed like rappers we listened to at the time, like Kurtis Blow, and perform a song," he wrote. "It sounds ridiculous even now writing it. But because of our ignorance and glib attitudes — and because we did not have an appreciation for the experiences and perspectives of others — we dressed up and put on wigs and brown makeup."

Herring also said he's "sure we all have done things at one time or another in our lives that show poor judgment, and worse yet, have caused some level of pain to others." The 1980 party, he said, is a "glaring example" of that.

NATIONAL
Gov. Northam Is Finding Himself Increasingly Alone In Once-Supportive Virginia

The statement comes after a racist photo on Gov. Ralph Northam's 1984 medical school yearbook page surfaced last week. The photo shows one person in blackface and another wearing a Ku Klux Klan robe. After apologizing for the photo, Northam later insisted he was not one of the people in it. Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax is facing an allegation of sexual assault, which he has denied.

Herring is a progressive Democrat whose life and career reflect Virginia's evolution from capital of the Confederacy to the only Southern state that President Trump did not win in 2016.

"This was a onetime occurrence and I accept full responsibility for my conduct," Herring said.

The 57-year-old Virginia native comes from Loudoun County, a once largely rural area that now counts as one of Washington, D.C.'s outer suburbs. Herring began his political career there on the Board of Supervisors, followed by eight years in the Virginia Senate.

Read the full statement below:

"The very bright light that is shining on Virginia right now is sparking a painful but, I think we all hope, important conversation. The stakes are high, and our spirits are low.

"I am sure we all have done things at one time or another in our lives that show poor judgment, and worse yet, have caused some level of pain to others. I have a glaring example from my past that I have thought about with deep regret in the many years since, and certainly each time I took a step forward in public service, realizing that my goals and this memory could someday collide and cause pain for people I care about, those who stood with me in the many years since, or those who I hoped to serve while in office.

"In 1980, when I was a 19-year-old undergraduate in college, some friends suggested we attend a party dressed like rappers we listened to at the time, like Kurtis Blow, and perform a song. It sounds ridiculous even now writing it. But because of our ignorance and glib attitudes – and because we did not have an appreciation for the experiences and perspectives of others – we dressed up and put on wigs and brown makeup.

"This was a onetime occurrence and I accept full responsibility for my conduct.

That conduct clearly shows that, as a young man, I had a callous and inexcusable lack of awareness and insensitivity to the pain my behavior could inflict on others. It was really a minimization of both people of color, and a minimization of a horrific history I knew well even then.

"Although the shame of that moment has haunted me for decades, and though my disclosure of it now pains me immensely, what I am feeling in no way compares to the betrayal, the shock, and the deep pain that Virginians of color may be feeling. Where they have deserved to feel heard, respected, understood, and honestly represented, I fear my actions have contributed to them being forced to revisit and feel a historical pain that has never been allowed to become history.

"This conduct is in no way reflective of the man I have become in the nearly 40 years since.

"As a senator and as attorney general, I have felt an obligation to not just acknowledge but work affirmatively to address the racial inequities and systemic racism that we know exist in our criminal justice system, in our election processes, and in other institutions of power. I have long supported efforts to empower communities of color by fighting for access to healthcare, making it easier and simpler to vote, and twice defended the historic re-enfranchisement of former felons before the Supreme Court of Virginia. I have launched efforts to make our criminal justice system more just, fair, and equal by addressing implicit bias in law enforcement, establishing Virginia's first-ever program to improve re-entry programs in local jails, and pushing efforts to reform the use of cash bail. And I have tried to combat the rise in hate crimes and white supremacist violence that is plaguing our Commonwealth and our country.

"That I have contributed to the pain Virginians have felt this week is the greatest shame I have ever felt. Forgiveness in instances like these is a complicated process, one that necessarily cannot and should not be decided by anyone but those directly affected by the transgressor, should forgiveness be possible or appropriate at all. In the days ahead, honest conversations and discussions will make it clear whether I can or should continue to serve as attorney general, but no matter where we go from here, I will say that from the bottom of my heart, I am deeply, deeply sorry for the pain that I cause with this revelation."

Mark Katkov contributed to this report.


VIRGINIA ORDER OF SUCCESSION

https://news.wfu.edu/2019/02/06/expert-on-virginia-constitution-available-to-comment-on-gubernatorial-removal-succession-issues/
Expert on Virginia Constitution available to comment on gubernatorial removal, succession issues

February 6, 2019
by Cheryl Walker | walkercv@wfu.edu | 336.758.6073

John Dinan, a Wake Forest University politics and international affairs professor who specializes in the study of state constitutions and is the author of the book The Virginia State Constitution, can answer questions about the process in Virginia for removing a governor from office and what happens if a governor is removed or resigns.

Removing a governor from office: The Virginia Constitution provides two pathways for removing a governor from office. First, the Virginia Constitution allows for impeachment in cases of “malfeasance in office, corruption, neglect of duty, or other high crime or misdemeanor.” Similar to the process in place at the national level, it takes a majority vote in the house to impeach an official and a two-thirds vote in the senate for conviction and removal from office. Second, in a provision that roughly tracks the 25th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and was intended to apply to cases of physical or mental disability, a governor can be deemed “unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office,” as determined either by the attorney general, senate president pro tem, and house speaker acting together or by a majority vote of all members of the legislature. Such a determination triggers a process that ultimately requires a three-fourths vote in the house and senate to remove a governor on the ground of inability to discharge the powers and duties of the office.

Succession to the office of governor: When a governor leaves office before the end of the term, he is succeeded by the lieutenant governor. In case the lieutenant governor’s office is vacant, the attorney general would become governor. In case the office of attorney general is vacant, the house speaker would become governor. In any of these situations, someone assuming the office of governor mid-term would not be prohibited from running for and serving another full term in office, despite Virginia’s prohibition on a governor serving consecutive terms.

Succession to the office of lieutenant governor: In the event the lieutenant governor succeeds the governor and therefore the lieutenant governor’s office becomes vacant, the senate president pro tem would discharge the duties of the lieutenant governor, while continuing to serve in the senate. The governor is then permitted to appoint someone to fill the vacancy in the lieutenant governor’s office, with this appointee serving until the next scheduled general election (November 2019), when an election would be held to fill out the remainder of the original term.

Succession to the office of attorney general: In the event of a vacancy in the office of attorney general, the position would be filled by a person selected by a majority vote of all members of the legislature, as long as the legislature is in session, and that person would then serve the remainder of the original term. If the legislature is in recess, then the position would be filled temporarily by an appointee of the governor and that person would serve until the legislature is next in session and would select someone to fill out the term.

Categories: Faculty, Top Stories

Profile picture for Cheryl Walker
Media Contact
Cheryl Walker
walkercv@wfu.edu | 336.758.6073 | @CherylVWalker

WAKE FOREST NEWS
336.758.5237
media@wfu.edu
Meet the News Team

John Dinan
Expert on Virginia Constitution available to comment on gubernatorial removal, succession issues

Profile picture for John Dinan
John Dinan

Professor of Politics and International Affairs
Dinan studies federal and state policy-making and constitutional developments.

BROADCAST STUDIO
Wake Forest University’s Office of Communications and External Relations operates a fully equipped, professional television and radio studio to connect faculty members and campus newsmakers with global news media.

ABOUT WAKE FOREST NEWS
We are Wake Forest University’s primary news source and first point of contact for reporters. We help media by facilitating interviews, connecting with faculty experts or providing interesting story ideas. A staff member is on call 24/7 for media requests at 336.758.5237. Our team also offers a variety of communications resources for Wake Forest students, faculty and staff.


IF YOU CAN’T KILL THE PRESS WITH A SLEDGE HAMMER, CUT OFF THEIR ACCESS TO INFORMATION, BY UNDERHANDED AND NEFARIOUS MEANS, OF COURSE.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/its-not-just-the-white-house-at-pentagon-and-state-dept-the-press-is-out-in-the-cold-too/2019/01/31/96f5ee02-258b-11e9-81fd-b7b05d5bed90_story.html
It’s not just the White House: At Pentagon and State Dept., the press is out in the cold, too
By Paul Farhi January 31, 2019

PHOTOGRAPH -- Acting Secretary of Defense Patrick Shanahan vows to engage more frequently with the press. (Jim Watson/AFP/Getty Images)

With President Trump sending more troops to the southern border, pulling some out of Syria and causing uncertainty among allies in NATO, now would seem to be a good time for the Pentagon’s brass to be getting its message out about the U.S. military.

Instead, the Pentagon’s leadership is doing less press. Top officials haven’t given an on-camera briefing to reporters since August. When acting defense secretary Patrick M. Shanahan spoke to the news media for the first time this week, it was “off camera,” meaning no one could televise or make a video recording of what he said.

Over at the State Department, the daily press briefing — once held literally daily — has become a hit-and-miss event. Before the government shutdown obliterated any briefings at all in mid-December, department officials averaged just six briefings per month during the preceding three months. The briefings got briefer, too: In previous administrations, officials spent an hour or more addressing questions about U.S. diplomatic initiatives around the world; more recently, the sessions have lasted about 25 minutes.

The White House set a record in January for the longest period in modern history without holding a press briefing, the Q&A sessions that establish a record of administration policies. But these days, it’s not just the White House that isn’t talking much to the news media. The State and Defense departments — the diplomatic and military arms of the world’s only superpower — have been curtailing their outreach with reporters, too.

For decades, the State Department had a proud tradition of briefing reporters five days a week. The sessions were widely followed inside Foggy Bottom, at embassies across Washington and ministries around the world for clues about America’s foreign policy. That changed under Trump’s first secretary of state, Rex Tillerson, and has continued under his successor, Mike Pompeo.

The Pentagon had frequent briefings, too, as well as less formal “gaggles,” in which spokesmen discussed an array of topics. These sessions used to occur twice a week but are now held once or twice a month.

Both the Pentagon and the State Department have cut back on the number of reporters who travel with the secretaries on their trips abroad. The press retinue on the secretary of state’s frequent trips used to consist of 13 newspaper, wire service, radio and TV reporters and technicians; now it’s typically seven or eight, although the department says the number can vary depending on the size of the plane and the security arrangements. The defense secretary’s plane can take 18 in the press compartment; under former secretary of defense Jim Mattis, the press section had half or fewer than that number.

The cutback forced some reporters to book commercial flights to follow Pompeo on his recent to visit to eight countries in the Middle East. One problem: Pompeo’s schedule and commercial flight restrictions — regional rivals Qatar and Saudi Arabia do not permit reciprocal flights, for instance — meant reporters had to skip chunks of the trip.

Such limitation have forced journalists to increase their reliance on “pool” reporting to cover Pompeo’s travels, in which one reporter produces an account of events that is shared with the rest of the press corps. This arrangement, however, means there’s only one journalist, rather than multiple ones, covering the news.

It also means the public finds out less about decisions and actions on its behalf, reporters say.

“The briefing is the way an ordinary person, whether you’re sitting in St. Louis or Tennessee or the middle of Africa or Asia” learns about U.S. diplomacy, said Lesley Wroughton, a Reuters reporter who is president of the State Department Correspondents Association. “If you want to understand what the American attitude is, the briefing is the way to get at that. It’s also the way to hold the State Department and the administration accountable for their actions — by allowing reporters to ask questions, whether you like the questions or not. Without it, there are a lot of unknowns.”

In a statement, acting State Department press secretary Robert Palladino said Pompeo “has taken steps to increase media engagement at the State Department, across the United States, and around the world. No surprise that journalists want even more access — they wouldn’t be doing their jobs if they didn’t.”

His department cited statistics to bolster its record: Pompeo has appeared in eight televised briefings since his appointment in April, and given remarks or interviews 72 times while traveling abroad.

Pentagon spokesman Tom Crosson also said media relations are on the upswing. He said Mattis’s successor, Shanahan, is just getting started and has vowed to be more open with reporters. “He and other senior leaders will engage more frequently,” he said. “We’re working toward more engagement. . . . This is not a war on the media.”

Both the State and Defense departments say the travel restrictions on reporters are the result of logistical considerations, such as security arrangements, rather than an attempt to limit the press.

Nevertheless, beat reporters attribute the departments’ diminished interactions with the news media to the White House, which they say prefers to control the message.

“Everything has changed in the Pentagon since Trump,” said Kevin Baron, the executive editor of Defense One, a news site specializing in national security.

The reluctance of the Pentagon’s leadership to engage with reporters “is all a direct response to this White House and this president,” he said. “No one [at the Pentagon] wants to get crosswise with the president. They feel if they say the wrong thing, they’ll be in the crosshairs of the White House. What has happened under Trump is that it has all come to a screeching halt.”

Baron said Mattis avoided the news media because he was reluctant to air his disagreements with the president in public (Mattis’s repudiation of Trump, however, became explicit in his resignation letter in December). As a result, both Mattis and Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, have typically interacted with the press via off-camera “gaggles,” informal sessions that the public — and White House officials — don’t see (though Dunford has done multiple interviews and media appearances over the past year).

Reporters say their inability to get direct comment from senior officials has caused them to seek secondhand sources, whose knowledge is invariably more limited. They also say they have had more background interviews — those in which sources speak without being directly identified. Trump has railed against leaks and the practice of using anonymous sources in news stories, but the curtailed access to top officials may have led to an increase in both.

Improved access wouldn’t just make journalists’ jobs easier, it would also be good for the public, said Robert Burns, an Associated Press reporter who heads the Pentagon Press Association. The less government leaders engage, he said, “the less the public learns about what their government is doing on their behalf.”

Correction: This story originally stated that top Pentagon officials haven’t given an on-camera briefing to reporters since May. There was a briefing in August. The story has also been updated to clarify that Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr. has spoken to the media outside of off-camera gaggles.

Paul Farhi
Paul Farhi is The Washington Post's media reporter. He started at The Post in 1988 and has been a financial reporter, a political reporter and a Style reporter. Follow


I NOTICE THAT HOWARD SCHULTZ IS GOING AFTER THE FEMALE PROGRESSIVES AGGRESSIVELY, BUT HE DOESN’T EVEN MENTION SANDERS. HAS HE LOOKED AT HIS TAXATION PLAN FOR THE RICH? OR DOES HE THINK BERNIE IS TOO DECREPIT TO FUNCTION IN THAT OFFICE, OR CAN’T POSSIBLY WIN? I THINK SANDERS IS TOO HARD A FIGHTER TO GIVE UP THAT EASILY, AND HIS MIND IS STILL “SHARP AS A TACK,” AS MY FATHER USED TO SAY.

https://news.vice.com/en_us/article/nexnjz/howard-schultz-is-blaming-aoc-and-elizabeth-warren-for-his-decision-to-run-as-independent
Howard Schultz is blaming AOC and Elizabeth Warren for his decision to run as an independent
By Rex Santus Jan 30, 2019

Former Starbucks CEO and former “lifelong Democrat” Howard Schultz blamed Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and 2020 presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren for his decision to run for president as an independent.

In a series of recent interviews, Schultz said that Democrats are embracing “un-American” policies that target billionaires, which he happens to be. At a Monday night event for his book launch, he specifically called out Ocasio-Cortez’s informal proposal to tax America’s hyper-rich at a 70 percent marginal rate.

“I respect the Democratic Party. I no longer feel affiliated because I don't know their views represent the majority of Americans. I don't think we want a 70 percent income tax in America,” Schultz said, although he mischaracterized Ocasio-Cortez’s idea. She’s proposing a marginal tax on income over $10 million, which would affect only a tiny fraction of America’s most wealthy.

Schultz, who endorsed Hillary Clinton in 2016 and previously described himself as a “lifelong Democrat,” attempted to dismiss Ocasio-Cortez as a “bit misinformed.” Recent polls indicate a majority of Americans support Ocasio-Cortez’s idea, which was U.S. tax law until Ronald Reagan became president and cut taxes. Ocasio-Cortez said last week that a “system that allows billionaires to exist” is immoral.

Ocasio-Cortez responded to Schultz’s critiques of her by pondering why nobody ever tells billionaires seeking high office to work their way up or “start with City Council first.” A few anonymous Democrats told the Hill this week that they were seeking candidates to primary Ocasio-Cortez because she ascended too quickly.


Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez
✔
@AOC
Why don’t people ever tell billionaires who want to run for President that they need to “work their way up” or that “maybe they should start with city council first”?

The Daily Beast
✔
@thedailybeast
Howard Schultz blames Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez for his decision to run as Independent and it has to do with her plan to tax the rich https://trib.al/vxHYHyd

231K
9:58 AM - Jan 30, 2019
Twitter Ads info and privacy
67.2K people are talking about this


He also singled out Elizabeth Warren’s proposed “ultra-millionaire” tax that economists say would generate trillions in revenue over a decade by taxing the wealth of America’s richest. He said Warren’s plan was “ridiculous” and would never get passed.

Warren fired back and implied that Schultz wanted to buy the presidency to keep the system rigged” for himself and other billionaires.


Schultz also attacked Medicare for All, a policy idea that’s been widely embraced by 2020 Democratic candidates that would guarantee health coverage to all Americans but could abolish the private insurance industry.

“That’s not correct. That’s not American,” Schultz said Tuesday on CBS. “What’s next? What industry are we going to abolish next? The coffee industry?”

Last week, Schultz announced he is “seriously considering” running for president as a “centrist independent,” sparking a backlash among Democrats fearing he’d take votes from them and contribute to a Trump re-election. Many have also attacked his billionaire status: During his press tour, Schultz revealed that he has no idea how much a box of cereal costs.

Cover: Howard Schultz seen on day one of Summit LA18 in Downtown Los Angeles on Sunday, Nov. 2, 2018, in Los Angeles. (Photo by Amy Harris/Invision/AP)


THIS STORY DOESN’T DESCRIBE HOW THE RUNNER MANAGED TO STRANGLE/SUFFOCATE A YOUNG 80 POUND MOUNTAIN LION, OR COUGAR. THAT ISN’T A VERY LARGE LION BUT THEY ARE INCREDIBLY DANGEROUS. IT WAS PROBABLY INEXPERIENCED AT HUNTING, MAYBE STARVING, AND THE ARTICLE SAID THAT AN AUTOPSY WILL BE PERFORMED ON THE ANIMAL. MOUNTAIN LIONS DON’T USUALLY ATTACK PEOPLE. I ASSUME THEY WILL CHECK FOR RABIES. PERSONALLY, I WOULDN’T EVER GO ON A LONG MOUNTAIN HIKE ON MY OWN, AND I DON’T THINK A MAN SHOULD EITHER. HOPEFULLY AN UPDATE WILL BE ISSUED ON THE FACTS HERE. LOOK AT THESE WAYS GIVEN THAT A HUMAN CAN DEFEND HIMSELF AGAINST A CAT. THE INSTRUCTION GIVEN IS ABOUT THE SAME AS WITH DOGS AND BEARS. IN ALL CASES, WE HAVE TO AVOID LOOKING OR ACTING LIKE PREY, AND REMEMBER THAT THEY CAN OUTRUN US. FOUR LEGS ARE BETTER THAN TWO.

https://www.npr.org/2019/02/05/691528804/colorado-runner-kills-mountain-lion-in-self-defense
Colorado Runner Kills Mountain Lion In Self-Defense
February 5, 20198:02 AM ET
MATTHEW S. SCHWARTZ

PHOTOGRAPH -- A mountain lion leaps from a rock in this file photo. A man in Colorado successfully defended himself from a mountain lion attack while he was jogging on a trail Monday.
Avalon/UIG via Getty Images

Updated at 11 a.m. ET

A trail jogger in Colorado successfully defended himself Monday against a mountain lion that attacked him from behind. The cat is dead, and the man is recovering in a local hospital.

The jogger, whose identity has not been released, was running alone in the foothills of the Horsetooth Mountain Park in northern Colorado when, he said, he heard something behind him on the trail. As he turned to investigate, the juvenile mountain lion lunged.

The jogger said he was bitten on the face and wrist, according to a statement from Colorado Parks and Wildlife. But he was able to fight back, killing the young mountain lion. The man's injuries were serious, but not life-threatening, and he was able to get himself to a local hospital.

The man killed the animal by suffocating it, according to Colorado Parks and Wildlife's Northeast Region. Exactly how he did so wasn't immediately clear.


CPW NE Region
@CPW_NE
· 13h
More on today's mountain lion attack at Horsetooth Reservoir Open Space: the trail runner is recovering from his injuries, and the lion was killed as the victim defended himself on the trail. A necropsy* will be performed by @COParksWildlife. More details: https://cpw.state.co.us/aboutus/Pages/News-Release-Details.aspx?NewsID=6832 …


CPW NE Region
@CPW_NE
After additional investigation, including examination of the lion, we have confirmed the victim's account that he was able to suffocate the animal while defending himself from the attack.

1,410
9:39 AM - Feb 5, 2019
Twitter Ads info and privacy
838 people are talking about this

Colorado state park officials later found the body of the juvenile mountain lion near several possessions that the jogger asked officers to recover for him. The body of the big cat was taken to a state health lab for examination. It possibly weighed at least 80 pounds, CPW said.

"In the event of a lion attack you need to do anything in your power to fight back just as this gentleman did," Mark Leslie, Colorado Parks and Wildlife Northeast Region manager, said in the statement.

The park closed after the attack for an investigation, but reopened Monday evening, according to the Coloradoan.

The parks service said mountain lion attacks on people are rare, with fewer than 20 fatalities in more than a century. Lions are "elusive animals" that "tend to avoid humans," CPW said. Nonetheless, if people encounter a mountain lion, they should try not to run. "Running may stimulate a lion's instinct to chase and attack," the parks service said.

The parks service offered several tips for such an encounter: Face the mountain lion, stand tall, and make yourself appear larger by raising your arms and opening your jacket if you are wearing one. Never turn your back.

"What you want to do is convince the lion you are not prey and that you may in fact be a danger to the lion," the parks service said.

If the cat attacks, all is not lost, CPW said. "People have fought back with rocks, sticks, caps or jackets, garden tools and their bare hands successfully."

If you have to fight, the parks service recommends targeting the animal's eyes and nose.


ABORTION IS A SAD THING, BUT NOT AS SAD AS A CHILD BEING RAISED BY A WOMAN WHO, BECAUSE OF HER OWN EMOTIONAL PAIN, CANNOT GIVE IT THE INNER NURTURING THAT WE ALL NEED. A CHILD CAN’T THRIVE ON INTELLECTUALIZED “LOVE.” IF THERE ARE NO HUGS AND GENTLENESS, THERE IS NO USABLE LOVE. A WOMAN WHO FEELS THAT WAY SHOULD CONSIDER TAKING PSYCHOTHERAPY, AND IN THE FUTURE, USING BIRTH CONTROL; AND IF THE WOMAN FEELS THAT SHE CAN’T DO WHAT A MOTHER MUST DO, THERE SHOULD ALWAYS CONSIDER ADOPTION.

YES, I’M NOT A CHRISTIAN, BUT AN ETHICAL HUMANIST. I WANT LIFE ALWAYS TO BE BEARABLE AND WHEN POSSIBLE, HAPPY FOR EVERYBODY. THERE ARE KIDS BORN AND RAISED EVERY DAY IN A SITUATION THAT STIFLES THEIR DESIRE TO BE ALIVE AND THEIR ABILITY TO SUCCEED. NOW THAT REALLY IS A TRAGEDY. OH, YES, AND THEN WE INCARCERATE THEM.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/01/apprehension-on-all-sides-before-launch-of-irish-abortion-services
Apprehension on all sides before launch of Irish abortion services
Legislation and logistics have been fast-tracked to turn last May’s vote into reality

IMAGE -- People celebrate the result of the Irish abortion referendum in May 2018. Photograph: Clodagh Kilcoyne/Reuters

Ireland is poised to roll out its first regular abortion services in the coming weeks in the wake of the referendum vote to lift the country’s near-total ban on abortion.

Politicians and officials fast-tracked legislation and logistical preparations to turn last year’s landslide vote in favour of liberalisation into reality for women who wish to terminate pregnancies.

About nine of the state’s 19 maternity units, plus clinics run by other organisations, have indicated they will be ready to start abortion services in January.

Only 162 of Ireland’s 4,000 GPs have signed up to provide the service, but the government says that will suffice. The government plans to establish “exclusion zones” to move any protests away from clinics.

The rollout will mark another milestone in the Republic of Ireland’s transformation from a conservative society in thrall to the Roman Catholic church to a liberal, secular country, and will increase the pressure to lift Northern Ireland’s abortion ban, an anomaly in the UK.

“The fact it has been turned around so quickly is brilliant,” said Clare Murphy, a spokesperson for the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS), which catered to many of the approximately 3,000 women who travelled from Ireland to Britain last year to obtain abortions. “That number will definitely drop, without a doubt.”

The referendum last May delivered a mandate for change: 66.4% of voters chose to repeal the eighth amendment to the constitution, which gave “the unborn” equal rights to pregnant women and made abortion illegal even in cases of rape, incest or severe danger to the mother.

Since then, Ireland’s health minister, Simon Harris, has driven a tight timetable, steering legislation through contentious, marathon debates in parliament and negotiating with medical service providers.

The Irish president, Michael Higgins, signed the regulation of termination of pregnancy bill into law on 20 December, paving the way for services to open in January. Campaigners have hailed it as an overdue breakthrough for women’s rights and equality.

Under the new system, GPs will provide abortions to women up to nine weeks pregnant and hospitals will perform terminations at between nine and 12 weeks. After 12 weeks, abortions will be allowed only in exceptional circumstances. The service will be largely free, with the state paying GPs approximately €400 per patient.

As the rollout nears, all sides are apprehensive. Pro-choice groups criticised a mandatory three-day “cooling off” period for women who request abortions, calling it a sop to anti-abortion activists that lacked any medical basis. They also worry about uncertainty over those seeking abortions after 12 weeks, estimated in about 17% of cases.

“We expect there will be a significant cohort of women who won’t be catered for,” said Murphy. She expected hundreds of such cases to end up in British clinics this year.

Anti-abortion advocates have been dismayed, saying the referendum was not a mandate for abortion on demand. Brendan Leahy, the bishop of Limerick, said Ireland was experiencing an “inglorious watermark”.

Doctors, nurses, counsellors and administrators worry about bottlenecks and confusion in a health service already creaking from dysfunction and long waiting lists.

A 24-hour, seven-day helpline will direct women to local GPs who provide abortions. Concern about teething problems has deterred many GPs from signing up to abortion services.

An online consultation by the Irish College of General Practitioners (ICGP) found that 43% were unwilling because of concerns about the rollout, especially “referral pathways” to secondary care involving ultrasound and hospital services.

Tony Cox, the ICGP’s medical director, said: “A small but significant group, particularly younger GPs, see the introduction of abortion services as a significant milestone for women’s health services in Ireland.

“We believe the majority of members are concerned that the introduction has been rushed, that the referral pathways won’t be in place for a while, but are optimistic that it will settle down and that the media interest will subside, and the 24-hour helpline will work smoothly.”


“AND THE BEAT GOES ON, AND THE BEAT GOES ON.”

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jan/04/activists-protest-against-irelands-new-abortion-services
Activists protest against Ireland's new abortion services
Pro-choice groups condemn picket of clinic as health service warns of fake websites
Rory Carroll Ireland correspondent
@rorycarroll72
Fri 4 Jan 2019 13.18 EST

Anti-abortion activists have struck back against Ireland’s introduction of abortion services by picketing a clinic and by launching potentially misleading websites that mimic the state’s support service for unplanned pregnancies.

A group holding placards protested outside a doctor’s office in Galway on Thursday in an effort to deter women from seeking abortion pills just three days after abortion services became legal.

About half a dozen people stood outside the Galvia West medical centre in Galway city with signs bearing slogans including “Say no to abortion in Galway” and “Real doctors don’t terminate their patients.”

Organisers said it was a peaceful demonstration that received positive feedback from the public.

However, pro-choice groups condemned the picket as intimidation and urged the government to establish exclusion zones to prevent protests outside abortion service providers.

“I do find that this is public harassment, effectively, of people who are trying to access abortion services here,” Ailbhe Smyth from the Together for Yes campaign told Newstalk radio station on Friday.

“It’s despicable behaviour because they are deliberately seeking to deter women from accessing an entirely lawful health service in this country.”

She called on the health minister, Simon Harris, to deliver on a promise to introduce legislation for exclusion zones around medical practices offering abortion services, a call backed by Colm O’Gorman, the head of Amnesty Ireland.

“Exclusion zones don’t mean people cannot protest,” he tweeted. “But they must do so in a way that doesn’t interfere with another person’s right to access a lawful health service.”

Pro-choice activists hope Ireland’s success can be replicated in North

Meanwhile, other anti-abortion activists are believed to be behind several websites that mimic myoptions.ie, a support site for women affected by unplanned pregnancies run by the Health Service Executive (HSE), a state agency.

The site, which launched on Tuesday, directs women who seek abortions to advice and information about how to access the service, which is set to roll out across Ireland in the coming weeks and months.

The HSE warned this week of websites with possible hidden agendas using similar names to its helpline.

The mimic sites try to steer women away from abortions by warning of health dangers and offering ultrasounds to show an image of the foetus.

“Call us now and book a free ultrasound if you are thinking about termination and need to know how far pregnant you are and all you need to know to be fully informed,” says one such site, myoptions.website.

It links to research which claims to link abortions to breast cancer, an association which has been widely discredited by physicians and scientists.

When the Guardian called its helpline, it was answered by Eamon Murphy, a veteran anti-abortion activist based in Dublin. “We’re flooded with phone calls and demands,” he said.

He cited research purportedly connecting abortions to cancer. “We’re probably the only people telling women of the link.”

Asked about misleading callers by mimicking the state’s helpline, Murphy said his site was set up last year, predating the official site. Asked for more details, he ended the call.

Ireland started rolling out abortion services on 1 January in the wake of the referendum vote last year to lift a near-total ban on abortion, a landmark in the country’s social liberalisation.

A total of 66.4% of voters delivered a stinging rebuke to the Roman Catholic church by voting to repeal the eighth amendment to the constitution, which gave “the unborn” equal rights to pregnant women and made abortion illegal even in cases of rape, incest or severe danger to the mother.

Fast-track legislation led to the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Act being signed into law on 20 December 2018, paving the way for service rollout this month.

Most of the state’s 19 maternity units, plus clinics run by other organisations, are expected to start offering abortion services within weeks.

About 20 women reportedly sought terminations on the first working day of the service on Wednesday.

Under the new system, GPs will provide abortions to women up to nine weeks pregnant and hospitals will perform terminations at between nine and 12 weeks.

After 12 weeks, abortions will be allowed only in exceptional circumstances. The service will be largely free, with the state paying GPs approximately €400 (£358) per patient.


https://www.thenation.com/article/socialism-sotu-donald-trump-bernie-sanders/
Socialism Is More Popular Than You Think, Mr. President
Most surveys show Trump would lose in a matchup against a democratic socialist named Bernie Sanders.
By John Nichols TODAY FEBRUARY 6, 2019 5:16 PM

PHOTOGRAPH – SANDERS AND THE CROWD (Reuters / Lucy Nicholson)

Donald Trump’s State of the Union Address did not feature a musical soundtrack. But, if it had, surely the orchestral accompaniment would have soared when he got to the line: “We are born free, and we will stay safe. Tonight, we renew our resolve that America will never be a socialist country.”

But, just as surely, the music would have quieted down as the camera shifted to the assured countenance of newly elected US Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, the New York Democrat who was elected last fall after campaigning as “an educator, organizer, Democratic Socialist, and born-and-raised New Yorker running to champion working families in Congress; or that of US Representative Rashida Tlaib (D-MI), who won her 2018 primary and general election races as a member of Democratic Socialists of America and was endorsed by DSA’s muscular chapter in the Detroit area. And the music would have stopped when it got to Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, who is often referred to as “America’s best-known socialist,” and whom a lot of people would like to see challenge Trump in the 2020 presidential race.

The president might have wanted the joint session of Congress, and the American people who bothered to listen in, to believe that “Here, in the United States, we are alarmed by new calls to adopt socialism in our country. America was founded on liberty and independence—not government coercion, domination and control.”

But every recent national poll of prospective 2020 voters has Sanders, the democratic socialist, beating Trump, the socialism basher.

A PPP survey released January 22 had it Sanders 51 to Trump 41. That was an improvement on the nine-point lead a PPP survey gave the senator last June.

When CNN polled prospective 2020 voters last year, it was Sanders 55 to Trump 42.

In the battleground state of Michigan, which Trump narrowly won in 2016, a new Detroit News/WDIV-TV poll has Sanders leading by 11 points.

A PPP survey of North Carolina voters, which was conducted last month, put Sanders ahead 48-45 in another state that the Republicans won in 2016.

Sanders has not announced that he will challenge the president. But the senator, who won 23 primaries and caucuses as a contender for the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination, generally polls near the top of the Democrats and independents who will judge the wide field of 2020 Democratic prospects. (He’s behind former vice president Joe Biden but ahead of all or most of the other announced and prospective candidates.)

Biden often polls a point or so better against Trump than does Sanders in hypothetical matchups for a 2020 general election contest. But Sanders tends to run better than other Democratic prospects.

So it doesn’t seem like the “s” word is dragging the senator down.

Perhaps that is because, while Trump may think “socialism” is a scare word, and while many prominent Democrats may get scared when it is referenced, Sanders is comfortable discussing the ideology. “Do they think I’m afraid of the word? I’m not afraid of the word,” says Sanders.

On Tuesday night, the senator trumped Trump’s “born free… stay safe” rhetoric with a simple observation: “People are not truly free when they can’t afford health care, prescription drugs, or a place to live. People are not free when they cannot retire with dignity or feed their families.”

That’s how Sanders does it. He’s not defensive. He’s aggressive. While Trump equates the humane democratic socialism that millions of Americans embrace with “government coercion, domination and control”—in a desperate attempt to narrow the discourse—Sanders makes honest comparisons that expand and enhance the dialogue.

“I happen to believe that, if the American people understood the significant accomplishments that have taken place under social-democratic governments, democratic-socialist governments, labor governments throughout Europe, they would be shocked to know about those accomplishments,” the senator told me several years ago. “How many Americans know that in virtually every European country, when you have a baby, you get guaranteed time off and, depending on the country, significant financial benefits as well. Do the American people know that? I doubt it. Do the American people even know that we’re the only major Western industrialized country that doesn’t guarantee healthcare for all? Most people don’t know that. Do the American people know that in many countries throughout Europe, public colleges and universities are either tuition-free or very inexpensive?”

The numbers don’t tell us that America is a socialist country. But they do suggest that Americans are intrigued by socialism as an alternative to capitalism. Thirty-seven percent of Americans now view socialism positively, according to a Gallup survey from last year. And among the rising generation of voters, the numbers are substantially higher. “Americans aged 18 to 29 are as positive about socialism (51 percent) as they are about capitalism (45 percent),” explains the Gallup analysis. “This represents a 12-point decline in young adults’ positive views of capitalism in just the past two years and a marked shift since 2010, when 68 percent viewed it positively.”

Another set of numbers may be even more telling. Membership in Democratic Socialists of America has spiked from 7,000 members in 2016 to over 55,000 today. And dozens of democratic socialists now serve in elected posts, from the US Senate to the US House to state legislatures and municipal governments and school boards across the country.

Take note, Mr. President, the “s” word isn’t as scary as you think. Indeed, says Ocasio-Cortez, “I think he’s scared.”

“He sees that everything is closing in on him,” says the democratic socialist, who is advancing a Green New Deal plan and proposing tax hikes for the rich. “And he knows he’s losing the battle of public opinion when it comes to the actual substantive proposals that we’re advancing.”


MOST POPULAR

4
STACEY ABRAMS SHOWS TRUMP WHAT A POLITICIAN WHO CARES ABOUT THIS COUNTRY SOUNDS LIKE

5
THE UNITED STATES IS A PROGRESSIVE NATION WITH A DEMOCRACY PROBLEM

John NicholsTWITTERJohn Nichols is The Nation’s national-affairs correspondent. He is the author of Horsemen of the Trumpocalypse: A Field Guide to the Most Dangerous People in America, from Nation Books, and co-author, with Robert W. McChesney, of People Get Ready: The Fight Against a Jobless Economy and a Citizenless Democracy.


ABOUT SANDERS' ADVISER MATT DUSS:

https://www.thenation.com/article/matt-duss-bernie-sanders-foreign-policy-blob/
Who Is Matt Duss, and Can He Take On Washington’s ‘Blob’?
Bernie Sanders’s foreign-policy adviser is part of a new generation of progressives fighting an entrenched status quo.
By David KlionTwitter TODAY FEBRUARY 6, 2019 2:00 PM

ART – WASHINGTON ENGULFED IN A HUGE PINK “BLOB”

Forty-five years after Congress passed the War Powers Resolution over Richard Nixon’s veto, the Senate finally invoked its power to end a war. This past December, 56 senators voted to cut off all US support for Saudi Arabia’s horrific military campaign in Yemen, which began in the final years of the Obama administration, sharply escalated under Donald Trump, and has led to the deaths of an estimated 85,000 children due to starvation.

The morning of the vote, Bernie Sanders addressed his Senate colleagues next to a photo of an emaciated Yemeni child and urged them to pass the resolution, which he’d introduced along with co-sponsors Mike Lee, a Republican, and Chris Murphy, a Democrat. “We have been providing the bombs the Saudi-led coalition is using, refueling their planes before they drop those bombs, and assisting with intelligence,” Sanders said. “In too many cases, our weapons are being used to kill civilians.”

As the Vermont senator spoke, a 6-foot-5, bespectacled bear of a man sat quietly beside him. Matt Duss, 46, has recently become one of the most significant figures reshaping progressive foreign policy in the Trump era. Since February 2017, when Sanders hired him as his foreign-policy adviser, Duss has played a key role in advancing the Yemen resolution and has deeply informed Sanders’s growing emphasis on international affairs.

“I give Matt an extraordinary amount of credit on Yemen,” says Representative Ro Khanna, who introduced the joint resolution in the House. “He’s the principal reason that Sanders took this huge risk in introducing the War Powers Resolution in the Senate and agreeing to [support] what we had introduced in the House.”

RELATED ARTICLE
The Nation
THE AMERICAN EMPIRE’S HISTORY OF AMNESIA
Tom Engelhardt

Sanders is reportedly about to announce a second presidential run, and attention is already turning to his foreign-policy views. In his 2016 campaign, Sanders’s primary focus was on domestic economic issues, and many critics regarded him as a lightweight on foreign policy. This time around, Sanders has won over skeptics in the foreign-policy establishment with substantive speeches in 2017 and 2018, laying out a comprehensive vision for America’s role in the world. Beyond wanting to end or prevent wars in the Middle East, Sanders has also linked the global rise of authoritarian populism to wealth inequality, and has called for an international progressive movement to combat authoritarian leaders and kleptocrats from Russia to Brazil. And while Duss doesn’t want to take credit for what he says are his boss’s deeply held views, he has had a hand in all of this.

To the extent that Sanders is raising new ideas and challenging the interventionist consensus that has long dominated Washington, it makes sense that he’s relying on the advice of a relative outsider. The nation’s capital is infamously a town of straight-A students who hustled their way through the most elite schools and prestigious internships in pursuit of power. Duss took a more meandering path, playing in bands and working odd jobs for years before finishing college in his early 30s. He then spent the next decade influencing the public debate, mainly as a blogger, before finally emerging as a Senate staffer.

Duss is now gaining prominence at a pivotal moment for progressive foreign policy. Since the end of the Cold War, leading Democrats have broadly subscribed to the liberal-internationalist doctrine, with its emphasis on free-trade pacts, military coalitions to overthrow dictators and prevent atrocities, and, since 9/11, ruthless prosecution of the War on Terror; any differences with their Republican colleagues have often been more of degree than kind. Foreign-policy critics on the left, meanwhile, have generally been relegated to academia and the alternative media, and have focused mainly on challenging the excesses of empire, not on articulating a more positive and ambitious global vision.

More than most policy-makers, Duss is a product of that left-leaning tradition. His ascension was in many ways made possible by the political earthquake of 2016—not just Trump’s election, but the defeat of Hillary Clinton, the enduring influence of Sanders, and the emergence of a new generation of progressives who have grown up amid endless wars. The open question is whether Duss and others like him are capable of taking on the foreign-policy world’s entrenched status quo.

Duss was born in 1972 in the Hudson Valley town of Nyack, an hour north of Manhattan. His mother, a nurse, came from a family of truck drivers in rural western Pennsylvania; his father, a journalist and aid worker, was born in a displaced-persons camp in Germany after his family, some of whom had been kulak* in Ukraine, survived famine under Stalin and some of the worst carnage of World War II. When Duss’s father was 2, his family emigrated to the United States and settled in Brooklyn. Despite their very different origins, Duss’s father and mother shared an evangelical faith; they met while attending a missionary-training college in Nyack, where they eventually settled.

“We’re a family of refugees,” Duss tells me over brunch near his home in northern Virginia. “That’s always been part of my understanding of where we came from.” Because of his family history, Duss says, he never had any illusions about Soviet communism, but he does identify as a man of the left, a strong social democrat perfectly at home with Sanders’s political program.

Duss himself grew up in a tight-knit community of evangelical Christians. While he wrestled with his faith throughout his teens and early adulthood—he describes himself as pro-choice, pro–LGBTQ rights, and very liberal—the communitarian and humanitarian aspects of Christianity remain central to his life.

In 1983, his family relocated for a year to a refugee-processing center in the Philippines to work with a Christian NGO there. From age 10 to 11, Duss attended a Christian boarding school while helping refugees from Southeast Asia prepare for life in North America. He was in Manila at the time of the assassination of opposition politician Benigno Aquino, a critic of the US-aligned dictator Ferdinand Marcos. “It was an interesting vantage point for how the US was perceived elsewhere,” he says. “Obviously, I couldn’t fully understand or engage with the political conversation there—but still, it made an impression.”

Exposure to the wider world left Duss feeling more isolated from his peers back home. Once a promising student, in junior high he became disengaged from school, grappling with his religious upbringing and preferring music to homework. At 15, he took up guitar, his influences ranging from Van Halen to indie groups like the Replacements, the Pixies, and Dinosaur Jr. It was through playing in bands that he found his peer group, which included an Iraqi-American singer who helped personalize the first Gulf War for him. “I just was uncomfortable with America sending troops around the world,” Duss says.

After two and a half years at a small Christian college in Massachusetts, Duss found himself unmotivated and returned home to Nyack, where he worked in a variety of menial jobs while pursuing his true passions: playing guitar and writing fiction. In 1994, he moved to Seattle, where he met his wife, and where he first became involved in politics via anti-globalization activism and Ralph Nader’s 2000 presidential campaign.

Duss became fascinated with the Muslim world on a trip to Istanbul for a friend’s wedding in 2000. He found the experience of being awakened by the morning call to prayer transformative, and began reading obsessively about Islamic history and politics. The 9/11 attacks the following year left him frustrated and concerned about the way the US media portrayed Muslims and the Middle East, and for the first time in his life he felt a sense of political mission. At a time when many US policy-makers were encouraging open-ended war across the Muslim world, Duss dedicated himself to understanding the societies that would bear the brunt of such a policy.

In 2002, Duss transferred from community college to the University of Washington, where he finally earned his bachelor’s degree at 31 and his master’s at 34 while studying Arabic and raising a newborn. He wrote his thesis on Muqtada al-Sadr, the Shiite cleric who had become the political and spiritual leader of the insurgency against the US-led coalition occupying Iraq.

After finishing his academic work, Duss and his family moved back east and settled in Alexandria, Virginia. Duss quickly took to the Beltway blogosphere and started several websites, including one dedicated to monitoring the Islamophobic writings of Marty Peretz, then publisher of The New Republic. He began receiving wider recognition writing about the Middle East for The American Prospect. That eventually earned him a staff job at the Center for American Progress, where in early 2008 he became editor of the national-security team for the liberal think tank’s affiliated blog, ThinkProgress. “If TAP was like getting signed to Sub Pop,” says Duss, referring to the indie label that signed bands like Nirvana and Sleater-Kinney, “going to CAP was like a major label.”

“His success is an argument for all kinds of diversity in the foreign-policy community,” says Heather Hurlburt, a former State Department official during Bill Clinton’s presidency. “Perhaps ironically, it’s also a vindication of [CAP founder] John Podesta, of all people, whose early vision for the Center for American Progress was that it would hire and pay talented young people who didn’t come from super-privileged traditional backgrounds.”

At the same time that Duss was starting at CAP, Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton were engaged in a heated presidential primary. During a January 2008 debate, Obama contrasted his opposition to the Iraq War with Clinton’s initial support for it. “I don’t want to just end the war,” Obama said. “I want to end the mind-set that got us into war in the first place.” For Duss, this line “was like hearing [Jimi Hendrix’s] ‘Voodoo Child (Slight Return)’ for the first time. It’s like, ‘That is rock and roll.’”

“Matt has always been willing to challenge underlying assumptions about the conduct of American foreign policy,” says Ben Rhodes, one of Obama’s closest national-security advisers. “He rightly seized on President Obama’s statement…and he held us to that standard for eight years.”

The Obama administration often struggled to hold itself to that same standard. The idealism that appealed to Duss and many others produced some significant achievements, notably the Iran nuclear deal, the reestablishment of relations with Cuba, and the Paris climate accord. But Obama didn’t end US military operations in Iraq or Afghanistan, and he launched new, undeclared wars in several other countries in the Muslim world. He authorized record sums of military aid to Israel and Saudi Arabia despite the atrocities they committed in the Gaza Strip and Yemen. He championed the Arab Spring, then stood by the Gulf monarchies and the Egyptian military junta as they snuffed it out.

Obama’s foreign-policy record disappointed many activists and writers on the left. But inside the Beltway and among key Democratic institutions, it had plenty of defenders, including some who would clash directly with Duss once he’d entered the think-tank world.

Duss worked at CAP until 2014 and blogged prolifically for ThinkProgress, where he was an outspoken voice against military interventionism, a critic of Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian territories, and an advocate of diplomacy with Iran. He co-authored a report on Islamophobia in the world of conservative donor networks and think tanks, making his share of enemies in the process. He also helped identify and recruit like-minded writers to the site, including Ali Gharib (now an editor at The Intercept) and Eli Clifton (now a fellow at Type Media Center).

Initially, Duss had a significant degree of freedom to express his opinions at ThinkProgress, which he attributes to Podesta’s hands-off approach. Asked whether that approach continued for the entirety of his time at CAP, Duss says simply, “No, it didn’t.”

In 2011, the year that CAP’s current president, Neera Tanden, took over from Podesta, Duss’s team drew the ire of pro-Israel organizations and media outlets in Washington. Following an article in Politico by Ben Smith (now editor in chief of BuzzFeed News) spotlighting ThinkProgress’s critical coverage of Israel, Duss and several other CAP writers felt targeted. “The goal of that piece was definitely to start a campaign against us,” says Duss, who adds that he has no personal resentment toward Smith and respects much of his work. “It was clear he was working off of an opposition document that had been shopped to him that was later leaked.” Duss specifically calls out the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), The Washington Free Beacon, and some members of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies for coordinating a campaign against him and his colleagues.

“Reporters get information from all sorts of places, and from people with all sorts of motives,” Ben Smith says in response. “That was an accurate story about the differences on Israel inside a Democratic institution—a story that is obviously still playing out in the party.” In any case, Gharib and Clifton would voluntarily leave CAP after what Duss says was significant internal pressure that interfered with their work. Duss remained at the organization for three more years, essentially daring the higher-ups to fire him.

Faiz Shakir, who ran ThinkProgress at the time and hired all of the writers targeted by AIPAC, still speaks warmly of Duss. “Matt was advocating for the Iranian deal long before it was mainstreamed; he was also warning of the consequences of [Israel’s] settlement expansion long before the Obama administration tried to take a hard line on the issue,” says Shakir, now the ACLU’s national political director. “For his work, he obviously engendered opposition from powerful groups who didn’t want to see ideological movement on those issues.”

Tanden’s only comment for this profile was delivered via her communications director: “While at CAP, Matt Duss made important contributions to our national-security team, and he has done critical work since.”

While it’s clearly a sensitive subject for all parties involved, the tensions from the CAP incident presaged deeper divides within progressive policy circles. Tanden was an outspoken critic of Duss’s future boss Sanders during the 2016 Democratic primaries and remains so today. CAP’s acceptance of funds from the United Arab Emirates, which started during her tenure, was recently a source of significant internal turmoil, as was Tanden’s 2015 event with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, whereas Duss has vociferously criticized both the UAE and Israeli governments for years. His experience at CAP speaks to the limits of trying to challenge donors and policy-makers within powerful Democratic Party–aligned organizations—limits that Sanders will likely run into again if he seeks to reform foreign policy in a progressive direction.

In 2014, Duss left CAP to become president of the Foundation for Middle East Peace, a small nonprofit that provides grants to Israeli, Palestinian, and American civil-society groups. While at FMEP, Duss participated in working groups in coordination with Ben Rhodes to support the Obama administration’s nuclear deal with Iran, which faced significant opposition from hawks and pro-Israel groups in Congress.

Several times during Duss’s tenure at both CAP and FMEP, some neoconservative and pro-Israel critics accused him of anti-Semitism, a charge that he finds hurtful and absurd. A 2013 article in The Washington Free Beacon insinuated that Duss, his brother, and his father are all hostile to Jews, largely relying on their persistent criticism of the Israeli occupation as evidence. In 2015, a Republican congressman issued a press release accusing Duss and his family of “anti-Sematic [sic] ties,” again citing as evidence their criticism of the Israeli government. “Any fair reading of my work—and, frankly, my life—refutes that plainly,” Duss says.

Duss’s deep interest in the Israel-Palestine conflict is rooted in both his Christian upbringing and his humanitarian instincts. The first of his many visits to Israel and the occupied territories was in 2003, in the middle of the second intifada, while his brother was doing relief work there. “A bus had blown up in Jerusalem a week before, so the reality of terrorism is there; you have to recognize it,” Duss says. “But at the same time, watching the daily indignity and humiliation and violence that is visited on Palestinian civilians in multiple ways… there’s no justification for that.”

The public conversation about Israel has shifted in the past few years. Younger Jews on college campuses and elsewhere have become disenchanted with Israel and more critical of the occupation, and this has created more space in the media and in politics for views like Duss’s. The new Congress includes several Democrats who have endorsed the boycott, divestment, and sanctions movement, a position that many other Democrats not only oppose but are trying to make illegal. Neither Duss nor Sanders has endorsed boycotting Israel, but both have defended the right to engage in such boycotts, and in 2015 Duss testified before Congress that “it is a mistake to focus on the BDS movement while ignoring the main reason for its continued growth, which is the failure to end the occupation.” While some BDS activists may consider that a moderate position, no one has ever voiced it in the context of a presidential campaign.

During the 2016 Democratic primary contest between Clinton and Sanders, Duss bemoaned the absence of a real foreign-policy debate. At the time, many progressives were frustrated with Clinton’s reflexive hawkishness, on the one hand, and Sanders’s perceived lack of a serious interest in international affairs, on the other.

Had Clinton defeated Trump that fall, Duss expected to remain at FMEP and attempt to push the new administration toward a more progressive approach to the Middle East. Instead, mere weeks after Trump’s shocking victory, Duss met with Sanders in person and soon found himself working for the Vermont senator, taking a pay cut in order to directly shape policy on Capitol Hill. “He’s very much like he is in public, except funnier,” Duss says of Sanders, “and that’s how I immediately knew we could work together.”

While they come from very different backgrounds, Sanders and Duss share something important in common: At least by Washington standards, they both spent their 20s adrift. After graduating from the University of Chicago, where he was more interested in activism than in grades, Sanders moved to Vermont and worked as a carpenter while making radical film strips and writing for alternative publications. He didn’t win an election until he was 39, didn’t go to Washington for another decade after that, and has only emerged as a leading national figure in the past few years. Like Duss, Sanders has stubbornly held onto a set of core ideals and waited, at whatever cost to his career, for the national debate to shift his way. As Duss puts it, both men’s identities were fully formed outside the Beltway.

“People with Matt’s views don’t always work within the US government, so I was glad he took on his current role as an adviser for Bernie,” Ben Rhodes says. “It’s good for the Senate to have a progressive activist in that role, and it’s good for someone like Matt to learn how to navigate the complexity of being a Senate staffer.” Rhodes, who rocketed to international influence at 29 on the basis of his “mind meld” with Obama, is the most obvious example of the kind of role that Duss might be expected to play in a Sanders administration. Rhodes was also a critic of the US foreign-policy establishment, which he dubbed “the Blob,” and its interventionist consensus—and during his time in the White House, he made many of the same enemies that Duss has.

RELATED ARTICLE -- The Nation
WASHINGTON TRAINED GUATEMALA’S KILLERS FOR DECADES
Greg Grandin and Elizabeth Oglesby

In the lead-up to the 2020 Democratic primaries, a number of the expected major contenders have tacked left on the domestic-policy issues that Sanders staked out in 2016. But no one has indicated as clearly as Sanders that there needs to be a break with the foreign-policy consensus that Clinton embodied and would have reinforced. No one besides Sanders has hired an adviser with such a clear track record of defying the Blob. But while foreign policy could be an issue that attracts activists to Sanders, it will also likely inspire attacks, especially with regard to Israel. In fact, Ann Lewis, a pro-Israel Democratic operative who pressured CAP over Duss and his cohort in 2012, now co-chairs a well-funded new organization, the Democratic Majority for Israel, dedicated to countering the growing criticism of Israel among progressives.

Then again, the world has changed a lot in the past decade, and some Democrats are optimistic about ending the status quo. “Matt represents a real break from interventionist thinking,” says Ro Khanna, “and it’s why foreign policy is going to be an advantage for Bernie Sanders if he runs. Last time, they said he was naive on foreign policy. This time, he’s responsible for the biggest foreign-policy success of the past few years, with the Yemen vote. And I would give a lot of credit to Matt Duss.”

Duss himself is insistently modest, refusing to claim any special credit for Sanders’s perceived new outspokenness. He compares his boss to the legendary jazz trumpeter Miles Davis. “One of Miles’s real geniuses was as a band leader, assembling the best players of the moment and getting them to play better than they ever had before—and in many cases than they ever would again,” Duss says. “This is the best band I’ve ever played in.”

David KlionTWITTERDavid Klion is a writer and editor in Brooklyn whose work has appeared in The Nation, The New York Times, The Guardian, Jewish Currents, and other publications.


[Stolypin reform -- http://www.economywatch.com/agrarian/stolypin.html
Stolypin Reform
APRIL 21, 2010• AGRARIAN REFORM• BY ECONOMYWATCH


The Stolypin Reform (1906-17) is one of the well-known agrarian land reform programs, which brought immense, revolutionary changes in the agricultural sector of Imperial Russia, affecting both the agricultural productivities and the lives of the native farmers. The Stolypin Reform was the brain-child of the Chairman of the Russian Council of Ministers, Pyotr Stolypin. Implemented during the tenure of Pyotr Stolypin, the Stolypin Reform was born out of the recommendations of the "The Needs of Agricultural Industry Special Conference", held in Russia during 1901-1903. However, most of the benefits offered by the Stolypin Reform were implemented by the 1920 Soviet agrarian reform programs.

Objectives of the Stolypin Reform:
Stolypin Reform was introduced, for bringing about differences in the agricultural activities of Russia. It was therefore, guided by the following goals:

The Stolypin Reform initiated a metamorphosis of the "Archaic Obshchina" form of agriculture in Russia. This enabled the Russian imperialism to trap the Russian farmers and scrap them out of their independence they enjoyed as a result of various emancipation reform programs in 1861. The reasons why "Archaic Obshchina" required transformation was that it emphasized more on aggregate land ownerships, repressing control on the lands by the elder members of a family and dispersed allotment of lands depending on size of the families involved.

Being a firm believer of conservative ides and views, Pyotr Stolypin's aim in initiating the Stolypin Reform was the complete eradication of the existing commune system known as the Mir. The reform also attempted to banish the emancipation enjoyed by the Russian peasants so far, to prevent the emergence of further causes of peasant revolution, like the one in 1905. The primary aim of all these imposed restrictions was to tie the farmers to their own private pieces of land. It also tried to make the farmer class loyal to the then Russian Tsar rulers.

Implementation of the Stolypin Reform:
Implementation of the Stolypin Agrarian Reforms started with the introduction of Ukase or the unconditional right of individual landownership on 9th November 1906, The immediate aim of this reform was to get rid of the "Archaic Obshchina" agricultural system, replacing it with a more capitalist-oriented, advanced form of agriculture, with special emphasis on modern and strengthened farm places and private land ownership.”]


[KULAKS* --
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kulak --

The kulaks (/ˈkuːlæk/; Russian: кула́к, tr. kulak, IPA: [kʊˈlak] (About this soundlisten), plural кулаки́, "fist", by extension "tight-fisted"; kurkuli in Ukraine, but also used in Russian texts in Ukrainian contexts) were a category of affluent peasants in the later Russian Empire, Soviet Russia and the early Soviet Union. The word kulak originally referred to independent farmers in the Russian Empire who emerged from the peasantry and became wealthy following the Stolypin reform, which began in 1906. The label of kulak was broadened in 1918 to include any peasant who resisted handing over their grain to detachments from Moscow.[1] During 1929–1933, Joseph Stalin's leadership of the total campaign to collectivize the peasantry meant that "peasants with a couple of cows or five or six acres more than their neighbors" were labeled "kulaks".[2]

According to the political theory of Marxism–Leninism of the early 20th century, the kulaks were class enemies of the poorer peasants.[3] Vladimir Lenin described them as "bloodsuckers, vampires, plunderers of the people and profiteers, who fatten on famine".[4][5] Marxism–Leninism had intended a revolution to liberate poor peasants and farm laborers alongside the proletariat (urban and industrial workers). In addition, the command economy of Soviet Bolshevism required the collectivization of farms and land to allow industrialization or conversion to large-scale agricultural production. In practice, government officials violently seized kulak farms and killed resisters[3][6] while others were deported to labor camps. Another result of dekulakization was the mass migration of these "class enemies" from the countryside to the cities[7] following the loss of their property as it was turned over to the collective as part of the collectivization campaign.]


PROTECTIONS FOR THE QUEEN – THIS LOOKS AS THOUGH TIMES ARE GETTING MORE DANGEROUS NOW. I HOPE THE TURMOIL OF THIS PERIOD WILL JUST PASS THROUGH THE DIFFICULTIES INTO A BETTER WORLD. THIS MOVE ON BRITAIN'S PART, OF COURSE, IS PROBABLY JUST PRECAUTIONARY THINKING, LIKE THE US CONGRESS TAKING BACK ITS’ RIGHT AND ABILITY TO STOP WAR BY REFUSING TO FINANCE IT, EVEN IF PRESIDENT TRUMP DOES START ONE.
[SEE: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/world/2018/12/13/donald-trump-senate-votes-end-u-s-support-yemen-war-jamal-khashoggi/2296155002/.]

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/feb/03/queen-to-be-evacuated-if-brexit-turns-ugly-reports
Queen to be evacuated if Brexit turns ugly – reports
Cold war plans revived to move royals to safe locations away from London if unrest follows no deal
PHOTOGRAPH -- Queen Elizabeth and members of the royal family could be evacuated from London in the event of unrest following a no-deal Brexit. Photograph: Alastair Grant/AP Reuters
Sat 2 Feb 2019 21.07 EST

British officials have revived cold war emergency plans to relocate the royal family should there be riots in London if Britain suffers a disruptive departure from the European Union, two Sunday newspapers have reported.

“These emergency evacuation plans have been in existence since the cold war but have now been repurposed in the event of civil disorder following a no-deal Brexit,” the Sunday Times said, quoting an unnamed source from the government’s Cabinet Office, which handles sensitive administrative issues.

The Mail on Sunday also said it had learnt of plans to move the royal family, including Queen Elizabeth, to safe locations away from London.

RELATED -- Voters will never forgive Tories for a no-deal disaster, says minister

In January an annual speech by the Queen, 92, to a women’s group was widely interpreted in Britain as a call for politicians to reach agreement over Brexit.

Jacob Rees-Mogg, a Conservative MP and keen supporter of Brexit, told the Mail on Sunday he believed the plans showed unnecessary panic by officials over a no-deal Brexit as senior royals had remained in London during bombing in the second world war.

But the Sunday Times said an ex-police officer formerly in charge of royal protection, Dai Davies, expected Queen Elizabeth would be moved out of London if there was unrest. “If there were problems in London, clearly you would remove the royal family away from those key sites,” Davies was quoted as saying.



Tuesday, February 5, 2019




ST. LOUIS BLUES
COMPILATION AND COMMENTARY
BY LUCY WARNER
FEBRUARY 5, 2019

ST. LOUIS POLICE HAVE HAD SERIOUS PROBLEMS WITH THEIR OFFICERS, SEVERAL TIMES IN THE LAST TWO OR THREE YEARS AT LEAST, SINCE I’VE BEEN PRESENTING NEWS STORIES AND TRENDS. DOES THE DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE NEED TO INTERVENE AND FORCE THEM TO IDENTIFY THEIR PROBLEMS AND MAKE CHANGES? OF COURSE, ERIC HOLDER DID AN EXEMPLARY JOB WITH THAT IN MY VIEW, BUT HE IS GONE, GONE, GONE. I DON’T HAVE THAT FAITH IN THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION LEADERS.

THE SECOND STORY IS FROM MCALLEN TEXAS, THOUGH IT IS ALL TOO SIMILAR TO ST LOUIS PROBLEMS, AND THERE’S A LOONEY TUNES TOUCH TO BOTH STORIES.

https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2019/02/russian-roulette-st-louis-police-shooting-bizarre-tragic.html
The Fatal “Russian Roulette” Shooting of a St. Louis Police Officer Keeps Getting More Bizarre
The “Russian Roulette” Shooting of One St. Louis Police Officer By Another Keeps Getting More Bizarre
By AARON MAK
FEB 01, 2019 2:51 PM

PHOTOGRAPH -- An St. [sic] Louis officer died during an alleged game of Russian Roulette.
Michael B. Thomas/Getty Images

At about 1:00 a.m. on Jan. 24, two on-duty officers from the St. Louis Police Department rushed a third, off-duty officer named Katlyn Alix to a hospital. Alix, a 24-year-old military veteran who had worked at the department for two years, soon died from the gunshot wound in her chest.

“What’s going on is that two on-duty officers went by one of their homes,” police chief John Hayden said at a press conference a few hours later. “They were on duty. While they were at that particular home, an off-duty female officer came to that home. While they were there at that home there was, what we understand to be, an accidental discharge. The female off-duty officer was shot in the chest and she was brought to the hospital by those officers. Upon arrival shortly thereafter, she was pronounced deceased.”

The unusual nature of Alix’s death immediately attracted media attention, and subsequent developments have only heightened the scrutiny on the case. Initial reports indicated that the firearm was not a service weapon, and that the on-duty officers were miles away from the district they were supposed to be patrolling. Over the past week, the details that have emerged underscored the senselessness of the incident and raised new questions about exactly what happened that day.

A day after the shooting, the St. Louis Circuit Attorney’s Office charged 29-year-old Nathaniel Hendren with involuntary manslaughter. The office released a probable cause statement from the police department, which revealed that the three officers had congregated at Hendren’s apartment. At some point, Alix and Hendren had reportedly been playing with guns, and Hendren produced a revolver. “The defendant emptied the cylinder of the revolver and then put one cartridge back into the cylinder.”

Hendren allegedly spun the cylinder, a routine often associated with Russian Roulette, and aimed the gun away. The gun did not fire when he pulled the trigger. According to the police statement, Alix allegedly then took the gun and aimed it at Hendren. It again did not fire when she pulled the trigger. Hendren allegedly took the gun back, aimed it at Alix, and accidentally shot her in the chest. The third officer, Patrick Riordan, told investigators that he admonished Alix and Hendren for fooling around with the revolver and was about to leave when it was discharged.

Hendren was booked on Monday and held on a $50,000 cash-only bond, which was subsequently raised to $100,000. In his mugshot, his left eye and forehead appeared to be bruised. Sources familiar with the situation later told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch that he had headbutted the back window of a police vehicle while at the hospital and sustained minor injuries.

On Thursday, local outlet KMOV4 published an internal police misconduct report indicating that the three officers had been consuming alcohol on the night of the shooting. A lieutenant with the police department filed the complaint about 20 minutes after Alix’s death suggesting that Hendren and Riordan had violated an administrative regulation that dictates, “No employee shall report for duty or remain on duty with an alcohol concentration of 0.04 or greater. Moreover, no employee shall consume alcohol while on duty and/or engaged in City business.” Riordan’s attorney claims that his client only had a few sips of beer and poured the rest down the sink and that he blew a 0.0 on a breathalyzer test.

However, the breathalyzer has ignited further controversy in this case. The St. Louis Circuit Attorney’s Office sent a letter to the police department questioning why blood tests had not been performed on the two officers, which would give a more accurate reading of their level of intoxication. The letter indicated that the St. Louis University Hospital did not honor a search warrant for a blood test. The attorney’s office wrote that the fact that only urine and breathalyzer tests were performed “appears as an obstructionist tactic to prevent us from understanding the state of the officers during the commission of this alleged crime.” The police department’s public safety director, Jimmie Edwards, said in a press conference, “Our officers are not obstructionist.”

Medical examiners have performed an autopsy on Alix, but they will not release the report until the results of a toxicology test are complete. Hendren has been suspended without pay, while Riordan is on paid leave. Hayden, the police chief, told reporters that the department’s laptops are currently being upgraded so that supervisors can use GPS and radio to ensure that officers remain in their assigned patrol locations.


WHEN POLICE BEHAVIOR IS EXPOSED, LOOK AT THE EXCUSES SOME OF THE “GOOD PEOPLE” MADE FOR THEIR ACTIONS. SOME OTHERS, THOUGH, ARE ON THE RIGHT TRACK. THE FICTION THAT POLICE VIOLENCE IS OKAY, JUST BECAUSE THEY ARE THE POLICE IS A SICKNESS THAT OUR SOCIETY CARRIES IN IT FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION. I HAVE A LITTLE HOPE THESE LAST TEN YEARS OR SO THAT WE MAY BE MAKING PROGRESS. THE MCKINNEY STORY, THOUGH, IS REGRESSIVE. ONE STEP FORWARD, TWO STEPS BACK.

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2018/07/after-the-police-brutality-video-goes-viral/564863/
After the Police Brutality Video Goes Viral
Three years after a pool-party video made McKinney, Texas, infamous, I returned to find suburbanites who feel threatened, a mayor and activists at odds, and socioeconomic divisions that persist.
OLGA KHAZAN
JUL 23, 2018

PHOTO ENSEMBLE -- YOUTUBE / PHOTKA / FOCUSSTOCKER / SHUTTERSTOCK / BY KATIE MARTIN / THE ATLANTIC

McKINNEY, Texas—When I approached a small house in the Craig Ranch neighborhood here on a steamy day in early June, an angry, white man stormed out. He only grew more irate throughout our conversation. Three years ago, he was getting death threats, he said: messages saying his daughter would be raped or his son hanged. Texas Rangers were opening suspicious packages on his lawn. Friends of his said they saw pictures of his kids with targets on their faces posted online. He didn’t want it to happen again. He refused to give me his name, citing the fear of more threats, as did almost all the town residents I spoke with for this story.

I’m from McKinney, a Dallas suburb that a 2015 viral video made temporarily famous, because it showed a white police officer manhandling an unarmed black teenager in a swimsuit in front of a Craig Ranch neighborhood pool. Before I began knocking on doors, I was worried about how residents would react to my desire to revisit the ordeal. My fears were justified.

The man’s wife emerged from the house too, then burst into tears when I began asking questions. The couple told me there is an organized movement by groups like Black Lives Matter and the hacker collective Anonymous to paint the community as racist. That couldn’t be more wrong, the man said.

McKinney, Texas, and the Racial History of American Swimming Pools
YONI APPELBAUM

His wife went inside, weeping. “Stay strong!” the man yelled after her.

The events depicted in the McKinney video are reminiscent of similar episodes in the past few years, in which white people have called police on black people engaged in relatively minor infractions—or no infraction at all—as well as incidents in which encounters between people of color and police officers have deteriorated into violence. Last month, for example, a white woman was filmed calling the police on a black girl who was “illegally” selling water on a San Francisco sidewalk. In another case, in San Francisco, a white woman called the police on two black men using a charcoal grill in a technically non-charcoal-grill-area of a park. A black student at Yale was awoken by police after another student called the campus cops on her for taking a nap in a common room. Many officers who use force excessively don’t face consequences: A former South Carolina sheriff’s deputy faced no charges in 2016 for grabbing a black student and dragging her across the floor.

The McKinney incident represents a common quandary in parsing these viral racial flashpoints: When does something hint at a broader societal problem, and when is it just the malicious action of one individual? What I found is that some people here see the incident as an isolated moment of police brutality that had nothing to do with race, while others see it as a symptom of a community riven by deep divides along racial and economic lines.

My parents moved to McKinney, which is about an hour north of Dallas, in the early 2000s in search of cheap real estate, good schools, and proximity to well-paying jobs. McKinney is the kind of place that aggressively believes in the American dream: “Faith is the postage stamp on our prayers!” proclaimed one of the many church signs near my parents’ house on a recent weekend. That vision apparently resonated even with my jaded immigrant father.

We bought the biggest house we’d ever lived in for $139,000. Our neighborhood, like Craig Ranch, was on the west side of Highway 75, which bisects McKinney. The west has long been referred to as the “new” side, the “good” side, and sometimes the “white” side.

Builders have carved up the west side into sylvan subdivisions with names like Hidden Creek and Eldorado Lakes. The west-side neighborhoods are full of tidy lawns and brick homes. To combat the triple-digit heat that engulfs North Texas for much of the summer, they have swimming pools that are accessible only to residents.

On the east side, some homes are new or remodeled, but others are patched with plywood and corrugated metal. Eighty-six percent of the west side was white in 2009, when the city was forced to settle an affordable-housing lawsuit, compared with 49 percent of the east. The lawsuit claimed that all of the town’s public housing and most of the landlords willing to take Section 8 vouchers were on the east side. The east side has vape-supply stores, payday lenders, and bail bondsmen. The west side has a store called Nothing Bundt Cakes.

In 2014, Money magazine named McKinney the No. 1 place to live in America, topping the article with a picture of mothers strolling around Towne Lake, the local park.

The following year brought “the incident,” as it’s known on Wikipedia. A summer-Friday teen party was, according to reports from conservative media, advertised on Twitter as a “Dime Piece Cookout,” in a park across from a pool in Craig Ranch. The “dime piece” descriptor—slang for a woman who is a “perfect 10”—has, among some here, contributed to the sense that the teens were up to no good.

Tatyana Rhodes, the young woman who reportedly organized the party, and her mother, lived in Craig Ranch. (Rhodes did not respond to requests for comment.) It’s not clear how many of the teens involved in the incident lived on the east side, but some of the attendees did not live in Craig Ranch. Residents told me that the partygoers played loud rap music with lewd lyrics.

Several teenagers said at the time that someone in the neighborhood told the group of mostly black kids to “go back to your Section 8 housing,” and Rhodes said that she was slapped by an adult woman. (The woman later denied this.)

Before long, the teens roamed over to the nearby pool, which has a guarded gate and limits residents to a maximum of two guests—and absolutely no blowout parties. Finding themselves thus limited, the teens began hopping a fence to get to the pool. Several people called the police, first saying the teens were simply trespassing, then complaining that some were “throwing stuff at cars” and fighting.

When one of the police officers, Eric Casebolt, arrived at the scene, he detained several black boys and drew his gun on one man. He then wrestled a black girl to the ground, shoved her face into the grass, and sat on her back as she wailed for help.

An image of Casebolt pointing into a phone camera soon shot around the globe. A large white man atop a crying black girl: A more perfect snapshot of racial oppression would be hard to dream up. (Casebolt declined interview requests, as did Shashona Becton, the guardian of Dajerria Becton, the girl who was tackled by Casebolt.) The video was viewed more than 12 million times on YouTube. Katy Perry tweeted about it and Jon Stewart mocked it.

Casebolt resigned soon after, and a few weeks ago Dajerria Becton received $148,850 in a settlement. Now Craig Ranch residents just want the incident to go away, while some local activists intend to keep it—and the rifts it exposed—in the spotlight.

When I lived in McKinney 15 years ago, I encountered some of the kindest people I’ve ever met and some of the most prejudiced attitudes I’ve ever heard. In my yearbook, which had been graciously subsidized by my journalism teachers, a student wrote, “If you can ever make it on the ballot to run for president, I’ll vote for you. Unless it’s against Arnold Schwarzenegger, or a man.” At a high-school job, a co-worker of mine liked to show me pictures of her family’s cows, the black one of which was named the N-word. She served as a foster mom to several needy children.

Since then, McKinney has doubled in size, to 170,000 people, and the growing population has infused the town with new ideas. In 2014, my old high school had a lesbian homecoming queen. Hillary Clinton won 39 percent of the vote here in 2016, compared with the 24 percent Al Gore won in 2000. Like so many other booming towns, it contains both victories and sorrows. In the week I spent here recently, one McKinney boy won the National Spelling Bee and another shot himself to death in an empty high-school classroom. As Dominique Alexander, a leader of the Next Generation Action Network, a civil-rights group in the Dallas area, put it to me, “It’s a beautiful city, but it has its pains.”

In the aftermath of the incident, home values in the neighborhood dropped for a time. Craig Ranch residents felt that they were unfairly portrayed as racists living in an overwhelmingly white, affluent community. (According to census data, the median household income of the tract containing Craig Ranch is $105,000—higher than that of the county as a whole—and the tract is majority white.) Three days after the incident, Alexander and his group led a peaceful march through Craig Ranch, which some white residents interpreted as a sign that he was blaming them, rather than Casebolt alone. Several people I spoke with were incensed that activists were planning an upcoming pool party—at a public pool, this time—to mark the anniversary of the incident.

Most of the Craig Ranch residents who answered their doors either closed them when I introduced myself or politely declined to talk. “It’s in the past; I don’t want to reopen old wounds,” one man said. Another called it a “nonstory.” One couple gleefully told me that they’d gotten their house because all the other offers pulled out after the incident. One woman opened the door just to say that a real injustice had been done that day—to the police department.

Among those who did talk, the thinking seemed to be that Casebolt had lashed out at the kids not because they were black or poor but because the homeowners’ association forbade what they were doing. “I’m not saying I condone what occurred,” one Hispanic resident said. “But [Dajerria Becton] was told numerous times to leave the area. The teens were being disrespectful, and creating chaos when there didn’t need to be chaos.”

A man who identified himself only as Chris said that there was blame on both sides. “The cop overreacted, but the party was illegal,” he said. “They provoked him, and he got provoked.”

In the end, he said, “it made everyone look bad.”

The incident was perhaps especially incendiary because it involved a swimming pool: Pools have historically been the sites of major feuds over race, income, and access. As my colleague Yoni Appelbaum wrote in the wake of the McKinney incident, in the early 20th century, public pools were plentiful—but segregated. As civil-rights activists pushed to desegregate them, many cities privatized the facilities rather than be forced to integrate them. Private and exclusive pools became more common; public ones, less so. “Suburbanites organized private club pools rather than fund public pools because club pools enabled them to control the class and racial composition of swimmers, whereas public pools did not,” the historian Jeff Wiltse noted in his 2007 book, Contested Waters: A Social History of Swimming Pools in America.

Many of the homes on McKinney’s east side were built before homeowners’ associations began incorporating gated pools into their developments. People in McKinney who don’t belong to homeowners’ associations can use the city’s public swimming pools. There are four, and rather than operating on homeowners’-association dues, they charge a fee for admission. The newest pool, at a facility called the Apex Center, features water slides and costs $10 a person for a day pass. (It’s on the west side.) If Rhodes had wanted to host her party legally, she would have had to rent one of these pools. For up to 200 guests, the cost is $110 to $800 for two hours, depending on the pool.

“Craig Ranch is a multimillion-dollar development,” said Henry Moore, a pastor at Saint Mark Baptist Church, an old black church on the east side, whom I spoke with one Sunday last month before services began. “On the east side, there is no Craig Ranch multimillion-dollar development. So there will be nicer things on the west side than there are on the east side.”

When the socioeconomic divide in a town is so stark, the line between feeling unwanted because you’re not from the neighborhood and feeling unwanted because of your race can start to blur. “Are you saying I'm not supposed to be here because I don't live here?” Moore continued, speculating on the mind-set of some of the teens that day. “But I was invited.”

Those tensions might be exacerbated by residential segregation. The Inclusive Communities Project, a Dallas-based housing nonprofit, approached McKinney a decade ago to discuss building housing for lower-income families on the west side. It was only after McKinney settled a lawsuit with the Inclusive Communities Project that two low-income apartment complexes were built west of Highway 75, something west-side residents vocally opposed.

“I’ve seen what Section 8 housing does to property values, and I’ve also seen what Section 8 housing does to the schools,” said one man during a city-council meeting in 2014. “Section 8 housing … brings with it the history of drugs, gangs, and lawlessness, and a lot of police activity,” another man said. (Roslyn Miller, the director of the McKinney Housing Authority, said at the time that in her 10 years with the agency, there had been just one homicide in a public-housing or affordable-housing unit. How low-income housing is incorporated into a community is a factor, but such a program generally doesn’t appear to affect crime rates or property values.)

Demetria McCain, the president of the Inclusive Communities Project, told me McKinney is not unique in resisting affordable housing. Income segregation has increased around the country in recent decades: Nationally, in 1970 just 15 percent of families lived in neighborhoods considered either “affluent” or “poor,” but by 2007, 31 percent of families did. All around the Dallas area, homeowners’ associations have prevented homeowners from renting to holders of affordable-housing vouchers, and they have questioned renters’ right to use a homeowners’-association pool, McCain told me. She sent me a webpage from a council candidate in Wylie, which is not far from McKinney, who promised not to approve affordable-housing developments in the city. In a survey of 1,901 market-rate* properties in Collin County, which contains McKinney, and neighboring counties last year, Inclusive Communities found that only 12 percent were willing to rent to families with a Housing Choice Voucher, which is part of a program aimed at the very poor. In McKinney, more than 90 percent of the properties refused to rent to voucher holders, according to the survey. In the greater Dallas area, the voucher recipients are predominantly black.

“I didn’t expect the [pool-party] incident to create any big, positive change,” McCain told me recently. “And I don’t think it has.”

Opening up west McKinney to lower-income families, who are often people of color, might improve racial relations in town, McCain offered. Usually, she noted, opposition to affordable housing dies down after the renters move in. “Maybe if we live together more,” she said, “people who are afraid of us might get to know us as people.”

“I'm not going to say the mayor is racist, but he is certainly singing the tune,” Kim T. Cole, Dajerria Becton’s lawyer, told The Dallas Morning News in May.

This was after Cole and Dominique Alexander, the activist, got into a heated exchange at a press conference with McKinney’s mayor, a local builder named George Fuller. In an email to Alexander covered by the News, Fuller called Eric Casebolt "a reckless, overly stimulated, excessive force wielding cop,” but also referred to "a verbally abusive, disobedient girl" at the pool party.

"For this mayor to come out today and say that this girl was verbally abusive to this officer as if this justifies his behavior is ridiculous," Cole said at the time.

Fuller, though, stuck by that description of Becton and the other teens in an interview in his office recently. “The officer used force that was not necessary in that situation. Absolutely,” he told me. “But [police] were called not because there were black people in the pool. They came ... because there were people trespassing, destroying property, and smoking dope.” (Fuller said the residents who called the police saw the teens smoking pot. The teens have denied that they were using drugs or alcohol, and neither the 911 calls from the pool itself nor the police reports make mention of drugs.)

A few weeks ago, Cole held a pool party at the Apex Center to mark the third anniversary of the incident, telling reporters that she wanted to give McKinney kids “the pool party they didn’t have.” According to the News, Becton and the other teens involved in the settlement did not attend.

“I'm not a fan of this anniversary celebration,” Fuller told me. “What are we celebrating? Are we celebrating the trespassing of the pool? Are we celebrating the excessive force of a police officer? Are we celebrating the accusation of this racial bias and discrimination on McKinney, Texas, that was not the case?”

Fuller also said he thought the incident wasn’t racial—and wasn’t reflective of the city. Fuller, who is white and has an adopted black daughter, said he doesn’t see much racial tension in the city. A black city-council member recently alleged that police treated him unfairly during a traffic stop, but after a review of body-cam footage, the council member said he had been partly at fault and apologized. Of course racial discrimination exists, Fuller said, but it exists in the world, not only in McKinney.

Fuller said the city has made progress on policing since the incident. The police department has body cameras now, and officers have been patrolling neighborhoods on the east side by bike and on foot in order to build rapport with the community. The police meet with community members at events like Tacos With Cops and Coffee With Cops.

The mayor is done engaging with Alexander, the activist, who Fuller says threatened him inappropriately during a council hearing. He and other critics of Alexander point out his checkered legal past. Alexander, to him, is a “fame junkie looking to stay relevant” and “a clown that belongs in the circus.”

Alexander admits that he threatened to release information about council members’ conflicts of interest to the media, but says he doesn’t feel that was inappropriate. He told me that he has learned from his legal troubles, and he denied that he seeks fame.

He said the city hasn’t done nearly enough to address residential segregation and discriminatory policing. He’d like to see even more community meetings, along with an equity study of McKinney. “Back in 2015, I made an oath that I will continue to fight to address this issue,” he told me, “so that McKinney can live up to what it always brags about, which is that it’s the best place to live in America.”

Before I left McKinney, I went through the guarded gates of the pool from the video to talk with families as they watched their kids splash around.

“Why are you even here?” a white man in a baseball cap said when I introduced myself. He said he doesn’t trust the media much and feels that these days, people are hated just for voting for Trump.

“The cop was rough with a girl, he was amped Up*, it was a ruckus—but that girl went from punk to victim,” he said. He gazed out over the turquoise water, the fountains, the manicured park beyond. Black Lives Matter—a terrorist organization, in his view—was portraying the community in a bad light. Alexander, to him, was a “race baiter.” “I work my ass off to get what I have, and we’re gonna call you racist? That’s a candy-ass* argument,” he muttered.

[HAVING JUST LOOKED THAT TERM CANDY-ASS UP – I HAVE FOUND ANOTHER NEW MEANING. I COULD TELL IT WAS A VULGAR INSULT, BUT NOW I KNOW WHAT IT TRANSLATES INTO: “WUSS, WIMP, OR WORSE, “PUSSY.” SO DON’T EVER CALL ANYBODY THAT!] [AND AS FOR “AMPED UP,” IT MEANS INTENSELY OR OVERLY EXCITED RATHER THAN HIGH ON DRUGS.]

A white woman sitting nearby chimed in to say that if her son’s school were predominantly black, she doubted her family would be accepted.

If unrest comes their way, the man in the baseball cap said, “there are citizens who are armed and are not gonna put up with that.”

I walked around the pool toward another white couple playing with their kids in the water. They gave me fake names because they were worried about their jobs. “This is the most diverse neighborhood we’ve ever lived in,” the man said, paddling away from me slowly. The incident says nothing about the neighborhood, he added.

On this, he, McCain, and almost everyone I talked with seemed to agree: The incident is not unique to McKinney. It could have happened anywhere.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.

OLGA KHAZAN is a staff writer at The Atlantic.


MARKET-RATE* --
https://www.thespruce.com/market-rate-apartment-155986

THIS ESSENTIALLY MEANS THAT THERE ARE NO EXTERNAL RESTRICTIONS ON THE RENTS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD. IN OTHER WORDS, IT IS NOT “RENT CONTROLLED” TO KEEP THE PRICE DOWN, NOR RESTRICTED TO KEEP SUBSIDIZED HOUSING RECIPIENTS OUT, SUCH AS “VOUCHER HOLDERS.” THE FIRST WOULD ALLOW “THE WORKING POOR” TO LIVE THERE ON THEIR BUDGET, AND THE SECOND WOULD KEEP THE VERY POOR OUT – WHICH OFTEN MEANS A RACIAL OR ETHNICITY BARRIER. IT’S JUST ANOTHER FILTER TO KEEP THE RACES APART, AND TO KEEP THE HOITY TOITY FROM HAVING TO LIVE WITH “HOI POLLOI.” THAT PHRASE MEANS SPECIFICALLY, “THE PEOPLE,” OR “THE MASSES.” GO TO HTTPS://WWW.MERRIAM-WEBSTER.COM/DICTIONARY/HOITY-TOITY. HOITY TOITY IS AN INCORRECT SPELLING AND PRONUNCIATION OF “HÔƏDĒˈTOIDĒ,” WHICH WEBSTER DEFINES AS “SNOBBISH,” ELITIST, AND A STRING OF OTHER UNPLEASANT TERMS.

SEE HTTPS://EN.WIKIPEDIA.ORG/WIKI/HOI_POLLOI FOR TWO MORE DEFINITIONS RELATED TO THAT WORD. IF TAKEN FROM PERICLES WHO WAS A DEMOCRATIC SOUL, IT WAS USED TO IMPLY A POSITIVE CONNOTATION, IT MEANT “THE PEOPLE,” [YES, KARL MARX DIDN’T MAKE THAT UP] HIS PREFERENCE BEING FOR THE ATHENIAN DEMOCRACY AND NOT THE PRIVILEGED CLASS, OR “HOI OLIGOI,” WHICH TRANSLATES AS "THE FEW." THAT WORD IS RECOGNIZABLE IN THE TERM “OLIGARCHY.”

THIS PROBABLY ACCOUNTS FOR THE FACT THAT I HAVE HEARD PEOPLE USE THE PHRASE HOI POLLOI TO MEAN BOTH INTERPRETATIONS, GOOD AND BAD. SINCE ALMOST NOBODY STUDIES GREEK ANYMORE, IT HAS BECOME AN OFTEN-MISUSED PHRASE, AND A LOGICAL ERROR; ALSO, ANYONE WHO GOES AROUND SPEAKING CLASSICAL GREEK THESE DAYS IN AMERICA IS ALMOST CERTAINLY A SOCIAL CLIMBER, OR INSANE, SO I SUGGEST YOU DON’T DO IT. I PREFER TO USE “THE MASSES” OR “THE PEOPLE” EITHER ONE MAKES ME SOUND LIKE A LIBERAL DEMOCRAT, AND THAT’S JUST GREAT. TO ME, WITHOUT A MIXTURE OF PEOPLES AND IDEAS, THINGS TO SEE AND DO, IT ISN’T A REAL “CITY.” MY CITY WAS WASHINGTON, DC., AND MY NEIGHBORHOOD WAS DUPONT CIRCLE.


OTHER ST. LOUIS PD PROBLEMS

THIS IS THE FIRST TIME I’VE SEEN THE PSYCHOLOGICAL PROBLEM THAT TOO MANY OF THESE COPS HAVE BEING CALLED WHAT IT ACTUALLY IS, EXCEPT BY ME SOMETIMES. WE SAY, DIRTY COPS, POLICE BRUTALITY, RACIST COPS, CORRUPT COPS AND IT IS ALL OF THOSE THINGS, BUT THE MENTAL DISEASE IS SADISM. WE, WHO DON’T SEE OURSELVES AS BEING SADISTIC, NEED TO AGITATE AGAINST THE CORRUPT POLICE DEPARTMENT HEADS AND MAYORS AND OTHERS IN AUTHORITY WHO ARE SUPPOSED TO HIRE DECENT PEOPLE TO BEGIN WITH, TRAIN THEM TO DO THEIR JOB WITHOUT ALL OF THAT POINTLESS FEROCITY, SO THAT THEY CAN BE THE HEROIC BEINGS THAT WE CLAIM THEY ARE. AS LONG AS OUR SOCIETY IS CALLOUS AND GREEDY, HOWEVER, WE WON’T DO THAT. WE AS INDIVIDUALS NEED TO MAKE OUR INNER BEING MORE INTELLIGENT AND MERCIFUL. THAT’S THE ONLY WAY OUR CULTURE CAN HAVE THOSE VIRTUES. A GROUP IS A COLLECTION OF INDIVIDUALS, AND IF WE WORK AT IT FROM THAT ANGLE, WE CAN MAKE CHANGES.

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/12/st-louis-police-brutality-stockley/577174/
IDEAS
Sadism in the St. Louis Police Department
Three cops who expressed an eagerness to brutalize protesters unintentionally targeted the one person likely to get them arrested.
DEC 3, 2018
Conor Friedersdorf
Staff writer at The Atlantic

PHOTOGRAPH -- JIM YOUNG / REUTERS

Last year, former police officer Jason Stockley was on trial in St. Louis, Missouri, for the shooting death of a black motorist named Anthony Smith.

He was acquitted, sparking street protests.

The St. Louis police activated what it calls its Civil Disobedience Team. Among the cops assigned to it were Dustin Boone, Randy Hays, and Christopher Myers, who sent texts to one another expressing their excitement and glee at the prospect of brutalizing protesters, according to federal prosecutors who reviewed their communications.

“Let’s whoop some ass,” Myers allegedly texted.

“The more the merrier!!!” Boone allegedly replied. “It’s gonna get IGNORANT tonight!! But it’s gonna be a lot of fun beating the hell out of those shitheads once the sun goes down and nobody can tell us apart!!!!” He went on to describe a fellow police officer as “a BIG OL black dude” who is “hands on,” and who is “basically a thug that’s on our side. It’s he and I that just grab fuckers and toss em around.” Later he described cops loading protesters onto prison buses while saying “Our streets,” in unison, mocking their chant. He added, “Did everyone see the protesters getting FUCKED UP in the galleria????? That was awesome.”

Read: In one year, 57,375 years of life were lost to police violence
Read: After the police brutality video goes viral

Hays allegedly explained, “It’s extremely frustrating, but you’ll eat yourself up inside if you don’t just let it go and deal with it when it comes. And this one is easy because we both are good, going rogue does feel good, but I’ve been elected to be the driver of a Tahoe, so if I get involved tonight, shit has hit the fan.” He added, “Remember we are in south city. They support us but also cameras. So make sure you have an old white dude as a witness.”

On September 17, 2017, these men put their sadistic language into practice, according to an indictment filed against them last week.

“The defendants threw L.H. to the ground and then kicked and struck L.H. while he was compliant and not posing a physical threat to anyone,” it states. “This offense resulted in bodily injury to L.H. and included the use of a dangerous weapon, that is: shod feet and a riot baton.”

They most likely would still be on the street, with their badges, their guns, and the ability to inflict lethal force, if not for the fact that L.H. happened to be an undercover police officer. “We’ve had several incidents of protesters and activists being the victims of excessive use of force and police abusing their authority without ever seeing charges like this,” Rev. Darryl Gray, a protest organizer, told The Washington Post.

An attorney who filed brutality lawsuits on behalf of 23 protesters told AP, “The text messages confirm our suspicions that these officers were using the anonymity of their swat uniforms and face masks after removing their name tags so that they could beat citizens with impunity.”

Now four officers await an early December court date, where they are expected to plead not guilty. According to the indictment, Myers “did knowingly destroy and mutilate L.H.’s cellular phone, a tangible object used to record and preserve information.” All three men allegedly conspired to influence the testimony of potential witnesses. One fellow officer, Bailey Colletta, was indicted for lying about the incident.

“St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kim Gardner said that her office has dismissed 91 criminal cases associated with four St. Louis police officers,” the St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported, adding this striking detail:

Gardner stopped accepting cases from the four officers in question, “When we learned these officers were under investigation and the reason for the investigation,” spokeswoman Susan Ryan said Friday. “That was in late August, early September,” she said. A source told the Post-Dispatch that those cases had been issued between 2016 and this year.

Several were issued after the alleged assault on Hall took place, and well into the federal investigation into the incident, according to a source. That means the accused officers were on duty, actively making arrests and building cases while they were the subjects of a federal criminal investigation. It is not clear whether they were ever disciplined internally or put on administrative duty during the investigation.

St. Louis prosecutors seem to have all sorts of problems with St. Louis police officers––they keep a list of the ones they won’t work with, but won’t reveal those names to the public and the cops remain on the job.

Additional information about police misconduct during the Stockley protests may emerge as more than a dozen federal lawsuits filed against the police department make their way through the courts.

“The suits claim police violated the arrestees’ Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights to be free from unlawful seizure and their First Amendment rights to assemble in public and express their views free from retaliation,” the Post-Dispatch reports. “The suits also say police conspired to deprive them of their civil rights and that the city failed to properly train officers to avoid violating the rights of protesters or others.”

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.

CONOR FRIEDERSDORF is a California-based staff writer at The Atlantic, where he focuses on politics and national affairs. He is the founding editor of The Best of Journalism, a newsletter devoted to exceptional nonfiction.


OFFICER ERROR

https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/st-louis-police-officers-indicted-accused-of-beating-an-undercover/article_4a82d209-b3cd-565e-9a97-309cf1c2a5af.html
4 St. Louis police officers indicted, accused of beating an undercover colleague during Stockley protests
By Robert Patrick St. Louis Post-Dispatch Dec 1, 2018

ST. LOUIS • Four St. Louis police officers were indicted Thursday on federal charges claiming that three of them beat an undercover colleague during protests last year and all four then covered it up, federal prosecutors say.

The indictment also claims that several of the officers exchanged messages that “expressed disdain” for protesters and “excitement about using unjustified force against them and going undetected while doing so.”

RELATED: Read the indictment against the St. Louis police officers

Prosecutors allege that officers Dustin Boone, Randy Hays and Christopher Myers threw a 22-year police veteran to the ground and kicked and hit him with a police baton on Sept. 17, 2017, amid protests downtown that followed the acquittal of former police Officer Jason Stockley on a murder charge for the fatal shooting of Anthony Lamar Smith. They believed the undercover officer was a protester and assaulted him “while he was compliant and not posing a physical threat to anyone,” the indictment says.

Officer Bailey Colletta is accused of lying to a federal grand jury investigating the incident.

All four of the accused officers are members of the St. Louis Police Officers’ Association, which is providing them with legal representation, according to Jeff Roorda, business manager. All four accused officers appeared in court Friday and turned themselves in.

Roorda referred all questions to the officers’ attorneys, saying, in part, “We encourage elected officials, the media and the public to allow them their day in court without speculation about their guilt or innocence.”

Hays’ and Colletta’s lawyers declined to comment. The others did not return messages.

After learning that the person they attacked was an undercover officer, the three male officers lied about the arrest, claiming the man resisted arrest and was not compliant, the indictment says. They also tried to contact the undercover officer to dissuade him from pursuing disciplinary or legal action, the indictment says.

The undercover officer is identified only by the initials “L.H.” The age, gender and initials match only one officer: Luther Hall. Hall was working undercover aiding other officers in identifying criminal activity, sources said.

At the time of the assault, police sources said Hall suffered a bloody lip during his arrest.

But sources close to Hall said Thursday that injuries from the assault were much more extensive. He has not been able to return to work.

Hall was kicked in the face, which inflamed his jaw muscles to the point where he could not eat. He went from about 185 pounds to 165.

The cut above his lip was a 2-centimeter hole that went through his face.

He also sustained an injury to his tailbone, which still causes him pain, the sources said.

And in October, he underwent surgery to repair two herniated discs in his neck and one in his back. He is still wearing a collar to keep his neck immobile.

Myers destroyed Hall’s cellphone with the intent to obstruct any subsequent investigation, sources said, and Boone, Hays and Myers obstructed justice by conspiring to prevent information about the beating from reaching federal investigators. Colletta and Hays were in a romantic relationship at the time of the incident and investigation, the indictment says.

Colletta initially denied knowing Hall and denied that she had ever come into contact with him on the night of his arrest, the indictment says, and lied when saying he was “brought to the ground very gently.”

The indictment says the officers exchanged a series of messages during the days of protest duty.

In one Sept. 15, 2017, message, Myers writes “let’s whoop some ass.”

On Oct. 5, 2017, Hays writes “going rogue does feel good.”

Boone later replies that “it’s gonna be a lot of fun beating the hell out of these (expletive) once the sun goes down and nobody can tell us apart!!!!” On Sept. 17, he wrote that it was “a blast beating people that deserve it.”

Boone, 35, Hays, 31, and Myers, 27, all face charges of depriving Hall of his constitutional rights and conspiracy to obstruct justice. Myers also faces a charge of destruction of evidence relating to the cellphone, and Colletta, 25, faces a charge of attempting to obstruct grand jury proceedings.

U.S. Attorney Jeff Jensen declined to comment, saying he would not make any statements outside of a news release announcing the charges.

St. Louis Public Safety Director Jimmie Edwards, who called the officers “outliers” in a statement, said the four officers have been suspended without pay from the police force.

In his own statement, Police Chief John Hayden said police sought the FBI’s help after learning about the allegations involving Hall.

“I am deeply disappointed in the alleged actions of these individual officers; however, it is in no way reflective of the hard work and dedication exhibited by the men and women of our Department who serve the community on a daily basis with integrity and honor,” his statement says.

Hayden said Hays had eight years with the department, Myers had three, Boone had two and Colletta, 18 months.

The officers could face up to 20 years in prison if convicted, although recommended federal sentencing guidelines will likely call for much less prison time.

Others alleged mistreatment

All four were among the 200 officers assigned to the police “Civil Disobedience Team,” prosecutors say, working protest duty.

They’re also among current and former officers that St. Louis city prosecutors have purportedly excluded from testifying in criminal cases.

St. Louis Circuit Attorney Kim Gardner, in a statement Thursday, said her office had dismissed 91 cases associated with the officers and would continue to review “cases where these officers’ testimony or involvement is fundamental.”

Following the alleged assault on Hall, then-Acting Chief Lawrence O’Toole asked police union leaders for a donation to cover the cost of a broken camera. Roorda confirmed at the time that the union’s nonprofit foundation, Shield of Hope, donated $500 to Hall to help cover those expenses or any other costs.

It was not immediately clear whether Thursday’s indictment would close out a federal investigation into police activity during the controversial police “kettle” on the night of Hall’s arrest.

St. Louis Mayor Lyda Krewson and O’Toole were among the officials who asked the U.S. attorney’s office to investigate less than two weeks later.

The mass arrest prompted criticism by a federal judge and a series of federal lawsuits alleging that police violated arrestees’ Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights to be free from unlawful seizure and their First Amendment rights to assemble in public and express their views free from retaliation.

The suits say arrestees were pepper-sprayed and physically injured even when attempting to be compliant with police orders.

Former Post-Dispatch reporter Mike Faulk, who was among the reporters assigned to cover the protests that night, was also arrested and has filed his own lawsuit.

Police supervisors have said that protesters blocking the street and refusing to disperse were given multiple warnings about possible arrest and the use of chemical munitions. They denied seeing any inappropriate use of force, saying pepper spray was used only on those who resisted police orders.

After the indictments were announced, Tony Rothert, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Missouri, wrote that “there has still been no real accountability for the individual officers who engaged in the same behavior toward protesters. St. Louis officials must address this rampant lawlessness by its police.”

“We expect professionalism from every City employee,” Krewson said in a statement. “No exceptions. The charges brought against these officers today do not reflect the standards we hold ourselves to as public servants.”

Police have also said multiple officers have been injured by rocks and bottles thrown by protesters on various occasions.

“In a few instances, some officers have fallen short of the professionalism required to work in our Police Department,” Edwards said in a statement. “I take accountability and transparency very seriously. When a public safety employee acts outside the scope of their authority, it is imperative that they be held accountable to the fullest extent of the law.”

Hall was not a member of the Ethical Society of Police, a police association which represents primarily black officers.

But the organization’s community liaison, the Rev. Darryl Gray, said the group has been calling on the department to investigate the assault ever since it happened.

“Anytime we have police officers who are labeled as rogue officers, other officers need to know there is accountability and there are consequences to police officers who think they’re above the law or try to hide their own viciousness and hatred behind the badge and under the cover of darkness,” Gray said.

Christine Byers and Joel Currier of the Post-Dispatch contributed to this report.

A TIMELINE OF EVENTS AND COVERAGE


2018 homicide map
2018 homicide map
Salary information
Salary information
Crime tracker
Crime tracker



THIS ARTICLE IS PROBABLY SUPPOSED TO MAKE ME FEEL PITY FOR THE POOR SUPERTASTERS AND FINICKY FELIX CHARACTERS, SO THAT I WOULD THINK THEY SHOULD CONTINUE TO FEEL DISGUST TOWARD PEOPLE WHO ARE “FULL OF DISEASES” OR “BROWN.” I SEE THE CONNECTION, BUT TO ME FINICKY PEOPLE ARE MORE OF AN IRRITANT THAN A SUPERIOR BEING.

DONALD TRUMP NOT LONG AGO STATED THAT THE “INVASION” COMING ACROSS THE BORDER WAS MADE UP OF PEOPLE WHO WERE CARRYING DISEASES, RAPISTS, THUGS, AND SOME OTHER SUCH DESCRIPTIVE TERMS, FINALLY FINISHING OFF WITH, “OF COURSE I ASSUME SOME OF THEM ARE FINE PEOPLE.” I HAD BEEN TOLD BEFORE THAT HE WAS A GERMAPHOBE. THAT TO ME IS MORE THAN FINICKINESS; IT IS BORDERLINE PSYCHOTIC. MAYBE IT’S BECAUSE THEY HAVE NEVER HAD TO DEAL WITH LIFE HEAD ON, WITHOUT THEIR SERVANTS, OR MAYBE IT’S BECAUSE THEY HAVE NEVER DONE AN HONEST DAY’S WORK IN THEIR LIVES.

WE ALL HAVE OUR CROSS TO BEAR. THEIR CROSS SHOULD BE TO CONFRONT THEIR OWN SMALL-MINDEDNESS WITH NEW INFORMATION AND MUSIC AND FOOD AND PEOPLE UNTIL THEY LOSE THEIR FEAR OF IT. INTERACTING WITH PEOPLE WHO ARE DIFFERENT IS STIMULATING AND ENJOYABLE WHEN YOU GET USED TO IT. A GREAT OR IRRATIONAL FEARFULNESS IS DISGUSTING TO ME. WE HAVE TO PULL OURSELVES OUT OF THAT WEAKNESS. SUCH PEOPLE SIMPLY COULDN’T HAVE LIVED IN A PRIOR TIME PERIOD BEFORE WE WERE ALL SO COMFORTABLY HOUSED AND WELL-FED.

THERE ARE MUCH MORE SERIOUS THINGS TO WORRY ABOUT, IF WE ARE GOING TO SET UP AND MAINTAIN CARING AND CIVILIZED SOCIETIES. I WONDER HOW THE TEST SUBJECTS WOULD HAVE ANSWERED THE QUESTIONS IF THEY HAD BEEN BORN A HUNDRED YEARS AGO AND IN A LESS WEALTHY NATION, INSTEAD OF NOW. MY WAY OF DEALING WITH A STICKY TABLETOP OR A YUCKY PUBLIC TOILET SEAT IS TO PULL OUT A PAPER TOWEL, WET IT, ADD SOAP AND WASH THE OFFENDING SURFACE.

https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2019/03/the-yuck-factor/580465/
Liberals and Conservatives React in Wildly Different Ways to Repulsive Pictures
To a surprising degree, our political beliefs may derive from a specific aspect of our biological makeup: our propensity to feel physical revulsion.
KATHLEEN MCAULIFFE
MARCH 2019 ISSUE


Email
I. “My Jaw Dropped”

Why do we have the political opinions we have? Why do we embrace one outlook toward the world and not another? How and why do our stances change? The answers to questions such as these are of course complex. Most people aren’t reading policy memos to inform every decision. Differences of opinion are shaped by contrasting life experiences: where you live; how you were raised; whether you’re rich or poor, young or old. Emotion comes into the picture, and emotion has a biological basis, at least in part. All of this and more combines into a stew without a fixed recipe, even if many of the ingredients are known.

To hear more feature stories, see our full list or get the Audm iPhone app.

On rare occasions, we learn of a new one—a key factor that seems to have been overlooked. To a surprising degree, a recent strand of experimental psychology suggests, our political beliefs may have something to do with a specific aspect of our biological makeup: our propensity to feel physical disgust.

In the mid-2000s, a political scientist approached the neuroscientist Read Montague with a radical proposal. He and his colleagues had evidence, he said, that political orientation might be partly inherited, and might be revealed by our physiological reactivity to threats. To test their theory, they wanted Montague, who heads the Human Neuroimaging Laboratory at Virginia Tech, to scan the brains of subjects as they looked at a variety of images—including ones displaying potential contaminants such as mutilated animals, filthy toilets, and faces covered with sores—to see whether neural responses showed any correlation with political ideology. Was he interested?

FROM OUR MARCH 2019 ISSUE

Montague initially laughed at the idea—for one thing, MRI research requires considerable time and resources—but the team returned with studies to argue their case, and eventually he signed on. When the data began rolling in, any skepticism about the project quickly dissolved. The subjects, 83 in total, were first shown a randomized mixture of neutral and emotionally evocative pictures—this second category contained both positive and negative images—while undergoing brain scans. Then they filled out a questionnaire seeking their views on hot-button political and social issues, in order to classify their general outlook on a spectrum from extremely liberal to extremely conservative. As Montague mapped the neuroimaging data against ideology, he recalls, “my jaw dropped.” The brains of liberals and conservatives reacted in wildly different ways to repulsive pictures: Both groups reacted, but different brain networks were stimulated. Just by looking at the subjects’ neural responses, in fact, Montague could predict with more than 95 percent accuracy whether they were liberal or conservative.

The subjects in the trial were also shown violent imagery (men pointing revolvers directly at the camera, battle scenes, car wrecks) and pleasant pictures (smiling babies, beautiful sunsets, cute bunnies). But it was only the reaction to repulsive things that correlated with ideology. “I was completely flabbergasted by the predictability of the results,” Montague says.

His collaborators—John Hibbing and Kevin Smith at the University of Nebraska at Lincoln, and John Alford at Rice University, in Houston—were just as surprised, though less by the broad conclusion than by the specificity of the findings and the startling degree of predictability. Their own earlier research had already yielded a suggestive finding, indicating that conservatives tend to have more pronounced bodily responses than liberals when shown stomach-churning imagery. However, the investigators had expected that brain reactions to violent imagery would also be predictive of ideology. Compared with liberals, they’d previously found, conservatives generally pay more attention—and react more strongly—to a broad array of threats. For example, they have a more pronounced startle response to loud noises, and they gaze longer at photos of people displaying angry expressions. And yet even in this research, Hibbing says, “we almost always get clearer results with stimuli that are disgusting than with those that suggest a threat from humans, animals, or violent events. We have an ongoing discussion in our lab about whether this is because disgust is simply a more powerful and more politically relevant emotion or because it is an emotion that is easier to evoke with still images in a lab setting.”

Findings so dramatic, especially in the social sciences, should be viewed with caution until replicated. The axiom that extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proof clearly applies here. That said, Hibbing, Montague, and their colleagues are scarcely alone in linking disgust and ideology.

At a deep, symbolic level, some researchers speculate, disgust may be bound up with ideas about “them” versus “us,” about whom we instinctively trust and don’t trust.

Using a far cruder tool for measuring sensitivity to disgust—basically a standardized questionnaire that asks subjects how they would feel about, say, touching a toilet seat in a public restroom or seeing maggots crawling on a piece of meat—numerous studies have found that high levels of sensitivity to disgust tend to go hand in hand with a “conservative ethos.” That ethos is defined by characteristics such as traditionalism, religiosity, support for authority and hierarchy, sexual conservatism, and distrust of outsiders. According to a 2013 meta-analysis of 24 studies—pretty much all the scientific literature on the topic at that time—the association between a conservative ethos and sensitivity to disgust is modest: Disgust sensitivity explains 4 to 13 percent of the variation in a population’s ideology. That may sound unimpressive, but it is in fact noteworthy, says David Pizarro, a psychology professor at Cornell who specializes in disgust. “These are robust, reliable findings. No matter where we look, we see this relationship”—a rarity in the fuzzy field of psychology. The trend stands out even more, he adds, when you consider all the other things that potentially impinge on “why you might have a particular political view.”

II. The Behavioral Immune System
broadly speaking, studies of possible connections between ideology and susceptibility to disgust fall into two categories. The first involves measuring subjects’ sensitivity to disgust as well as their social or political ideologies and then calculating the correlation between the two. The second category explores whether exposure to disgusting subject matter can actually influence people’s views in the moment. But whatever the type of study, the same general finding keeps turning up. “We are at the point where there is very solid evidence for the association,” says Michael Bang Petersen, a political scientist at Aarhus University, in Denmark. His own research finds that “disgust influences our political views as much as or even more than long-recognized factors such as education and income bracket.”

So many scientists have thrown themselves into this line of research in recent years that it has become an accepted discipline, sometimes jokingly given the aptly unappetizing name “disgustology.” Their conclusions raise a lot of questions, chief among them: Why in the world would your reaction to mutilated animals, vomit, and other unwelcome things somehow be associated with your views on transgender rights, immigration, or anything else stirring debate in the news?


Jeff Brown
Researchers have theories rather than answers. At a deep, symbolic level, some speculate, disgust may be bound up with ideas about “them” versus “us,” about whom we instinctively trust and don’t trust. In short, this research may help illuminate one factor—among many—that underlies why those on the left and the right can so vehemently disagree.


There is nothing inherently political about disgust. It evolved not to guide us at the ballot box but rather, it is widely theorized, to protect us from infection. As we move about in the world, a sizable volume of research shows, our minds are constantly searching our surroundings for contaminants—moldy leftovers, garbage spilling out of trash cans, a leaky sewage pipe—and when the brain detects them, it triggers sudden feelings of revulsion. Confronted, we withdraw from the threat. The mechanism is part of what’s known as the “behavioral immune system,” and it is as vital for survival as the fight-or-flight response. Our pathogen-tracking system does its job largely beneath our conscious awareness—and pays close attention to those walking germ bags we call human beings.

This dynamic was highlighted in a pioneering series of experiments launched in the early 2000s by the psychologist Mark Schaller, of the University of British Columbia. Like a smoke detector, Schaller discovered, our germ radar operates on a better-safe-than-sorry principle. It is error-prone in flagging danger—it produces a lot of false positives. Any physical oddity displayed by the people around us—contagious or not—can set off an alarm. Just as a pink eye, a hacking cough, or an open wound may activate our behavioral immune system, so too can a birthmark, obesity, deformity, disability, or even liver spots. Furthermore, having germs on our mind can affect how we feel about people we perceive to be of a different race or ethnicity from ourselves.


In one notable experiment, Schaller showed subjects pictures of people coughing, cartoonish-looking germs sprouting from sponges, and other images designed to raise disease concerns. A control group was shown pictures highlighting threats unrelated to germs—for instance, an automobile accident. Both groups were then given a questionnaire that asked them to assess the level of resources the Canadian government should provide to entice people from various parts of the world to settle in Canada. Compared with the control group, the subjects who had seen pictures related to germs wanted to allocate a greater share of a hypothetical government advertising budget to attract people from Poland and Taiwan—familiar immigrant groups in Vancouver, where the study was conducted—rather than people from less familiar countries, such as Nigeria, Mongolia, and Brazil. Familiarity does make a difference. Schaller, whose landmark studies are credited with sparking the initial interest in the relationship between disgust sensitivity and prejudice, says: “If I grow up in an environment where everybody looks pretty much the same, then someone from China, for example, might trigger my behavioral immune system. But if I grow up in New York City, then a person who comes from China is not going to trigger this response.”

If pathogen cues of this kind can indeed intensify prejudice, the explanation could be biological adaptation. Some scientists—notably the psychologist Corey Fincher, at the University of Warwick, in England, and the biologist Randy Thornhill, at the University of New Mexico—theorize that foreigners, at least in the past, would have been more likely to expose local populations to pathogens against which they had no acquired defenses. Other scientists think germ fears piggyback on negative stereotypes about foreigners common throughout history—the notion that they’re dirty, eat bizarre foods, and have looser sexual mores.

Whatever the explanation, an online study launched by Petersen and Lene Aarøe, also at Aarhus University, and Kevin Arceneaux of Temple University suggests that a dread of contagion is not just a personal matter. It can have an impact on society. The investigators began by evaluating the disgust sensitivity of nationally representative samples of 2,000 Danes and 1,300 Americans. The participants were then asked to fill out a questionnaire that assessed their views about foreigners settling in their respective countries. As the researchers reported in 2017, opposition to immigration in both the Danish and American samples increased in direct proportion to a participant’s sensitivity to disgust—an association that held up even after taking into account education level, socioeconomic status, religious background, and numerous other factors.

The team expanded the part of the study that focused on the U.S. It got state-by-state breakdowns of the prevalence of infections, and also analyzed statistics compiled by Google Trends, which tracks internet searches related to contagious illnesses in an effort to spot early signs of outbreaks. Crunching the numbers (the results are as yet unpublished), the researchers found that resistance to immigration is greatest in states with the highest incidence of infectious disease and where worry about this, as reflected by internet activity, has also been high.

More recent investigations by Petersen and Aarøe suggest that those with high disgust sensitivity tend to be leery of any stranger, not just foreigners. They view casual social acquaintances with a certain amount of suspicion—a robust finding replicated across three studies with a total of 4,400 participants. The implication is clear: Disgust and distrust are somehow linked. And maybe, again, the link is defensive in origin: If you shrink your social circle, you’ll reduce your exposure to potential carriers of disease.

III. The Smell Test
interest in disgust sensitivity extends beyond its potential role in fostering xenophobia and prejudice. As the social psychologists Simone Schnall, at the University of Cambridge, and Jonathan Haidt, at NYU, have shown, disgust sensitivity may also help shape beliefs about right and wrong, good and evil. In one experiment, Schnall, Haidt, and other collaborators sat subjects at either a clean desk or one with sticky stains on it as they filled out a form that asked them to judge the offensiveness of various acts, such as lying on a résumé, not returning a wallet found on the street, and resorting to cannibalism in the aftermath of a plane crash. One subgroup of participants seated at the filthy desk—those with high “private body consciousness,” meaning they were particularly sensitive to their own visceral reactions—judged the transgressions more severely than those seated at the pristine desk.

Foul odors can be just as effective as a sticky desk. Another experiment involved two groups of subjects with similar political ideologies. One group was exposed to a vomitlike scent as the subjects filled out an inventory of their social values; the other group filled out the inventory in an odorless setting. Those in the first group expressed more opposition to gay rights, pornography, and premarital sex than those in the second group. The putrid scent even inspired “significantly more agreement with biblical truth.” Variations on these studies using fart spray, foul tastes, and other creative disgust elicitors reveal a consistent pattern: When we experience disgust, we tend to make harsher moral judgments.


Jeff Brown
In thinking about why disgust sensitivity may be associated with conservative moral values, researchers have considered the potential connection between the behavioral immune system and religion. Religious strictures and other traditions may have the hidden function of protecting us from disease, some theorize. Our urge to respect certain culinary practices, sexual prohibitions, and injunctions about washing and hygiene may not be just about achieving spiritual or symbolic purity, but may be the result of an evolutionary drive to avoid contamination.

Could a predilection toward revulsion indicate how we vote? A team led by Cornell’s David Pizarro and Yoel Inbar, at the University of Toronto, set out to answer that question by conducting an online study during the 2008 U.S. presidential contest between Barack Obama and John McCain. In the run-up to the election, the researchers assessed the contagion anxiety of 25,000 “demographically and geographically diverse” Americans and then surveyed the attitudes toward the candidates held by a random subset of the larger group. Those with the highest germ fear reported that they were more likely to vote for McCain, the Republican nominee and the more conservative candidate. Further, the actual proportion of votes that went to him in each state directly scaled with that state’s level of contagion anxiety. The researchers eventually extended studies of this kind to 121 countries and found that disgust sensitivity correlated with a conservative ethos basically everywhere there were sufficient data for analysis. As Pizarro, Inbar, and the other authors of the study write in the journal Social Psychological and Personality Science, this result suggests that disgust sensitivity “is related to conservatism across a wide variety of cultures, geographic regions and political systems.”


IV. “It’s a Little Hack”
disgustology is a young endeavor. Not all the pieces fit together neatly, and some suppositions (as always) may turn out to be wrong. But a few clues have recently surfaced that suggest a useful framework for interpreting this sprawling mass of findings. One of them, in hindsight, is obvious: the etymology of disgust. The English word is derived from the Middle French desgoust, which literally means “distaste.” As it turns out, what tastes foul to us is typically a sour or bitter substance—which can be a marker of contaminants (think of spoiled milk). Several years ago, Pizarro learned that people vary tremendously in the number of bitter receptors they possess on their tongue, and thus in their taste sensitivity. What’s more, the trait is genetically determined. This got him wondering: If conservatives have a greater disgust sensitivity, are they also better at detecting bitter compounds? “It seemed like a really long shot,” Pizarro says. But he, Inbar, and Benjamin Ruisch, a grad student at Cornell, decided to put the idea to the test. They recruited 1,601 subjects from shopping malls and from the Cornell campus and gave them paper strips containing a chemical called Prop and another chemical called PTC, both of which taste bitter to some people. Sure enough, those who had self-identified as being conservative were more sensitive to both compounds; many described them as unpleasant or downright repugnant. Liberals, on the other hand, tended not to be bothered as much by the chemicals or didn’t notice them at all.


The researchers went a step further. Taste receptors, they knew, are concentrated in fungiform papillae—those spongy little bumps on your tongue. The greater the density of papillae, the more acute your taste. So they dyed subjects’ tongues blue (which allows the papillae to be more easily observed), pasted a paper ring on them like those used to prevent pages from tearing out of a metal binder (to create a standard area to be evaluated), and recorded the number of circumscribed papillae. The degree to which subjects’ views tilted to the right was, they found, in direct proportion to the density of papillae on their tongue. This result may have bearing on a puzzling partisan split in food preferences. A 2009 survey of 64,000 Americans revealed that liberals chose bitter-tasting arugula as their favorite salad green more than twice as often as conservatives did. It may also have a bearing on conservative President George H. W. Bush’s famous hatred of broccoli—an unusually bitter vegetable. Of course, sometimes a stalk of broccoli is just a stalk of broccoli.

No doubt your own political allegiances will heavily influence what you extract from the bulk of this research. If you’re liberal, you may be thinking, So this explains some of the other side’s nativism and hostility to immigration. But it’s just as easy to flip the science on its head and conclude, as conservatives might, that the left is composed of clueless naïfs whose rosy-eyed optimism about human nature—and obliviousness to various dangers—will only lead to trouble.

How Your Cat Is Making You Crazy
How to Cultivate Disgust

The research itself does not speak to the relative merits of a conservative or liberal ethos—how could it? Conservatism and liberalism are not monolithic, and they rest on deep intellectual traditions. In terms of gut reactions, the relative appeal of each philosophy can depend significantly on context—for instance, on whether times are kind or cruel. When tensions are high and groups split into factions, as they inevitably do, we can depend on our family and friends to defend our interests—but the outsider is an unknown quantity and, from an evolutionary perspective, may be seen as a source of contamination or, more generally, a threat.

One defining characteristic of disgust, though, is that it occupies a blind spot in our psyche. As Pizarro notes, “It’s such a low-level, almost noncognitive emotion that you really aren’t thinking that much about it.” Compared with anger, happiness, and sadness, he says, disgust is also “less open to change based on your judgment, your thoughts, your reasoning.” Chocolate in the shape of dog poop, he points out, is still gross. The emotion is more reflexive than reflective. “That is the rhetorical strength of disgust,” Pizarro says. “It’s a little hack. You hack into brains pretty quickly and easily by making them feel disgust,” bypassing logic and reason to sway judgment.

Aristotle may not have found this idea surprising. As he intuited millennia ago, a human being “is by nature a political animal”—uniquely endowed with the capacity for deliberation and speech, but at the same time governed by instincts we share with other living creatures. Like bees, he noted, we have a desire to congregate—to form societies. Aristotle could not have anticipated the germ theory of disease, or the role infection avoidance might unconsciously play, but his fundamental insight about the animal side of our politics remains prescient. Even the most rational among us might not always be as rational as we’d like to think.

This article appears in the March 2019 print edition with the headline “The Yuck Factor.”

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
KATHLEEN MCAULIFFE is a Miami-based science writer and the author, most recently, of This Is Your Brain on Parasites: How Tiny Creatures Manipulate Our Behavior and Shape Society.



Monday, February 4, 2019



FEBRUARY 3 AND 4, 2019

NEWS AND VIEWS

PRICE CONTROLS, YES. THAT IS ONE OF THE MAIN THINGS WRONG WITH OUR COST OF LIVING. THERE ARE NONE. WE CAN'T UPSET THE BIG BUSINESSES BY LIMITING THEIR PRIVILEGES. THERE ARE LIMITS TO WHAT THINGS ARE ACTUALLY WORTH, AND HOW MUCH IT COSTS TO MANUFACTURE THEM IS ONE OF THE FACTORS THAT DETERMINES THE VALUE. IT’S AN INTRINSIC VALUE. THE DESIRABILITY OF IT OR THE NEED FOR IT, THE MARKET VALUE, SHOULD NOT CAUSE THE PRICE TO RISE, ESPECIALLY IF HAVING IT IS CRUCIAL TO SOMEONE’S LIFE. IF THE PRODUCT RUNS OUT, APOLOGIZE TO THE PUBLIC FOR THAT AND THEN OFFER A SECOND PRODUCT IF THERE IS ONE. THIS IS THE KIND OF THING THAT MAKES ME FEEL THAT THE WORLD OF BUSINESS HAS SOME -- OR A GREAT -- TENDENCY TO BE CROOKED. HOW COULD PEOPLE REALIZE THIS AND YET GIVE THE MANUFACTURER THE HIGH PRAISE THAT SO MANY AMERICANS HAVE FOR THE WEALTHY? WE SHOULD PRAISE AND REWARD THE VIRTUOUS INSTEAD. AS FOR $375,000 A YEAR, SUCH PRICING USED TO BE CALLED "PRICE GOUGING," AND IT WAS ILLEGAL. IF EVERY TIME A COMPANY DID THAT, THEY WERE FINED HEAVILY THEY WOULD STOP THE PRACTICE. OF COURSE A POINTED LETTER FROM BERNIE SANDERS WILL HELP.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2019/02/04/bernie-sanders-drug-prices-catalyst-firdapse-lems-375-000/2768449002/
Bernie Sanders asks why Catalyst Pharmaceutical is pricing a once-free drug at $375,000
Aki Soga, Burlington Free Press Published 12:41 p.m. ET Feb. 4, 2019 | Updated 4:15 p.m. ET Feb. 4, 2019

Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., is calling a company's decision to price at $375,000 a year a drug that was previously offered free to those with a rare autoimmune disorder “an immoral exploitation of patients who need this medication.”

In a letter addressed to Catalyst Pharmaceuticals CEO Patrick J. McEneny dated Feb. 4, 2019, Sanders called the change, “a blatant fleecing of American taxpayers” adding "I am profoundly concerned that Catalyst's actions will cause patients to suffer or die."

In a statement posted on his Senate website, Sanders wrote that Catalyst announced the pricing to investors in December.

Shortly after noon, the company said there was no one immediately available to respond to Sanders' letter.

More: Democrats examine drug prices, a first step in Congress' path to cut prescription costs

Sen. Bernie Sanders is asking Catalyst Pharmaceuticals why a drug to treat a rare disease that was once available free has been priced at $375,000.
(Photo: Jason Bean/RGJ)

The drug in question is called Firdapse, which was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in November last year for the treatment of Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome, or LEMS, in adults.

The FDA describes LEMS as "a rare autoimmune disorder that affects the connection between nerves and muscles and causes weakness and other symptoms in affected patients."

Sanders writes that the active ingredient in Firdapse, 3,4-diaminopyridine, has been used to treat LEMS* for nearly 30 years and that "the clinical effectiveness had been established over decades in Europe and the United States."

Sanders said the cost of the drug ranges from $1,600 to $6,000 per year.

"Until now, patients have been able to access an unapproved version of this drug for free through a Food and Drug Administration compassionate use program," Sanders wrote to Catalyst, adding, "Simply put, this is corporate greed.

Sanders is asking Catalyst for information behind the cost and pricing of Firdapse, as well as other questions such as, "How many patients will suffer or die due to Catalyst's decision to set the annual list price of Fridapse [sic] at $375,000?"

The high cost of prescription medicine has been blamed as one of the drivers of rising U.S. health care costs. In January, the Trump administration announced a plan to eliminate some rebates paid by drugmakers in government programs such as Medicare to lower the prescription costs.

More: VT Insights: 4 challenges Bernie Sanders faces in a 2020 presidential bid

Sanders, who was a candidate for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2016, is contemplating another run for president in 2020.



THIS IS JUST ANOTHER STORY BY REUTERS ON THE SUBJECT OF FIRDAPSE. THIS ADDITIONAL PIECE OF INFORMATION IS WORTH HIGHLIGHTING. YA CAN’T SAY NOBODY LISTENS TO BERNIE. “CATALYST SHARES FELL NEARLY 8 PERCENT TO $2.31.”

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-healthcare-catalyst/senator-sanders-to-ask-why-drug-once-free-now-costs-375k-idUSKCN1PT0ZJ
POLITICS FEBRUARY 4, 2019 / 6:06 AM / UPDATED 2 HOURS AGO
Senator Sanders asks why drug, once free, now costs $375k
Yasmeen Abutaleb
4 MIN READ

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders sent a letter to Catalyst Pharmaceuticals (CPRX.O) on Monday asking it to justify its decision to charge $375,000 annually for a medication that for years has been available to patients for free.

PHOTOGRAPH -- U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders speaks during a news conference on Yemen resolution on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., January 30, 2019. REUTERS/Yuri Gripas.

The drug, Firdapse, is used to treat Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic Syndrome (LEMS), a rare neuromuscular disorder, according to the letter, made available to Reuters by the senator’s office. The disorder affects about one in 100,000 people in the United States.

The government is intensifying its scrutiny of the pharmaceutical industry and rising prescription drug prices, a top voter concern and a priority of President Donald Trump’s administration.

Both the Democratic-led U.S. House of Representatives and the Senate, controlled by Republicans, have begun holding hearings this year on the rising costs of medicines. Sanders is an independent who usually votes with Democrats.

In the letter dated Feb. 4, Sanders asked Catalyst to lay out the financial and non-financial factors that led the company to set the list price at $375,000, and say how many patients would suffer or die as a result of the price and how much it was paying to purchase or produce the drug.

Catalyst declined to comment on Sanders’ letter.

Catalyst shares fell nearly 8 percent to $2.31

For years, patients have been able to get the same drug for free from Jacobus Pharmaceuticals, a small New Jersey-based drug company, which offered it through a U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) program called “compassionate use.”

The program allows patients with rare diseases and conditions access to experimental drugs outside of a clinical trial when there is no viable alternative.

Florida-based Catalyst received FDA approval of Firdapse in November, along with exclusive rights to market the medication for several years. The company, which bought rights to the drug from a company called BioMarin in 2012, develops and commercializes drugs for rare diseases.

BioMarin and FDA did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

In December, Catalyst announced it would price Firdapse at $375,000 a year.

“Catalyst’s decision to set the annual list price at $375,000 is not only a blatant fleecing of American taxpayers, but is also an immoral exploitation of patients who need this medication,” Sanders wrote in his letter.

Sanders joins other U.S. lawmakers in investigating the pricing practices of pharmaceutical companies this year.

Democratic Representative Elijah Cummings, chairman of the House Oversight Committee, in January wrote to 12 pharmaceutical firms asking for detailed information on how they set drug prices.

Democratic Representatives Frank Pallone and Diana DeGette wrote to the heads of Eli Lilly and Co (LLY.N), Novo Nordisk (NOVOb.CO) and Sanofi SA (SASY.PA), the long-time leading manufacturers of insulin, requesting information on why the drug’s price has skyrocketed in recent years.

Reporting by Yasmeen Abutaleb; Editing by Sonya Hepinstall and Susan Thomas

Our Standards:The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.


BOILING THIS DOWN, LEMS IS A MUSCLE WEAKNESS CONDITION USUALLY ASSOCIATED WITH SMALL CELL LUNG CANCER, A LONG HISTORY OF SMOKING, AND HAVING A LATE LIFE ONSET. HOWEVER, THERE CAN BE OTHER CAUSES, IN WHICH CASES IT CAN START EARLIER.

SEE THE LIST OF RELATED CONDITIONS BELOW. ONE OF THESE WHICH I HAVE SEEN, COMMONLY CALLED BELLS PALSY IS “MYASTHENIA GRAVIS,” AND IT TENDS TO GO AWAY WITHOUT TREATMENT, BUT ANY MUSCLE WEAKNESS CAN LIMIT LIFE. IN THIS LEMS IT ALSO AFFECTS MUSCLES IN THE TRUNK OF THE BODY AND THIGHS, SO THAT GOING UP AND DOWN STAIRS BECOMES HARDER. THERE IS MORE ABOUT THESE CONDITIONS AND THEIR CAUSES IN THE “RAREDISEASES” WEB SITE BELOW, SHOULD YOU BE INTERESTED.

https://rarediseases.org/rare-diseases/lambert-eaton-myasthenic-syndrome/

Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic Syndrome

NORD gratefully acknowledges Paul Gozzard, MRCP, Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, UK, for assistance in the preparation of this report.

Synonyms of Lambert-Eaton Myasthenic Syndrome
Eaton-Lambert syndrome
Lambert-Eaton syndrome
LEMS
myasthenic syndrome of Lambert-Eaton

General Discussion

Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS) is a rare autoimmune disorder characterized by the gradual onset of muscle weakness, especially of the pelvic and thigh muscles. Approximately 60 percent of LEMS cases are associated with a small cell lung cancer (SCLC), and the onset of LEMS symptoms often precedes the detection of the cancer. The LEMS patients with cancer tend to be older and nearly always have a long history of smoking. In cases in which there is no associated cancer, disease onset can be at any age.

Signs & Symptoms

LEMS is characterized by weakness and fatigue especially of the pelvic and thigh muscles. The disease may affect the patient’s ability to engage in strenuous exercise and may make such activities as climbing stairs or walking up a steep walkway difficult. Onset is gradual, typically taking place over several weeks to many months. There is often a progression of symptoms whereby the shoulder muscles, muscles of the feet & hands, speech & swallowing muscles and eye muscles are affected in a stepwise fashion. The symptoms progress more quickly when LEMS is associated with cancer. Most LEMS patients also exhibit the following symptoms (sometimes called autonomic symptoms): dry mouth, constipation, impotence and, decreased sweating. LEMS patients with or without cancer may also undergo significant weight loss. The tendon reflexes are diminished or absent on examination. Hence, in summary, LEMS is often described as a clinical “triad” of proximal muscle weakness, autonomic symptoms and reduced tendon reflexes.

Causes

LEMS is an autoimmune disorder. Autoimmune disorders are caused when the body’s natural defenses against “foreign” or invading organisms (e.g., antibodies) begin to attack healthy tissue for unknown reasons. LEMS occurs because autoantibodies damage the “voltage-gated calcium channels (VGCC)” on the motor nerve membrane at the neuromuscular junction. These channels normally conduct calcium into the nerve resulting in release of a chemical known as acetylcholine. Acetylcholine helps in the communication between nerve cells and muscles and is one of a group of chemicals known as neurotransmitters, which help to transmit nerve impulses. The autoantibodies attack the VGCC resulting in less acetylcholine release.

In LEMS cases associated with cancer, it is believed that autoantibodies created against the VGCC on the small-cell lung tumor damage the VGCC on the nerve. It is unknown what causes autoantibody production in cases not associated with cancer.

In LEMS cases associated with cancer, affected individuals nearly always have a long smoking history.

Affected Populations

There are approximately 400 known cases of Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome in the United States. These include both males and females, but when LEMS is associated with SCLC, the patients tend to be older and are more likely to be men than women. The average age of onset of SCLC is around 60 years. Around 3% of SCLC patients develop LEMS. Clinical symptoms of LEMS usually precede the SCLC diagnosis (sometimes by many years).When LEMS is not related to cancer, the syndrome may occur at any age.

Related Disorders

Symptoms of the following disorders can be similar to those of Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome. Comparisons may be useful for a differential diagnosis:

MYASTHENIA GRAVIS (MG) is a chronic neuromuscular disease characterized by weakness and abnormally rapid fatigue of the voluntary muscles, with improvement following rest. Any group of muscles may be affected, but those around the eyes and the muscles used for swallowing are the most commonly involved. In LEMS, eye muscle weakness, when present, tends to be mild and, unlike with MG, is almost never the only symptom of the disease. Severe respiratory muscle weakness, which can be fatal in MG is rare in LEMS. On the other hand, the autonomic symptoms which affect most LEMS patients, are not present in MG. For more information on this disorder, choose “myasthenia” as your search term in the Rare Disease Database.)

GUILLAIN-BARRE SYNDROME is an autoimmune disease which occurs when the body’s defense system attacks the nerves, damaging the nerve’s myelin and axon. Nerve signals are delayed and altered, causing weakness and paralysis of the muscles of the legs, arms, and other parts of the body. Abnormal sensations such as numbness or tingling also occur. If muscle nerves are damaged, the patient experiences aching and weak muscles, shortness of breath, and difficulty in swallowing. If the autonomic nervous system is damaged, the patient may experience alterations of blood pressure, heart rate, vision, body temperature, bladder function, and blood chemistries. (For more information on this disorder, choose “Guillain” as your search term in the Rare Disease Database.)

Diagnosis

Diagnosis of LEMS is based on clinical symptoms and signs, electrophysiological studies, and antibody testing.

Electromyography initially shows a small amount of electrical activity in the muscle. After high frequency repetitive stimulation or exercise, there is increased activity in the muscle.

Anti-VGCC antibodies are detectable in around 85% of LEMS patients and when detected they are highly specific for the condition, or by measuring VGCC* antibodies in the blood.

Screening for SCLC* is a very important part of the diagnostic workup for LEMS. A chest CT (and sometimes FDG-PET) scan will usually form the basis of this screening. Depending on the risk profile, a negative initial screen will be repeated at suitable time intervals. A recently discovered tumor marker antibody directed against SOX, which is found in 65% of SCLC LEMS patients as opposed to only 5% of non-tumor LEMS patients may help guide clinical practice in the future.

Standard Therapies
Treatment

Treatment of LEMS may vary depending upon the individual’s age, general health, and the presence of associated cancer to autoimmune disorder. If cancer is present, treatment of Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome first involves treatment directed at the cancer. This may result in relief of LEMS symptoms.

In addition to symptomatic treatment, drugs that suppress the activity of the immune system (immunosuppressive drugs) are used in more severe cases of LEMS, e.g. prednisone (alone or in conjunction with azathioprine or cyclosporin).


VGCC – VOLTAGE GATED CALCIUM CHANNEL (AND ANTIBODIES TO THEM)

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4360501/
Logo of wjcc
World J Clin Cases. 2015 Mar 16; 3(3): 293–300.
Published online 2015 Mar 16. doi: 10.12998/wjcc.v3.i3.293

PMCID: PMC4360501
PMID: 25789302

Voltage gated calcium channel antibody-related neurological diseases

Can Ebru Bekircan-Kurt, Eda Derle Çiftçi, Aslı Tuncer Kurne, and Banu Anlar

ABSTRACT

VOLTAGE GATED CALCIUM CHANNEL (VGCC) antibodies are generally associated with Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome. However the presence of this antibody has been associated with paraneoplastic as well as non-paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration. Most patients with VGCC-antibody-positivity have small cell lung cancer (SCLC). Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome (LEMS) is an autoimmune disease of the presynaptic part of the neuromuscular junction. Its classical clinical triad is proximal muscle weakness, areflexia and autonomic dysfunction. Fifty to sixty percent of LEMS patients have a neoplasia, usually SCLC. The co-occurrence of SCLC and LEMS causes more severe and progressive disease and shorter survival than non-paraneoplastic LEMS. Treatment includes 3,4 diaminopyridine for symptomatic purposes and immunotherapy with prednisolone, azathioprine or intravenous immunoglobulin in patients unresponsive to 3,4 diaminopyridine. Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration (PCD) is a syndrome characterized with severe, subacute pancerebellar dysfunction. Serum is positive for VGCC antibody in 41%-44% of patients, usually with the co-occurrence of SCLC. Clinical and electrophysiological features of LEMS are also present in 20%-40% of these patients. Unfortunately, PCD symptoms do not improve with immunotherapy. The role of VGCC antibody in the immunopathogenesis of LEMS is well known whereas its role in PCD is still unclear. All patients presenting with LEMS or PCD must be investigated for SCLC.

Keywords: Voltage gated calcium channel antibody, Lambert-Eaton myasthenic syndrome, Paraneoplastic cerebellar degeneration, Onconeural antibodies, Small cell lung cancer






A NEW TURN OF EVENTS
COMPILATION AND COMMENTARY
BY LUCY WARNER
FEBRUARY 4, 2019 AT 10:58 PM

MORE SUBPOENAS HAVE BEEN ISSUED, AND CNN STATED THAT SUBMITTING THE DOCUMENTS WILL BE MANDATORY, WITH A POSSIBLE CONSEQUENCE FOR NON-COMPLIANCE. THERE MAY EVEN BE A SUPREME COURT DECISION IN THE FUTURE HERE, SINCE THERE HAVE BEEN SO FEW ACTUAL LEGAL PROCEDURES THAT ARE GENERALLY CONSIDERED TO BE CONSTITUTIONAL AND, SOMETHING WHICH IS MORE IMPORTANT TO ME, PERSONALLY, "EFFECTIVE." WE NEED TO LEARN LESSONS FROM WHAT WE ARE GOING THROUGH THESE LAST SEVERAL YEARS, AND WRITE IT INTO THE LAW, PERHAPS INCLUDING THE CONSTITUTION. I AM RELIEVED TO FIND THIS MOVE, AND I HOPE IT MAKES A DIFFERENCE IN THE (TRUE) STATE OF OUR UNION.

THIS MAY BE VERY IMPORTANT, BECAUSE, THOUGH IT’S JUST A BEGINNING, IT IS FISHING IN A GOOD PART OF THE RIVER WHERE THE BASS ARE LIKELY TO BE BITING. THERE HAVE BEEN QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW HIS INAUGURAL COMMITTEE COULD HAVE RECEIVED SUCH A HUGE AMOUNT OF MONEY FOR WHAT WAS DESCRIBED AS A FAIRLY SIMPLE EVENT. AS WE USED TO SAY, BACK WHEN PEOPLE REALLY READ “NEWSPAPERS,” IT’S ALSO “HOT OFF THE PRESS.”

https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/04/politics/sdny-subpoena-trump-inauguration-committee/index.html
Federal prosecutors subpoena Trump inaugural committee, source says
By Erin Burnett, Erica Orden, Gloria Borger and Caroline Kelly, CNN
Updated 10:08 PM ET, Mon February 4, 2019

(CNN)Federal prosecutors in New York on Monday subpoenaed President Donald Trump's inaugural committee for documents related to donors, vendors and finances, according to a copy of the subpoena reviewed by CNN, a step that appears to escalate that office's ongoing investigation of the committee's activity.

The wide-ranging subpoena from the Manhattan US attorney's office requires the committee to turn over documents related to virtually every donor or donation, attendee at a committee event, piece of paperwork related to the legal requirements attached to donations and even "the possibility of" donations made by foreign nationals.

It discloses that prosecutors are investigating a litany of potential crimes: conspiracy against the US, false statements, mail fraud, wire fraud, money laundering, inaugural committee disclosure violations, and violations of laws prohibiting contributions by foreign nations and contributions in the name of another person, also known as straw donors.

It demands documents related to any "benefits" offered to donors, including "tickets, photo opportunities, and/or small group receptions." It also requires the committee to turn over information about donations made directly to vendors, as well as communications discussing that possibility.

Federal prosecutors' investigation into the committee involves possible financial abuses related to the more than $100 million in donations raised for Trump's inauguration, CNN has reported. The prosecutor listed on the subpoena, Tom McKay, is a member of the office's public-corruption unit and was one of the lead prosecutors on the office's case against Trump's former personal attorney, Michael Cohen.

The broad demand for documents suggests that Trump and entities connected to him may face continued scrutiny by federal prosecutors, particularly in New York, even if special counsel Robert Mueller's probe winds down. ABC News first reported that the US attorney's office was prepared to issue a subpoena to the committee.

A spokesperson for the committee said Monday: "We have just received a subpoena for documents. While we are still reviewing the subpoena, it is our intention to cooperate with the inquiry."

A spokesperson for the Manhattan US attorney's office declined to comment.

Tom Barrack, the inaugural committee's chairman, also declined to comment. Barrack isn't named in the subpoena.

The investigation into the committee -- which was first reported by the Wall Street Journal in December -- involves possible financial abuses related to the more than $100 million in donations raised for Trump's inauguration, sources familiar with the matter told CNN at the time.

One source familiar with the matter told CNN in December that the investigation was in its early stages, and that investigators were generally focused on whether any inauguration money had been misspent.

The subpoena lists only two specific names: Imaad Zuberi and his investment firm, Avenue Ventures LLC. The subpoena asks for documents related to Zuberi but doesn't offer any clues as to why his donations may be of interest. Avenue Ventures donated $900,000 to the inaugural fund, Federal Election Commission records show.

Zuberi did not respond to a request for comment on Monday.

CNN's Fredreka Schouten, Kara Scannell and Devan Cole contributed to this report.