Tuesday, February 12, 2019
FEBRUARY 12, 2019
NEWS AND VIEWS
THE KAVANAUGH EFFECT
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/supreme-court-blocks-louisiana-abortion-law-1st-major-ruling-abortion-n968766
Supreme Court blocks Louisiana abortion law as John Roberts joins liberal justices in 5-4 ruling
The ruling blocks Louisiana from enforcing a law that women's groups said would have left the state with just one doctor allowed to perform abortions.
FEB. 8, 201900:31
Feb. 7, 2019, 9:40 PM EST
By Pete Williams
NEWS VIDEO -- Supreme Court blocks Louisiana abortion restrictions
The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday blocked Louisiana from enforcing a law that women's groups said would leave only a single doctor legally allowed to perform abortions in the state.
By a 5-4 vote, the court said the restrictions must remain on hold while challengers appeal a lower court decision in favor of the law. Chief Justice John Roberts voted with the court's liberal members.
It was the Supreme Court's first significant action on the hot-button issue of abortion since Donald Trump's nominee, Brett Kavanaugh, replaced Anthony Kennedy, who generally voted with the court's liberals to uphold abortion rights.
In Thursday's ruling, Kavanaugh voted with the conservatives — Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch.
Kavanaugh filed a dissent, writing only for himself. He said he would have allowed the law to take effect in order to see whether it would impose a burden on women's access to abortion in the state.
Abortion-rights advocates applauded the court ruling, while opponents expressed disappointment.
“The Supreme Court has stepped in under the wire to protect the rights of Louisiana women,” said Nancy Northup, president and CEO of the Center for Reproductive Rights. “The three clinics left in Louisiana can stay open while we ask the Supreme Court to hear our case. This should be an easy case — all that’s needed is a straightforward application of the court’s own precedent.”
Benjamin Clapper, executive director for Louisiana Right to Life, said he was disappointed that the law remains on hold. He said supporters of abortion rights have fought “against every common-sense health standard. This is just another example of the extreme lengths the abortion industry pursues to protect abortion-on-demand.”
The high court's decision Thursday was not a ruling on the legal merits of the Louisiana restriction. But the decision to keep the law on hold signals that a majority of the justices have doubts about its constitutionality.
Passed by the state legislature in 2014, the measure requires any doctor offering abortion services to have admitting privileges at a hospital within 30 miles. Two Louisiana doctors and a clinic filed a legal challenge, arguing that it was identical to a Texas law the Supreme Court struck down in 2016. In that ruling, joined by Justice Kennedy, the court said Texas imposed an obstacle on women seeking access to abortion services without providing them any medical benefits.
Image: Chief Justice John Roberts arrives prior to President Barack Obama's State of the Union speech on Capitol Hill on January 28, 2014.Larry Downing / Pool via Getty Images
The Center for Reproductive rights said Louisiana's law would leave only one doctor at a single clinic in New Orleans to perform the procedure, a drastic limitation that "cannot possibly meet the needs of approximately 10,000 women who seek abortion services in Louisiana each year."
But Louisiana officials urged the Supreme Court to let them begin enforcing the law. They said the challengers' claim of harm rested on the fear that clinics would be shut down overnight. "But that is not correct. Louisiana envisions a regulatory process that begins, logically, with collecting information from Louisiana's abortion clinics and their doctors," the state said.
Recommended
POLITICS
Senate has uncovered no direct evidence of conspiracy between Trump campaign and Russia
NEWS
Telephone scam artist picked the wrong target — former FBI and CIA director William Webster
The Supreme Court's 2016 ruling, in a case called Whole Women's Health, said requiring abortion doctors to have hospital admitting privileges was medically unnecessary, given that only a tiny fraction of abortions in the first trimester require hospitalization. By contrast the Texas law caused half the abortion clinics in the state to shut down, forcing women to endure longer travel and increased wait times.
It was the most important abortion ruling in 25 years and blocked similar restrictions in Alabama, Mississippi, Oklahoma, Tennessee, and Wisconsin.
The court’s action Thursday came in a brief unsigned order with no written opinion, so none of the five justices who voted to block enforcement of the Louisiana law explained their reasoning.
Roberts was among the dissenters when the court struck down the Texas law. But the court ruled that it was unconstitutional, and his vote Thursday was consistent with that holding.
In response to the lawsuit over Louisiana's identical law, a federal judge said it was likely unconstitutional and issued a stay, blocking its enforcement. But a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals voted to lift the stay. In a 2-1 ruling, the court said Louisiana's law would present far less of an obstacle than the Texas law would have. Less than one-third of Louisiana women seeking an abortion would face even the potential of longer wait times, the court said.
The appeals court concluded that the Louisiana law would not impose an "undue burden" on access to abortion, which has been the Supreme Court's key legal test for challenges to abortion restrictions for nearly three decades. The lower court's ruling was to have gone into effect February 4, but the Supreme Court put it on hold, giving itself more time to decide what to do.
Kavanaugh said that because Louisiana promised to put the law into effect gradually, he would have waited to see how many doctors were able to get hospital admitting privileges. So far, he said, the two sides in the case have offered only "competing predictions" about its effect.
The stay on enforcement of the law will remain until the challengers bring their full appeal to the Supreme Court. If the court agrees to hear the case, the stay would remain until it issues its decision, which would happen sometime late this year or early in 2020.
Pete Williams
Pete Williams is an NBC News correspondent who covers the Justice Department and the Supreme Court, based in Washington.
NEWS VIDEOS ON ABORTION CLINIC RULES
https://www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2019/02/08/supreme-court-blocks-abortion-clinic-regulations-louisiana-intv-cpt-vpx.cnn/video/playlists/this-week-in-politics/ VIDEO 3:03
I DO HOPE THAT THIS ISN’T ANOTHER DISEASE THAT WILL BE MADE MORE PREVALENT WITH GLOBAL WARMING. IT CAN INFECT A SURPRISING SET OF ANIMALS, BUT NOT, I NOTICE YOUR KITTY CAT. DOG, PIG, CATTLE, GOATS, AND PEOPLE. FOR TWO OTHER GOOD ARTICLES ON THE ILLNESS ITSELF IN HUMANS, GO TO: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/brucellosis/symptoms-causes/syc-20351738. IT DOESN’T USUALLY KILL, BUT CAN BECOME CHRONIC AND SETTLE IN CERTAIN ORGANS, INCLUDING THE HEART, THE CENTRAL NERVOUS SYSTEM, AND THE LIVER. NOT A NICE DISEASE!
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2019/02/12/infected-raw-milk-pa-farm-reached-people-19-states-cdc-says/2849261002/
Raw milk infected with Brucella potentially exposed to people in 19 states, CDC says
Sean Rossman, USA TODAY Published 3:11 p.m. ET Feb. 12, 2019 | Updated 4:06 p.m. ET Feb. 12, 2019
PHOTOGRAPH -- jug of milk with an old country table, a white drink is poured into a glass (Photo: Chepko, Getty Images/iStockphoto)
Federal and state health officials are investigating an outbreak of raw milk tainted with Brucella, a drug-resistant bacteria which can cause serious complications such as heart problems, arthritis and miscarriage.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says people in 19 states have bought or consumed the raw milk from Miller's Biodiversity Farm, a members-only club in Quarryville, Pennsylvania, that sells dairy products to its members.
The CDC advises people to toss any raw milk or raw milk products from the farm. People who used such products from the farm since January 2016 may have been exposed and should talk to their doctor, the CDC stated. The infection can strike up to six months after exposure, meaning people who drank or ate the raw milk products within that time frame should monitor their health for symptoms, which include fever, fatigue, loss of appetite and muscle and joint pain.
Authorities connected the farm to a Brucellosis infection (also called Mediterranean fever) in New York in November. An "unknown number" of people could have been exposed.
More: Got 'Milk!'? Mark Kurlansky's latest food history goes down smoothly
Raw milk, which skips the disease-killing pasteurization process, is favored by those who want more natural and unprocessed foods. However, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration says raw milk can expose people to food-borne illness.
The strain under investigation, RB51, is used in a vaccine in order to protect against more severe forms of Brucella. The bacteria can sometimes make its way into the milk of a vaccinated cow, which can cause those who drink it to develop brucellosis. One cow now removed from the herd tested positive for RB51.
Miller's Biodiversity Farm did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
The strain is resistant to first-line drugs, the CDC states, and it's difficult to diagnose because early symptoms resemble the flu.
More: Chicken recall: 100,000 pounds recalled, due to misbranding, undeclared allergen
Two RB51 raw milk outbreaks occurred in 2017 in New Jersey and Texas.
States where people purchased the raw milk products include the following: Alabama, California, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Iowa, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, and Virginia.
INFECTION AND TREATMENT
https://www.webmd.com/a-to-z-guides/brucellosis-symptoms-treatment#1
What Is Brucellosis?
BRUCELLOSIS is an infectious disease caused by a type of bacteria called Brucella. The bacteria can spread from animals to humans.
There are several different strains of Brucella bacteria. Some types are seen in cows. Others occur in dogs, pigs, sheep, goats, and camels. Recently, scientists have seen new strains in the red fox and certain marine animals, including seals. Brucella in animals cannot be cured.
Brucellosis is rare in the U.S. because of effective animal disease control programs. Fewer than 200 people get sick with the disease each year in the U.S. It is most often seen in the spring and summer months in:
Texas
California
Virginia
Florida
Brucellosis is considered a significant health threat in other parts of the world. The disease has been reported in more than a half-million people each year in 100 countries, according to the World Health Organization.
What Causes Brucellosis?
Brucellosis in humans occurs when a person comes into contact with an animal or animal product infected with the Brucella bacteria.
Very rarely, the bacteria may spread from person to person. Breastfeeding moms with brucellosis may pass the bacteria to their baby. Brucella may also be spread through sexual contact.
The bacteria can enter your body:
Through a cut or scratch in the skin
When you breathe in contaminated air (rare)
When you eat or drink something contaminated with the bacteria, such as unpasteurized milk or undercooked meat
Four types of Brucella bacteria cause the majority of brucellosis infections in humans:
B. melitensis . This type causes most cases of human brucellosis and is mainly found in sheep and goats. It is most often seen in:
Spain
Greece
Latin America
Middle East
India
B. suis . This infection found in wild pigs is the most common type of Brucella seen in the U.S. Brucellosis due to this strain most often occurs in the Southeast and California. It also occurs in Europe, South America, and Southeast Asia.
B. canis. The infection from this type of bacteria spreads from dogs. It is most often seen in:
North, Central, and South America
Japan
Central Europe
B. abortus . This infection comes from cattle. It occurs worldwide. It has been wiped outin several European countries, Japan, Israel, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
How Is Brucellosis Diagnosed?
Your doctor will examine you. You may have:
A swollen liver
Swollen lymph nodes
A swollen spleen
Unexplained fever
Joint swelling and pain
A rash
Blood tests will be done to diagnose the infection and determine what type of Brucella is making you sick. Proper identification of the bacteria helps pinpoint the source of the infection.
How Is Brucellosis Treated?
Brucellosis can be difficult to treat. If you have brucellosis, your doctor will prescribe antibiotics. Antibiotics commonly used to treat brucellosis include:
doxycycline (Acticlate, Monodox, Vibra-Tabs, Vibramycin)
streptomycin
ciprofloxacin (Cipro) or ofloxacin (Floxin)
rifampin (Rifadin, Rimactane)
sulfamethoxazole/trimethoprim (Bactrim)
tetracycline (Sumycin)
You will generally be given doxycycline and rifampin a in combination for 6-8 weeks.
You must take the antibiotics for many weeks to prevent the disease from returning. The rate of relapse following treatment is about 5-15% and usually occurs within the first six months after treatment.
Recovery can take weeks, even months. Patients who receive treatment within one month of the start of symptoms can be cured of the disease.
What Are the Complications of Brucellosis?
Severe brucellosis may cause:
Infection of the central nervous system
Endocarditis (infection of the lining of the heart or valves)
Liver abscess
Brucellosis can cause long-lasting symptoms that are similar to systemic exertion intolerance disease. SEID is formerly known as Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. The symptoms can lead to disability. They may include:
Fatigue
Fevers that come and go
Joint pain
Brucellosis in a pregnant woman may lead to:
Miscarriage
Birth defects in the baby
Death from brucellosis is uncommon. Most brucellosis-related deaths are due to endocarditis.
How Can I Prevent Brucellosis?
Brucellosis may be prevented with the following steps:
Do not drink or eat unpasteurized dairy products.
Wear rubber gloves if you work in the animal processing industry.
If you have come in contact with an animal infected with Brucella, tell your health care provider -- even if you do not have symptoms. You will need to be monitored for at least six months. There is no effective human vaccine to prevent brucellosis.
WebMD Medical Reference Reviewed by Jennifer Robinson, MD on December 20, 2018
Sources © 2018 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.
THE FOLLOWING ARTICLE IS FROM THE NATION, WHICH I HAVE SEARCHED FOR BIAS. IT IS ONE NOTCH TO THE LEFT OF CENTER, BUT TRUTHFUL AND ACCURATE ACCORDING TO: https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/the-nation-institute/. THIS IS THE WHOLE REPORT.
“These media sources have a slight to moderate liberal bias. They often publish factual information that utilizes loaded words (wording that attempts to influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes) to favor liberal causes. These sources are generally trustworthy for information, but may require further investigation. See all Left-Center sources.
Factual Reporting: HIGH
Notes: The Nation Institute is a nonprofit media organization associated with The Nation magazine. It sponsors fellows, host forums, publishes, and is involved in awards for journalism. The Nation Institute is always well sourced and factual. There is a left-center bias in story choices and occasionally with wording. (12/4/2016) Updated (D. Van Zandt 7/4/2017)
Source: http://www.nationinstitute.org/”
THIS EXCELLENT ARTICLE FROM THE NATION IS A WRAP-UP OF THE CENTRAL NEED IN THE USA TODAY.
https://www.thenation.com/article/bernie-sanders-progressive-estate-tax-teddy-roosevelt/
Bernie Sanders Is About as Radical on Tax Policy as Teddy Roosevelt
When the senator proposes a 77 percent tax on the value of an estate above $1 billion, he’s talking about renewing American values.
By John NicholsTwitter TODAY 5:58 PM
PHOTOGRAPH -- Senator Bernie Sanders responds to a question during a town-hall meeting in Jackson, Mississippi, on April 4, 2018. (AP Photo / Rogelio V. Solis)
“The really big fortune, the swollen fortune, by the mere fact of its size, acquires qualities which differentiate it in kind as well as in degree from what is possessed by men of relatively small means. Therefore, I believe in a graduated income tax on big fortunes.”
That’s what Teddy Roosevelt proposed in his agenda-setting “New Nationalism” speech from 1910, when he prodded the United States toward a fuller embrace of progressive reform. As a former president who was preparing to again bid for the position, Roosevelt opened a conversation about tax policy in order to frame a broader debate about at least some of the values that should guide American progress.
At the heart of Roosevelt’s agenda was a specific form of taxation. While progressive taxation in a general sense was desirable and necessary, Roosevelt was particularly enthusiastic about “another tax which is far more easily collected and far more effective—a graduated inheritance tax on big fortunes, properly safeguarded against evasion, and increasing rapidly in amount with the size of the estate.”
Teddy Roosevelt, it should be noted, was a Republican who possessed considerable wealth of his own. He was a flawed figure who let down the progressive cause at many turns and never matched the courageous domestic and foreign policy vision advanced by his rival for leadership of the progressive movement, Wisconsin Senator Robert M. La Follette. But Roosevelt recognized that taxing inherited wealth not merely to collect revenues but to preserve and extend democracy.
“One of the chief factors in progress is the destruction of special privilege.“ — Teddy Roosevelt, 1910
“The absence of effective state, and, especially, national, restraint upon unfair money-getting has tended to create a small class of enormously wealthy and economically powerful men, whose chief object is to hold and increase their power,” he explained. “The prime need to is to change the conditions which enable these men to accumulate power which it is not for the general welfare that they should hold or exercise.”
Roosevelt’s critics may have characterized him as a radical, but he was never as radical (or as right) as La Follette. Roosevelt was, however, conscious of the threats posed to the American experiment by the rapid consolidation wealth and power. And he knew that progressive taxation could be used to address those threats.
Bernie Sanders knows this, as well. That’s why Sanders is proposing a progressive estate tax on the fortunes of the top 0.2 percent of Americans. The senator from Vermont’s newly introduced “For the 99.8% Act” would collect $2.2 trillion from 588 billionaires.
“At a time of massive wealth and income inequality, when the three richest Americans own more wealth than 160 million Americans, it is literally beyond belief that the Republican leadership wants to provide hundreds of billions of dollars in tax breaks to the top 0.2 percent,” argues Sanders. “Our bill does what the American people want by substantially increasing the estate tax on the wealthiest families in this country and dramatically reducing wealth inequality. From a moral, economic, and political perspective our nation will not thrive when so few have so much and so many have so little.”
Sanders is widely expected to bid for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2020. If he does so, Sanders will not be the only contender with a bold plan to tax the rich. Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren, for instance, has a plan to levy a 2 percent tax on the assets of wealthy Americans with more than $50 million. From those with over $1 billion, she’d demand an additional 1 percent.
The Democrats who seek to dislodge Donald Trump in 2020 will all need to make tax policy a priority. Republicans have for so long practiced reverse Robin Hood politics—take from the poor and give to the rich—that the promised Democrats make will be unobtainable without the infusion of revenues that comes from taxing the wealthy. Changing tax policy also infuses governing with democracy, as it dials down the influence of specially interested billionaires (such as the Koch brothers) and their corporations.
What is notable about the Sanders plan is that, with his proposal to establish a 77 percent tax on the value of an estate above $1 billion, the senator is merely seeking “a return to the top rate from 1941 through 1976.”
SUPPORT PROGRESSIVE JOURNALISM
If you like this article, please give today to help fund The Nation’s work.
Sanders is proposing an approach that renews American values, as notes University of California–Berkeley economics professor Emmanuel Saez. “The estate tax was a key pillar of the progressive tax revolution that the United States ushered one century ago. It prevented self-made wealth from turning into inherited wealth and helped make America more equal,” explains Saez. “However, the estate tax is dying of neglect, as tax avoidance schemes are multiplying and left unchallenged. As wealth concentration is surging in the United States, it is high time to revive the estate tax, plug the loopholes, and make it more progressive. Senator Sanders’ bill is a bold and welcome leap forward in this direction.”
Teddy Roosevelt understood this economic calculus, and this democratic imperative.
“In every wise struggle for human betterment one of the main objects, and often the only object, has been to achieve in large measure equality of opportunity. In the struggle for this great end, nations rise from barbarism to civilization, and through it people press forward from one stage of enlightenment to the next,” the Republican president explained in 1910. “One of the chief factors in progress is the destruction of special privilege. The essence of any struggle for healthy liberty has always been, and must always be, to take from some one man or class of men the right to enjoy power, or wealth, or position, or immunity, which has not been earned by service to his or their fellows. That is what you fought for in the Civil War, and that is what we strive for now.”
John NicholsTWITTERJohn Nichols is The Nation’s national-affairs correspondent. He is the author of Horsemen of the Trumpocalypse: A Field Guide to the Most Dangerous People in America, from Nation Books, and co-author, with Robert W. McChesney, of People Get Ready: The Fight Against a Jobless Economy and a Citizenless Democracy.
To submit a correction for our consideration, click here.
For Reprints and Permissions, click here.
http://www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
Senator Cory Booker talks 2020 with Rachel Tuesday, 2/11 9pm ET
Senator Cory Booker talks 2020 with Rachel Tuesday, 2/11 9pm ET
02/11/19 09:59PM
Rachel Maddow alerts viewers that she will host newly declared presidential candidate Senator Cory Booker live in the studio on Tuesday, February 11 at 9pm ET. watch
Klobuchar on staff mistreatment reports: I have high expectations
02/11/19 09:40PM
Rachel Maddow talks with Senator Amy Klobuchar about the criticism that she is too nice to run for president, too demanding of her staff, and how she has prepared herself for the inevitable harsh press coverage that inevitably comes with running for president. watch
Trump border wall hype met by significant resistance in El Paso
Trump border wall hype met by significant resistance in El Paso
02/11/19 09:03PM
Against a backdrop of breaking news in negotiations over border security funding, Rachel Maddow reports on the March For Truth rally led by Beto O'Rourke in El Paso, Texas, organized to counter Donald Trump's nearby rally for his border wall agenda. watch
Denver school teachers walk out on first day of strike
Denver school teachers walk out on first day of strike
02/11/19 09:02PM
Rachel Maddow reports on the start of a strike by Denver school teachers who have walked out asking for better, more stable pay, among other demands. watch
Monday, February 11, 2019
FEBRUARY 9, 10 AND 11, 2019
NEWS AND VIEWS
THE SHEER AMOUNT OF EVIDENCE IN THIS CASE IS THE CAUSE FOR THE TWO YEARS THAT IT HAS CONSUMED. I’VE WATCHED MOST OF IT THROUGH THE EYES OF RACHEL MADDOW AT NIGHT, RELAXING FOR BED, AND SHE GOES INTO GREAT DETAIL. THE NUMBER OF RUSSIANS WHO HAVE BEEN IN CONTACT WITH SEVERAL OF THE TRUMPS IS AMAZING, AND A DOZEN OR MORE BUSINESS ASSOCIATES OF TRUMP HIMSELF HAVE PARADED ACROSS THE NATIONAL STAGE.
I WANT TO SEE NOT JUST HIS CLOSEST ALLIES FACE A JUDGE, BUT THE REPUBLICANS IN CONGRESS AND THE SENATE WHO HAVE RUN INTERFERENCE FOR HIM AS WELL. WERE THEY PAID TO DO THAT? WAS SENATOR FLAKE BUMPED OUT FOR BEING UNCOOPERATIVE? TRUMP HAS DENIED KNOWING AT LEAST ONE OF THEM, OR BEING ABLE TO RECOGNIZE HIM BY SIGHT, IN SPITE OF PHOTOS INCLUDING THE TWO OF THEM. I WANT MUELLER TO GRIND ALL THE WAY THROUGH THE MATERIAL UNTIL THE END. WHETHER OR NOT HE IS INDICTED, HE MUST NOT BE REELECTED IN 2020 AS PRESIDENT. THAT WOULD BE TOO SHAMEFUL FOR OUR PEOPLE, AND MIGHT WELL BE THE END OF OUR COUNTRY AS A FREE SOCIETY.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2019/02/11/special-counsel-robert-mueller-may-not-say-anything-russia-probe/1422892002/
Robert Mueller has spent two years investigating Trump, and he hasn't said a word. It's possible he never will.
Kevin Johnson and Bart Jansen, USA TODAY Published 8:53 a.m. ET Feb. 11, 2019 | Updated 4:49 p.m. ET Feb. 11, 2019
WASHINGTON – Occasionally, his signature appears on court documents. But on the most consequential days of the nearly two-year investigation into Russia’s interference in the 2016 election, the man leading it – Robert Mueller – has been conspicuously absent.
When President Donald Trump's senior aides and confidants paraded through federal courtrooms to face criminal charges his office had filed, the former FBI director was nowhere to be seen. When some of them came back to court to be convicted, he said nothing.
It's possible he never will.
Mueller's investigation has cast a shadow over nearly all of the first two years of Trump's presidency. Prosecutors working to determine whether Trump's campaign coordinated with Russian efforts to sway the election that put him in office have brought charges against some of his top aides and revealed extensive Moscow ties. As the inquiry grinds closer to its conclusion, there are signs that the public might never learn the full extent of what Mueller has – or hasn't – found.
Special counsel Robert Mueller is investigating Russian interference in the 2016 election. (Photo: AP)
Justice Department rules require that Mueller submit a confidential report when his work is done. William Barr, the man likely to be confirmed as his next boss, cast doubt on whether he would permit that document to be revealed. Those who know him say Mueller, reluctant to speak publicly even when the circumstances seem to require it, is unlikely to do it on his own.
"A public narrative has built an expectation that the special counsel will explain his conclusions, but I think that expectation may be seriously misplaced," said John Pistole, Mueller's longtime top deputy at the FBI. "That's not what the rules provide, and I really don't see him straying from the mission. That's not who he is."
The Justice Department's special counsel rules don't call for Mueller to make any public statements about his work, let alone deliver a report of what he has found. Instead, his confidential report must explain why he filed the charges he did and why he might have declined to bring charges against others. It would be up to the attorney general to decide whether that becomes public.
Barr, who is likely to be confirmed this month as attorney general, told lawmakers he couldn't commit to releasing Mueller's report in full. Neither was he clear on whether he would permit Mueller to testify to Congress about his work. He said he wanted to be transparent about Mueller's findings but offered few details.
"Where judgments are to be made by me, I will make those judgments based solely on the law and department policy and will let no personal, political or other improper interests influence my decision," Barr said during his confirmation hearing in January.
Some lawmakers found the answer unsettling.
After Barr's testimony, Sens. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, and Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., introduced legislation that would require a special counsel to provide a report directly to Congress in addition to the attorney general.
People who know Mueller say that unless his bosses tried to derail his work, they would be surprised if the former FBI director did more than issue a brief statement indicating that a report had been submitted to the attorney general before quietly departing.
For any other major player in official Washington, where outsize egos routinely clash for political supremacy or simple adulation, such a scenario would be unthinkable. But Mueller's aversion to the spotlight has been consistent across a lifetime in public service, from the battlefields of Vietnam to the office that represents perhaps the most serious threat to the Trump presidency.
"I don't think that there is any chance that he strays from what the regulations say," said Chris Swecker, a former FBI assistant director who worked closely with Mueller. "So far, he has spoken through the indictments and other court documents his office has filed. You have to understand who he is. He will do what the law prescribes; he's not going to be running his own pass patterns.
“None of this has ever been about his ego,” Swecker said. “He relishes the work as much as he hates the fanfare. It’s never been about him; it’s always been about the work.”
A look at former FBI director Robert Mueller
Fullscreen
Meticulous investigator
Just as the FBI, maligned in the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks, was transformed into his own image as a meticulous investigator, the Russia investigation has come to embody Mueller’s unflagging, buttoned-up personality.
“He’s not a warm and lovable guy,” Swecker said. “If you work for him, you are never going to feel appreciated. Things move too fast for that. He believes that you signed up to do a job. And it’s your mission to get it done. He doesn’t like drama.”
Mueller’s team embraced that approach.
His prosecutors have brought charges against 34 people and three companies, including Trump's former campaign chairman Paul Manafort; his first national security adviser, Mike Flynn; and his former personal attorney, Michael Cohen. Outside of court filings, prosecutors have had nothing to say about any of them.
When the team won a jury verdict after a three-week trial against Manafort, prosecutors retreated to their offices rather than appear at a clutch of microphones outside the courthouse. Asked by email if they had any comment, Mueller's spokesman responded with a single word:
“Nope."
Pistole, who served for six years as Mueller’s deputy at the FBI, describes his former boss as “totally apolitical,” with an unmatched work ethic.
“For him, it was about what is right for the country,” Pistole said. “Nothing else.”
'Most transformative director since Hoover'
Mueller exited the FBI in 2013 as the longest-serving director since J. Edgar Hoover – amassing a legacy best defined by a grind-it-out style that kept the FBI intact.
Michael Chertoff, a former secretary of Homeland Security, described Mueller in an interview with USA TODAY marking the FBI chief's departure as “the most transformative director in the history of the FBI since Hoover.''
"And I mean that in a good way," Chertoff said.
Robert Mueller will oversee the Russia investigation. Here's a look at his background. USA TODAY
After the FBI, Mueller stayed on the public stage but seldom in the spotlight.
As a partner at the high-powered law firm of Wilmer Hale, Mueller had clients that included some of the most recognizable corporate brands, including the National Football League.
The NFL hired Mueller in 2015 to examine the league's handling of a domestic violence incident involving then-Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice. When it was complete, the 96-page report, which cleared the NFL of any intentional improper conduct, was simply posted online. No news conference, no public appearance by Mueller to discuss the findings.
Mueller was among those Trump interviewed to replace his ousted successor at the FBI, James Comey. Instead, Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein appointed Mueller in May 2017 to head the investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election.
Since then, the public has had only occasional glimpses of Mueller. One photo captured him waiting for a plane at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, a few yards away from Donald Trump Jr. The photograph went viral, a measure not only of the chance passing of the two potential adversaries but the intense interest in the intensely private man leading perhaps the most widely watched criminal investigation in a generation.
It was months before Mueller's appointment as a Russia special counsel when Pistole last had an extended visit with his former boss. Pistole said he was surprised to encounter a "jovial" Mueller, a feature few have witnessed in such an outwardly serious character.
"He had been away from government for a while," Pistole said. "He was laughing and joking. I thought: ‘Who is this guy? What have you done with my director?’ I doubt he's had many moments since he took this job."
The case for saying nothing
Barr suggested that if the Senate confirms him, the public is unlikely to hear from Mueller directly.
Barr, who was attorney general in the administration of George H.W. Bush, has made no secret of his allegiance to the chain of command. In the midst of the 2016 campaign, he objected to then-FBI Director Comey's decision not to recommend criminal charges against Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton for her use of a private email server while secretary of state because he said the decision should have been left to the attorney general or the deputy attorney general, not the chief investigator.
Barr told lawmakers he would "provide as much transparency as I can, consistent with the law," about what Mueller's investigation concludes.
He expressed doubt about how much detail he would be able to reveal. Justice Department rules require only that he notify Congress about instances in which he had overruled Mueller's decisions about how the investigation should be handled. Some of the facts Mueller has gathered could be the result of grand jury proceedings, which are required by law to remain secret.
Barr pointed to a Justice Department policy to avoid publicizing "derogatory" information about people who aren't charged with a crime. Senate Democrats expressed concern that the policy, combined with the department's view that a president cannot be indicted, could lead Barr to keep confidential parts of the investigation that relate to Trump.
That could in turn set up a battle with congressional Democrats eager to know the details.
“If the attorney general doesn’t issue a public report, they can expect it to be subpoenaed by Congress because of the high public value of Americans understanding just what the Russians did and who worked with them,” said Rep. Eric Swalwell, D-Calif.
Rudy Giuliani, Trump's lead attorney, has said repeatedly that he fully expects Mueller to produce a final report, indicating that the president's legal team would issue a "counter-report."
Last month, acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker raised expectations when he said Mueller's work was "close to being completed."
"I hope we can get the report from Director Mueller as soon as possible," Whitaker said, only to suggest last week in testimony before the House Judiciary Committee that even he wasn't really sure of the timing and hadn't received a report.
“Bob Mueller is going to finish his investigation when he is going to finish his investigation,” Whitaker told lawmakers.
Some doubt that a substantial final report from the special counsel is even in the offing.
"He's a federal prosecutor; they don't write public reports," said George Washington University law professor Randall Eliason, a former federal prosecutor. "Everybody is breathlessly waiting for the Mueller report, and I'm not sure that one is even coming."
SANDERS MAY BE READY TO RUMBLE, BUT IS HE READY TO ANNOUNCE? I HOPE HE WILL SOON, SO WE CAN GET THIS WAGON TRAIN MOVING. OF COURSE, HE HAS TO DO IT WHEN EVERYTHING IS PREPARED, OR HE WOULD BE DAMAGING HIS CHANCE OF WINNING.
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/02/bernie-sanders-close-announcing-presidential-campaign/582328/
Bernie Sanders Is Ready to Rumble
The senator from Vermont thinks he can prevail against the crowded Democratic field and then beat Trump for president in 2020.
EDWARD-ISAAC DOVERE
FEBRUARY 8, 2019 7:27 AM ET
PHOTOGRAPH – SANDERS SPEAKING PATRICK SEMANSKY / AP
Bernie Sanders has seen himself as on a mission since he started running for office in the 1970s, and he sees no reason to stop now. He thinks he’s dramatically changed the conversation over the past three years, and he feels like he’s close to achieving his ultimate goal.
Plus, there’s Donald Trump.
When the president used his State of the Union speech on Tuesday to preview his own reelection campaign and warn against creeping socialism, Sanders was only encouraged. He’d love to take on Trump directly, and people around him think he’ll be able to use Trump’s threat to coalesce support in the primaries.
Get the latest issue now.
“Nothing unifies Democrats like being made a villain by Trump,” said one Sanders ally.
The senator from Vermont has been huddling with staff in meetings and brainstorming on phone calls over the past few weeks, chewing over plans. Barring a surprise, last-minute change of heart, he will jump into the 2020 race, convinced he can win, according to people familiar with his plans. His spokeswoman, Arianna Jones, did not return a request for comment on Sanders’s plans.
Read: A lot of people want Bernie Sanders to run in 2020
Last time, he didn’t get in until the end of April 2015. This time, the launch will be in February. He sees advantage in a much more crowded 2020 field. The left-leaning politics he campaigned on in 2016 have been broadly embraced in a progressive surge among Democrats, and Sanders has succeeded in diminishing the nominating power of so-called super delegates, the elected officials and party elders who help consolidate establishment power within the Democratic National Committee.
Sanders will likely announce an exploratory committee in the coming weeks, followed by a rally. One major early focus will be finding a campaign manager and other top-level staffers who are not white, and preferably not male, in light of his problems appealing to minority voters in 2016 and recent revelations of sexual harassment by lower-level staffers on the 2016 campaign. Staff interviews have been quietly under way.
But a core team of advisers will return from 2016, spearheaded by Sanders’s wife and closest adviser, Jane O’Meara Sanders.
Peter Beinart: Bernie Sanders offers a foreign policy for the common man
His aides know this race will be different from his 2016 run against Hillary Clinton, when he surprised even himself with how close he came to knocking her off. Democratic leaders have been impressed by the extent to which the ideas from his campaign have carried forward, injecting far-left populism into the mainstream of Democratic politics—even as many in the party still bitterly point to his candidacy as weakening Clinton to the point that Trump was able to win.
Sanders has heard the argument that his stature would be diminished by running again if he doesn’t end up winning the nomination. He’s heard the argument that he might split the progressive vote and allow a more moderate candidate to win, but that hasn’t moved him either. That’s not how Sanders thinks, people who know him point out.
“He understands what happens in the streets is what prompts actions in Washington,” said Vincent Fort, a former Georgia state senator who supported the last campaign and has been in touch with Sanders’s team about this campaign.
There are also the nuts-and-bolts political considerations that Sanders doesn’t focus as much on, but that his team pays close attention to: He’s the one with the massive email list. Alone among those eyeing the Democratic nomination, he’s the one who had 40,000 people watching various live-streams of his State of the Union response. He’s the one whose team thinks he could, on day one, raise more money online and get more attention than any of the other candidates.
Sanders believes that he continues to have the strength in Iowa and New Hampshire to either win or come close there—especially with other candidates fragmenting support and lowering the bar for what it will take to win. Likewise, in a South Carolina primary that has both Cory Booker and Kamala Harris competing for African American votes and, likely, Joe Biden drawing on his own decades of connections there, Sanders sees a path to slip through and win.
Biden in the race, after all, would make it so that the senator isn’t the only white man in his 70s in the field.
If the early states all come together, Sanders would be positioned to power through the front-ended primary calendar that has California, Texas, and several other big states voting on the first Super Tuesday, March 4, just a month after Iowa. No one else in the field has anything like his proven success with both grassroots supporters and the small-dollar online fundraising that it will take to fund the kind of massive national operation any 2020 campaign will require.
“With all the other people in, the fact is, Bernie is the one whose ideas everyone else is ‘borrowing,’ whether it be Wall Street reforms, or Medicare for all, or free college. These are all ideas that Bernie came up with first and best,” Fort said. “I’m a little bit skeptical of the sincerity of some of the latecomers.”
Changes to DNC procedures, which Sanders and his team fought for, have diminished the role of the caucuses where Sanders ran the strongest in 2016, but they have also taken power away from the elected officials and party elders who might, for example, help tilt a tight race to Biden or another candidate who isn’t an outsider insurgent.
Sanders’s team has been eyeing Beto O’Rourke nervously, given the former Texas congressman’s strong online presence and appeal with many of the same types of voters that Sanders taps into. O’Rourke also drew significant support from young former Sanders staffers who helped build the 2016 campaign into what it was. But there’s a sense that O’Rourke’s support is flagging, as he continues to talk about running without making a decision.
Now a Sanders candidacy would seem to be the biggest threat to Elizabeth Warren, who’s been campaigning on her own anti-corporate platform, with proposals such as a new tax on the ultrarich. Aides to the senator from Massachusetts have been preparing her on how to respond. But though they will clearly compete for some of the same voters, Sanders and his aides have always seen him as a greater threat to her than she is to him, and have been encouraged by the continuing problems she’s facing from the controversy over her claims of Native American heritage. He’s the one with the devoted followers, Sanders and his aides believe, and some of them are still angry at Warren for deciding to sit out the 2016 primary race rather than endorsing him.
Read: Sanders and Warren are heading for a standoff
What a Sanders candidacy may do for Warren, though, is enable her not to seem as radical as his democratic socialism. It might also enable her to note that she’s a generation younger than Sanders, as opposed to currently being the oldest Democratic candidate in the field. And a Sanders candidacy might allow Warren to argue that she’s largely in line with him politically, but the one who could actually win.
A Warren spokeswoman declined comment on how Warren would position herself if Sanders runs.
Sanders boosters note that with a field this big, coming in first in Iowa might take only about 30 percent of the vote, and that he came just shy of 50 percent of the vote there against Clinton. Rules changes to the caucuses might also play to Sanders’s favor, clarifying an arcane process that weighs votes in a way that can make the final results not fully representative of the number of people who actually show up on caucus night.
But Sanders skeptics doubt that he fully appreciates how much of the approximately 45 percent of the primary vote he received in 2016 was fundamentally an anti-Clinton vote, and doubt that he realizes how many of those people might leave him once they realize how many other choices they have. Unlike in his last run, he will start right away with the spotlight of a presumed front-runner on him, and issues involving his background and record that were overlooked in 2016 will likely receive new scrutiny. Warren, Biden, and Harris have been the focus of most of the Republican attacks and reporters’ digging so far, but that dynamic may shift if Sanders continues to run as strong as public polling suggests.
There’s the potential that once he’s in, any stumbles will be higher profile, and any drop-off in the polls could suggest he’s leaching support. Already, in the past week he waited until after all the declared Democratic candidates to call for Virginia Governor Ralph Northam to resign over the blackface/Ku Klux Klan–hood photo. He also faced outrage for doing his own State of the Union response for the third year in a row; this year’s followed Stacey Abrams’s official Democratic response. Some griped that he was being disrespectful, a charge that Sanders and his team found ridiculous, even as they dealt with the fallout.
He spent most of his response explaining how Trump’s supposed economic miracle hasn’t reached many people in the country.
“I know that this will probably not shock you—I hate to say this—but not everything Donald Trump said tonight was true or accurate,” Sanders said in a live video on social media.* “For many of President Trump’s billionaire friends, the truth is, they have never, ever had it so good. But for the middle class, and for the working families of our country, the truth is that the economy is not so good.”
*This article originally misstated that Sanders delivered his response to the State of the Union address immediately after Trump spoke. In fact, Sanders delivered his response after Stacey Abrams finished giving the Democrats’ official response to the president’s address.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.
EDWARD-ISAAC DOVERE is a staff writer at The Atlantic.
IT’S INTERESTING TO SEE THAT A YOUNGER AND LESS EXPERIENCED CANDIDATE IS BEING COMPARED TO SANDERS. I DID WATCH O’ROURKE SPEAK ON THE YOUNG TURKS, AND HE’S PRETTY EXCITING. HE’S NOT FOR 2020, THOUGH. I’M BEHIND SANDERS UNTIL OR UNLESS HE ACTUALLY LOSES. I ALSO LIKE OCASIO-CASTRO PRETTY WELL. SHE’S REALLY TOO YOUNG, THOUGH. I ALSO WOULD LIKE TO SEE STACEY ABRAMS GO FOR IT, IN A LATER ELECTION, THAT IS.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/02/09/us/politics/2020-democrats-campaign-funding.html
Sanders and O’Rourke Are Way Ahead in Race for Small-Dollar Donors
By Shane Goldmacher, Lisa Lerer and Rachel Shorey
Feb. 9, 2019
PHOTOGRAPH -- Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont has by far the largest number of low-dollar online donors of any current or likely 2020 Democratic presidential candidate, according to a Times analysis of campaign finance data.CreditCreditTravis Dove for The New York Times
Senator Bernie Sanders would begin a 2020 presidential bid with 2.1 million online donors, a massive lead among low-dollar contributors that is roughly equivalent to the donor base of all the other Democratic hopefuls combined.
Beto O’Rourke, the former Texas congressman who narrowly lost a Senate race last year, is also poised to be a fund-raising phenom if he runs for president: He has twice as many online donors as anyone eyeing the race besides Mr. Sanders.
Three senators who are already running have their own solid track records with small donors. Senator Elizabeth Warren, with the third-highest number, has notable strength in New Hampshire, even topping Mr. O’Rourke there. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand has built up broad national support among small donors, despite a reputation as a big-money fund-raiser, while Senator Kamala Harris raised $1.5 million online in her first 24 hours as a presidential candidate.
Small-dollar donations are expected to be a huge deal in 2020 — the renewable resource that Democratic candidates will depend upon to fuel their campaigns. And those five Democrats represent a distinctive top tier with the most formidable followings, each counting a base of at least 230,000 online donors, according to a New York Times analysis of six years of federal election filings from ActBlue, the Democratic Party’s dominant donation-processing platform.
[Check out the 6 days when 2020 Democratic hopefuls scored big with small donors.]
The findings provide a window into one of the most closely guarded and coveted resources of a modern campaign: the digital donor lists that bring in the vast bulk of low-dollar donations. These online donations average just under $40, and candidates like to point to such modest amounts as evidence of the breadth and depth of their support among regular people.
In the early stages of a presidential race, when polling measures little more than name recognition, the relative size of donor networks can provide one of the best metrics of strength.
“The people who have a strong base right now have a material head start,” said Teddy Goff, who served as a top digital strategist for the campaigns of President Barack Obama in 2012 and Hillary Clinton in 2016. “And more often than not, there is a good reason they have that base, and it’s that they have a talent for connecting with the grass roots of our party.”
For Mr. Sanders and Mr. O’Rourke, the enormous early edge in their donor rolls has afforded them the flexibility to wait longer before deciding to jump in, and has sparked a sense of urgency in other campaigns. Both men have signaled they would rely overwhelmingly on small donors to fuel any campaign.
The particular power of Mr. Sanders’s list was on display in late December when he emailed supporters with the provocative subject line, “If I run.” That single email netted $299,000 from 11,000 donations, according to a senior Sanders official.
That is almost the exact amount that Ms. Warren raised on the day she announced she was entering the race, data shows.
The Times’s analysis estimated the size of the online donor armies for current and potential candidates by comparing hundreds of millions of dollars in donations processed through ActBlue. The analysis does not include candidates who have not run for federal office, such as mayors or governors, nor those who did not use ActBlue.
To get a sense of scale, if Mr. Sanders’s 2.1 million donors constituted a city, the closest approximation would be to Houston, the country’s fourth-largest by population. For Mr. O’Rourke, it would be Seattle (742,000). For Ms. Warren, Honolulu (343,000). Ms. Gillibrand would be Toledo, Ohio (271,000). Ms. Harris would be Winston-Salem, N.C. (239,000).
Image
Beto O’Rourke, the former Texas congressman, amassed a huge number of online donors during his 2018 Senate race against Ted Cruz.CreditEric Gay/Associated Press
Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey, who entered the race at the start of February, would be Grand Forks, N.D. (56,000) — a sign of how Mr. Booker has not yet converted his vast social-media following into financial contributors.
Former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr., despite being nationally known, would probably also begin far behind because he has not run for office on his own in a decade. His political action committee reported about $925,000 in donations of less than $200 since mid-2017, but since Mr. Biden does not use ActBlue there is no estimate of his number of donors. A spokesman for Mr. Biden declined to comment.
[Check out the Democratic field with our candidate tracker.]
Mr. Biden does have one unusual asset: access to the Obama campaign’s vaunted email list, which was 9 million-strong when turned over to the Democratic National Committee in 2015, according to the party. But email lists rapidly atrophy, and one that is seven years old is seen as a relative relic.
Donors lists can take years to compile, and the biggest ones are often only developed through running a high-profile race. Email remains the dominant way to raise money online, and campaigns heavily advertise efforts like petition-signing drives on Facebook to harvest new donor email addresses. Those lists, in turn, generate volunteers and a network of potential supporters who can amplify candidates’ messages on social media to build further support.
Grass-roots giving is seen as so important in 2020 that the Democratic National Committee has included it as part of its presidential debate qualification rules.
Who’s Running for President in 2020?
Who’s in, who’s out and who’s still thinking.
Jan. 21, 2019
“It is hard to see someone winning this nomination who isn’t at or near the top of ability to generate small donations, because they are a measure of enthusiasm,” said Anita Dunn, a Democratic strategist and veteran of the Obama White House.
Candidates are under intense pressure to lock down donors, big and small, in an already sprawling race. Whether small-dollar donors and larger bundlers give to multiple candidates or stay “monogamous” remains an open question, as Democrats have not had such a sizable field since the rise of online fund-raising.
The findings represent the best snapshot of small donor strength at the starting gate of a campaign where the ability to raise tens of millions of dollars from small donors will be crucial, particularly as leading candidates are disavowing super PACs that allow for unlimited sums from wealthy backers.
Of course, in a race likely to stretch over the next 18 months, early advantages can dissipate quickly. A strong poll or viral moment can prompt donors to give to new candidates, thereby growing their lists by huge numbers — so long as they are positioned to capitalize. Ms. Harris’s launch-day haul, for instance, rivaled that of Mr. Sanders in 2015.
Ms. Dunn said she saw the initial rankings less as a predictor for the coming primary’s outcome and more as a revealing indicator of “who was able to use their 2017 and 2018 effectively to prepare for a presidential race.”
Both Ms. Harris and Ms. Gillibrand landed on the leader board despite having not faced a competitive election in recent years. The two senators spent heavily to bulk up their small donor lists, investing in multimillion-dollar campaigns on Facebook in 2017 and 2018 to add email addresses to their supporter list and lure in new contributors.
“It’s almost like growing vegetables,” said Tim Lim, a veteran Democratic digital strategist. “You have to be mindful. You have to be aware of major events. You have to be patient. But then, within six months or so, your investment will pay back.”
While it is no surprise that Mr. Sanders is ahead with small digital donors — he is the only potential candidate to have a previous run for president included in the analysis — the sheer magnitude of his opening advantage is striking.
Mr. Sanders had 369 days during his 2016 presidential campaign where he processed more online donations than Ms. Gillibrand did on her single best day in the Senate — the day after President Trump tweeted about her “begging” him for money — through the end of 2018, according to the data. (Ms. Gillibrand’s biggest days were notably smaller than those of her rivals with large bases of support.)
The advantage that Mr. Sanders and Mr. O’Rourke enjoy is not just the size of their lists but the exclusivity of their donors — the vast majority of whom (an estimated 87 percent for Mr. Sanders, 72 percent for Mr. O’Rourke) have not contributed to any other potential 2020 candidate. In contrast, less than half of Ms. Warren’s donors have given only to her among the potential 2020 field.
Ms. Gillibrand actually had slightly more donors who were exclusive to her than Ms. Warren — even though she counted 70,000 fewer donors overall.
Critical questions remain about almost every candidate’s donor lists: Will donors to Mr. Sanders from his 2016 primary challenge to Hillary Clinton stick with him in a 2020 race with progressive alternatives? How much of Mr. O’Rouke’s flock were drawn to the chance to defeat Senator Ted Cruz, a favorite liberal villain? And how many of Ms. Warren’s boosters backed her against then-Senator Scott Brown but may not be on board for a run for the White House?
Behind the top five candidates, Senator Sherrod Brown of Ohio, who is traveling through the early states as he considers a run, finished next with 114,000 donors. Next was Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon, who was the only senator to endorse Mr. Sanders in 2016 and is now mulling a campaign; his 105,000 online donors suggest his fund-raising potential is relatively underrated.
Mr. Booker is among the most widely followed potential presidential candidates on social media (he has 4 million Twitter followers) but the New Jersey Democrat had the seventh-most donors among senators looking at 2020 bids. Mr. Booker’s campaign website intermittently used ActBlue in 2013, 2014 and 2015, suggesting his full number of online donors is likely at least somewhat higher.
“He’s the perfect case study to show what it takes to build a large online grass-roots following today. It’s folly to think you can just grow that organically,” said Mr. Lim, the digital strategist. “Just because you have a lot of followers or people who like you or talk to you, that doesn’t translate to an organized and impactful community of donors.”
Mr. Booker has announced that Jenna Lowenstein, a former top digital strategist for Mrs. Clinton’s 2016 campaign, would serve as his deputy campaign manager, a move seen as focusing on improving his online donor footprint.
Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, who is expected to announce a 2020 bid on Sunday, lags far behind her colleagues, with fewer than 38,000 donors. That figure was about on par with Richard Ojeda, who briefly declared his presidential candidacy after losing a House race in West Virginia before abruptly quitting in late January.
Representative Tulsi Gabbard of Hawaii, who announced her bid for president in January, had 41,000 donors, but more than 75 percent of her donors overlapped either with Mr. Sanders, whom she endorsed in 2016, or with at least two other potential candidates.
Ms. Gabbard’s single best day for online donations came two and half years ago. That was the day Mr. Sanders sent a fund-raising email for her.
A version of this article appears in print on Feb. 10, 2019, on Page A1 of the New York edition with the headline: In Race for Donations, Democrats Think Small. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe
THIS IS ANOTHER SUBJECT THAT I WAS UNAWARE OF. THE AMOUNT OF VIOLENCE OF THIS LAST CENTURY IS ALMOST UNIMAGINABLE. IT IS PROBABLY IMPOSSIBLE FOR US HUMAN CREATURES TO BECOME ANYTHING CLOSE TO WHAT I CONSIDER TO BE “CIVILIZED.” THIS IS ONE OF MANY SHOCKING TIME PERIODS AND EVENTS, AND I CAN SEE WHY THEY HAVE BEEN SET UP IN A WEBSITE TO BE REMEMBERED, BECAUSE TO FORGET IS TO FAIL TO REPENT.
“THE MOSCOW TERROR PROJECT”
https://topos.memo.ru/en/node/1
About the project
What is the project about?
The website “Topography of Terror” is part of the project “Moscow: Sites of Memory,” organized by International Memorial since 2013.
What do we do?
We conduct research and endeavor to raise public awareness about the Soviet terror in Moscow. Our aim is to make the history of the Soviet terror and the relationship between individuals and Soviet society visible on the contemporary map of the city.
From where does the name of the site originate?
The website's name is inspired by the project “Topography of Terror” in Berlin. After much deliberation, we adopted the same name because it accurately characterizes the mission of our project. Although our possibilities are far more limited, we have learned a great deal—ethically, methodologically, and technically—from our German colleagues.
How can I use the website?
The website “Topography of Terror” is an address book and database about the Soviet terror in Moscow. There are two ways to explore the contents: via the map or via articles. On the contemporary map of Moscow you can activate one or several of the themed layers and find out more about the history of the marked locations. Both current and Soviet-era names of streets and avenues can be seen. In the articles section, you can choose to read one page at a time. Every text includes an address, information about the location's history, and a description of the buildings or other artifacts related to the events. Many places have not survived intact; in this case, the area is marked with a pale color. Some sites we unfortunately cannot locate accurately; in this case, the given area is marked with dots. New thematic content appears monthly.
What sources do we use?
We use all possible sources that are reliable. We study old handbooks, maps, newspapers, and magazines. We interview witnesses and experts, research published and unpublished memoirs, and reinterpret art and literature, such as Solzhenitsyn’s and Shalamov’s works. Most importantly, we try to track down sources from the Russian state archives. This is the most difficult task—even though we know where the necessary sources are, our access is restricted. Therefore, we have to use indirect sources, such as the archives of party prisons, administrative documents, related materials, fonds, and so forth. Our work is similar to that of a detective—we investigate old crimes and try to collect evidence. A summary of the archival sources used for “Topography of Terror” can be found on an open resource at notepad.memo.ru.
How can we do it?
The answer is that we cannot succeed by working alone. We rely on the contributions of experts, researchers, trainees, volunteers, photographers, cartographers, graphic designers, programmers, and many others, including ordinary readers. If you wish to make a contribution or contact us, please send an e-mail to: ap@memo.ru
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Purge
Great Purge
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This article is about the 1936–38 Soviet purge. For the general article about political purges, see Purge.
The Great Purge or the Great Terror was a campaign of political repression in the Soviet Union which occurred from 1936 to 1938.[5] It involved a large-scale purge of the Communist Party and government officials, repression of wealthy landlords and the Red Army leadership, widespread police surveillance, suspicion of saboteurs, counter-revolutionaries, imprisonment, and arbitrary executions.[6] In Russian historiography, the period of the most intense purge, 1937–1938, is called Yezhovshchina (literally, "Yezhov phenomenon",[note 1] commonly translated as "times of Yezhov" or "doings of Yezhov"), after Nikolai Yezhov, the head of the Soviet secret police, the NKVD, who was executed a year after the purge. Modern historical studies estimate the total number of deaths due to Stalinist repression in 1937–38 to be between 681,692-1,200,000.[2][1]
In the Western world, Robert Conquest's 1968 book The Great Terror popularized that phrase. Conquest's title was in turn an allusion to the period called the Reign of Terror during the French Revolution (French: la Terreur, and, from June to July 1794, la Grande Terreur, the Great Terror).[7]
HERE IS UP-CLOSE INFORMATION ABOUT THE SANDERS LIFE, FOR THOSE WHO ARE INTERESTED. THIS IS A 2016 ARTICLE, SO SOMETHING WILL HAVE CHANGED BY NOW, I'M SURE. DOES HE STILL DO HIS OWN LAUNDRY AND CHOP HIS OWN FIREWOOD? I HOPE HE DOES, BECAUSE CHOPPING WOOD IS GOOD EXERCISE, AND DOING HIS OWN LAUNDRY IS THE RIGHT WAY TO TREAT A WOMAN. I HAVE TRIED CHOPPING WOOD. I HAD HATEFUL BLISTERS ON MY HANDS, AND I’LL NEVER DO IT AGAIN UNLESS I REALLY DO HAVE TO. THAT WAS WHEN I WAS IN THE GIRL SCOUTS.
https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/onpolitics/2016/01/20/bernie-sanders-paleo-before-paleo-thing/79065692/
Bernie Sanders 'was Paleo before Paleo was a thing'
Josh Hafner, USA TODAY Published 1:52 p.m. ET Jan. 20, 2016 | Updated 3:55 p.m. ET Jan. 20, 2016
PHOTOGRAPH -- Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders speaks to a crowd of voters during a campaign appearance in Underwood, Iowa, on Jan. 19, 2016. (Photo: Tannen Maury, EPA)
Corrections and clarifications: An earlier version of this post misstated Burlington's location. It's in northwestern Vermont.
Journey with me, if you will, to Vermont.
There, in Burlington, off the shores of Lake Champlain, the good folks of People magazine take us into the "modest colonial home" of Bernie Sanders.
In an interview dropping [sic] Friday, the 74-year-old welcomes us to sit at a crackling wood stove with his wife, Jane, for a humanizing glimpse of the democratic socialist in an increasingly close battle for the Democratic presidential nomination.
Fun tid-bits ensue.
Sure, Jeb Bush got early press for losing 30-plus pounds on the Paleo diet. But Bernie's been on the diet trend all along.
(Sanders) does his own grocery shopping and grilling, sticking to a diet of mostly meat and vegetables. "He was Paleo before Paleo was a thing," says Jane's other daughter, Carina Driscoll.
And did you know people pay money for pre-cut firewood? Ha! Not Bernie.
He also chops his own firewood and can be handy around the house – just not, as Jane puts it, "with a lot of attention to aesthetics." He once tacked new screening onto a window frame without cutting away the excess, she recalls, "so we had a window with a tutu. And he said, 'Well, it works!'
And while my closet currently contains as many as 10 sweaters, Sanders thinks that's ridiculous:
Jane jokes to PEOPLE of her minimalist husband, "If Bernie has seven sweaters, that's three too many for him."
That's far too many sweaters! Oh, Bernie!
View image on Twitter
View image on Twitter
People
✔
@people
EXCLUSIVE: @BernieSanders does his own laundry (and grocery shopping, too!) http://peoplem.ag/OGniAJ8
1,779
11:05 AM - Jan 20, 2016
631 people are talking about this
Twitter Ads info and privacy
Glenn Reynolds: We just might get that Trump-Sanders race
https://people.com/celebrity/inside-bernie-sanders-family-and-home-life-he-does-his-own-laundry-shopping/
Bernie Sanders Does His Own Laundry (and Grocery Shopping): Inside the Family Life of the Down-to-Earth Democratic Candidate
"How far we've come is really incredible," Bernie Sanders tells PEOPLE
SANDRA SOBIERAJ WESTFALL TIERNEY MCAFEE
January 20, 2016 05:50 AM
"How far we've come is really incredible," Bernie Sanders tells PEOPLE
In the past year, everything and nothing has changed for Bernie Sanders.
The one-time Democratic dark horse has gradually become a top-tier contender for the presidential nomination, with recent polls in New Hampshire and Iowa showing him neck-and-neck with – or even leading – rival Hillary Clinton.
Yet in his heart and home the Vermont senator remains the same down-to-earth “Bernster” – as his son, Levi, lovingly refers to him – he’s always been. And that much was plain to see when PEOPLE stopped by to visit Sanders and his family at his modest colonial home in Burlington, Vermont, last month.
Bernie Sanders with his grandchildren Dylan and Ella Photographs by Martin Schoeller
As Sanders’ wife, Jane, reviewed his laundry list of accomplishments for PEOPLE at the kitchen table, the senator let out a deep sigh. “He doesn’t like to talk about himself – or hear about himself,” Jane explains. But his ears perk up moments later when the buzzer of a dryer sounds from the basement.
“That’s my cue!” Sanders says, jumping up to tend to his laundry.
For much more of PEOPLE’S interview with Bernie Sanders and his family, pick up the new issue, on newsstands Friday
Not that he has much laundry. Jane jokes to PEOPLE of her minimalist husband, “If Bernie has seven sweaters, that’s three too many for him.”
Adds Heather Titus, one of Jane’s daughters from her first marriage, “If they still sold cars with manual locks and windows, that’s what Bernie would have.”
The 74-year-old Democratic socialist from Brooklyn leads a simple home life indeed. He does his own grocery shopping and grilling, sticking to a diet of mostly meat and vegetables. “He was Paleo before Paleo was a thing,” says Jane’s other daughter, Carina Driscoll.
He also chops his own firewood and can be handy around the house – just not, as Jane puts it, “with a lot of attention to aesthetics.” He once tacked new screening onto a window frame without cutting away the excess, she recalls, “so we had a window with a tutu. And he said, ‘Well, it works!’ ”
Sanders’ bellowing indignation – against income inequality, Wall Street greed and climate change – seems to be working as well, especially among millennials who swell the crowds at rallies drawing tens of thousands.
With voting set to begin in Iowa on Feb. 1, Sanders marvels to PEOPLE, “How far we’ve come is really incredible.”
GUN CRIMES AND MENTAL HEALTH
COMPILATION AND COMMENTARY
BY LUCY WARNER
FEBRUARY 7, 2019
I CAN’T HELP WONDERING WHAT A “LAW ABIDING CITIZEN” MEANS TO DO WITH A LOADED GUN ANYWHERE EXCEPT AT THE FIRING RANGE. WHAT IS GOING ON IN THEIR MINDS? SELF-DEFENSE? WHY ARE THEY SO FRIGHTENED? ONE OF MY DEVELOPING CONCLUSIONS FROM READING SO MUCH NEWS IS THAT MENTAL CONDITIONS WHICH ARE POTENTIALLY UNHEALTHY, AT LEAST TO SOME DEGREE, INCLUDING EXTENSIONS OF A NORMAL INSTINCT, ARE PRESENT BEFORE THE CRIME IS COMMITTED, AND ESPECIALLY IN CASES OF VIOLENCE. THEY ARE ALSO FAR MORE COMMON AND HARDER TO DETECT THAN I WOULD LIKE TO BELIEVE. THAT DOESN’T MEAN THAT WE SHOULD NOT TAKE AS MANY GUNS AS POSSIBLE OUT OF THE HANDS OF THE MENTALLY ILL, AND OFF THE STREETS IN GENERAL. MANY A TRAGEDY HAS OCCURRED FROM A FIREARM BEING LEFT OUT IN THE OPEN FOR A CHILD TO FIND.
OF COURSE, THERE WILL STILL BE VIOLENCE WITHOUT FIREARMS, BUT NOT 50 PEOPLE BEING GUNNED DOWN FROM THE TOP OF A BUILDING, AS OCCURRED A YEAR OR TWO AGO IN LAS VEGAS. THIS ARTICLE DOESN’T MENTION THE ISSUE OF RELIGION AND POLITICS IN REGARD TO GUNS. THE RELIGIOUS TEND TO THINK THAT IF THEY FRIGHTEN THE POPULATION ENOUGH ABOUT A FIERY HELL, THE SIN WILL STOP; AND THE PARANOID BELIEVE THAT THE CONSTITUTION GIVES THEM THE RIGHT TO CARRY A GUN ANYTIME AND ANYWHERE THEY WANT TO, SO THEY CAN BE THE HEROIC DEFENDER AGAINST A GUN-CARRYING VILLAIN.
IT’S ALL INTELLECTUAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL NONSENSE, OF COURSE, AND IN THE MEANTIME THE NATIONAL RIFLE ASSOCIATION CONTINUES TO BRIBE CONGRESSMEN AND SENATORS TO VOTE THEIR WAY, AND THREATEN THEM IF THEY PUT UP TOO MUCH OPPOSITION. WE NEED TO “GET SERIOUS” ABOUT THE KIND OF SOCIETY WE ARE WILLING TO LIVE IN. PERSONALLY, I WANT TO BE SANE, MORAL AND INTELLIGENT FIRST. IF I FEEL THAT MY NEIGHBORHOOD IS UNSAFE, I’LL CARRY A LESS LETHAL WEAPON SUCH AS A KNIFE. THEY’RE DANGEROUS ALSO, BUT MORE CONTROLLABLE THAN A GUN.
THE SECOND WRITING BELOW IS AN ARTICLE FROM psychiatrictimes.com, SO IT IS MORE PROFESSIONALLY RELIABLE ON THE ISSUE OF INSANITY AND CRIME, THAN IS THE AVERAGE NEWS REPORT. IT, HOWEVER, IS A VERITABLE TANGLE OF FACTORS THAT ARE 1) TIGHTLY INTERRELATED AND 2) INSUFFICIENTLY SPECIFIC IN THEIR MEANING AND STATISTICAL PREDICTABILITY TO ALLOW A PSYCHIATRIC WORKER TO “PREDICT” ACCURATELY WHO WILL COMMIT ANY KIND OF VIOLENCE, AND ESPECIALLY GUN VIOLENCE IN PARTICULAR. 3, I WOULD LIKE MORE ATTENTION PAID TO THE FACT THAT MENTAL ILLNESS IS TOO OFTEN “UNDIAGNOSED,” SO THE UNPREDICTABILITY FACTOR IS A MAJOR CAUSE OF PROBLEMS. IT INTERESTS ME THAT THE ARTICLE IS SPECIFICALLY ABOUT GUN VIOLENCE. GIVEN THE EASY AVAILABILITY OF FISTS, STICKS, CUTTING OBJECTS AND ROCKS, THE LIKELIHOOD OF A MURDER OCCURRING IN ANGER BY ONE OF THOSE METHODS IS MUCH GREATER. WE NEED TO FOCUS MORE ON VIOLENCE ITSELF.
MY BROTHER-IN-LAW, A “CONSERVATIVE” SOUTHERNER, DID TAKE A SAFETY RAZOR WITH THE BLADE IN IT ONTO AIRPORT PROPERTY WITH THE INTENTION OF TAKING IT ON THE PLANE. HE ISN’T DANGEROUS OR “INSANE,” BUT HE IS A BIT OF A SMART-ALECK. HE MAINLY WANTED TO GET AWAY WITH IT. HE DIDN’T LIKE THE LIST OF RESTRICTIONS ON WHAT CAN GO INTO THE CARRY-ON BAG, SO HE PACKED IT INTO THE TOE OF A SHOE WITH WADDED PAPER STUFFED IN BEHIND IT. THE LUGGAGE EXAMINERS FOUND IT, AND I ASSUME HE WAS AT LEAST EMBARRASSED. MY SISTER DIDN’T TELL ME WHAT HAPPENED TO HIM, BUT ACCORDING TO THIS ARTICLE, PEOPLE CAN BE FINED UP TO $13,333 FOR ONE OFFENSE. IT JUST ISN’T WORTH IT.
WATCH THE VIDEO THAT GOES WITH THIS ARTICLE. SEE ALSO THE SECOND, VERY INTERESTING ARTICLE ON FREQUENCY AND PREDICTION OF A DIAGNOSED MENTAL ILLNESS IN PUBLICIZED CASES OF VIOLENCE: “psychiatrictimes.com.”
https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/flights/todayinthesky/2019/02/07/guns-airports-tsa-record-2018/2799757002/
TSA found a record-setting number of guns at airports in 2018
TODAY IN THE SKY
Harriet Baskas, Special to USA TODAY Published 9:39 a.m. ET Feb. 7, 2019 | Updated 2:00 p.m. ET Feb. 7, 2019
VIDEO -- In 2018, TSA screeners detected a record number of guns in airline passenger carry-on bags. Buzz60
It’s no secret that it is illegal for passengers to bring firearms, loaded or not, to airport security checkpoints.
Yet, in 2018, the Transportation Security Administration found a record-setting 4,239 firearms in carry-on bags at 249 airport checkpoints around the country.
That’s more than a 7 percent increase over the 3,957 firearms discovered at airport checkpoints in 2017, averaging out to 81.6 firearms a week and 11.6 firearms a day, according to the TSA’s Year in Review, which was released today.
Perhaps more alarming, of the 4,255 firearms found last year, more than 86 percent (3,656) were loaded (another record) and almost 34 percent (1,432) had a round chambered.
The TSA's 2018 Year in Review. (Photo: TSA)
The TSA’s Year in Review also lists the top 10 airports for firearm discoveries in 2018.
Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL), tops that list, with 298 firearms (253 loaded), an increase of 53 compared to 2017.
ATL, which regularly sets records for the busiest airport (in terms of passenger count), also set a record for the airport with the most firearms discovered in one month: In August 2018, 32 firearms were found at ATL checkpoints.
Some of the firearms found at airport checkpoints in 2018.Some of the firearms found at airport checkpoints in 2018. (Photo: TSA)
Here’s the rest of the TSA’s top 10 list of airports for firearms discoveries in 2018:
.... Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport: 219 (193 loaded)
.... Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport: 129 (120 loaded)
.... Denver International Airport: 126 (95 loaded)
.... Orlando International Airport: 123 (112 loaded)
.... George Bush Intercontinental Airport: 117 (115 loaded). Some good news here: this is a decrease of 25 compared to 2017.
.... Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport: 96 (80 loaded)
.... Austin-Bergstrom International Airport: 93 (76 loaded)
.... Dallas Love Field Airport: 89 (83 loaded)
.... Nashville International Airport: 86 (80 loaded)
While the laws regarding firearm possession vary by state and locality, TSA is able to, and regularly does, impose civil penalties of up to $13,333 per violation, per person for prohibited items violations and violations of other TSA regulations.
In a year when the TSA also screened a record number of travelers (813.8 million; a 5.5 percent increase over 2017), the agency’s officers also found a wide variety of prohibited items and "artfully concealed" objects other than firearms in carry-on bags, including inert grenades, a bottle of lighter fluid, fireworks and knife combs*.
The TSA’s week in review also notes the loss of Curtis “Blogger Bob” Burns, the charmingly corny employee who chronicled the agency’s odd finds on the TSA blog, on Twitter and on Instagram. Burns is featured in quirky videos highlighting the TSA’s most unusual finds for 2016 and 2017 and the TSA’s Year in Review promises that a video highlighting 2018’s most unusual finds will be released soon.
TODAY IN THE SKY: 'Blogger Bob' Burns, TSA’s surprise social media star, dies
PHOTOGRAPH -- Some of the prohibited items found at airport checkpoints in 2018. (Photo: TSA)
https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/special-reports/gun-violence-stigma-and-mental-illness-clinical-implications
Gun Violence, Stigma, and Mental Illness: Clinical Implications
Jonathan M. Metzl, MD, PhD
Mar 25, 2015
Volume: 32, Issue: 3
Special Reports, Trauma And Violence
New legislation in a number of states requires mental health professionals to assess their patients for the potential to commit gun crimes. For instance, New York state law mandates that mental health professionals report anyone who “is likely to engage in conduct that would result in serious harm to self or others” to the state’s Division of Criminal Justice Services, which then alerts local authorities to revoke the person’s firearms license and confiscate his or her weapons. Similarly, a recently passed bill in Tennessee requires mental health professionals to report “threatening patients” to local law enforcement.
Supporters of these types of laws argue that they provide important tools for law enforcement officials to identify potentially violent persons—and understandably so. US policymakers and the general public look to psychiatry, psychology, neuroscience, and related disciplines as sources of certainty in the face of the often incomprehensible terror and loss that gun violence inevitably produces. And to be sure, persons with mental illness who have shown violent tendencies should not have access to weapons that could be used to harm themselves or others.
However, the notion that psychiatric attention might prevent gun crime is more complicated than it might seem. New research undertaken by me and my colleague, Professor Ken MacLeish, warns of the potential pitfalls of such laws if they are unaccompanied by other community-based or antistigma interventions.1 We systematically reviewed the key psychiatry, psychol- ogy, public health, and sociology literature that addressed connections between mental illness and gun violence between 1960 and 2014. We also used our own primary source historical research on violence and mental illness, and American gun culture.2-4
Our review critically addresses 4 central assumptions that underlie many US political and popular associations between gun violence and mental illness:
• That mental illness causes gun violence
• That psychiatric diagnosis can predict gun crime before it happens
• That US mass shootings teach us to fear mentally ill loners
• That because of the complex psychiatric histories of mass shooters, gun control “won’t prevent” another Tucson, Aurora, Newtown, or Navy Yard
Each of these statements is certainly true in particular instances. At the same time, our research shows how these seemingly self-evident assumptions are replete with complicated and at times contradictory assumptions. At the aggregate level, the notion that mental illness causes gun violence stereotypes a diverse population of persons with psychiatric conditions and oversimplifies links between violence and mental illness. Moreover, notions of mental illness that emerge in relation to gun violence frequently reflect larger cultural issues that become obscured when mass shootings come to stand for all gun crime and when “mentally ill” ceases to be a medical designation and becomes a sign of violent threat.
Our research also shows how anxieties about insanity and gun violence are imbued with often unspoken anxieties about race, politics, and the unequal distribution of violence in American society. In the current American landscape, these tensions play out most clearly in differing cultural responses to, for instance, high-profile shootings in places like Newtown (where headlines located pathology in the perpetrator’s brain) and New York City (where news commentators wondered whether murderous actions were motivated by “black politics.”5)
Our analysis suggests that similar, if less overt, tensions suffuse discourses linking guns and mental illness more broadly, in ways that subtly connect “insane” gun crimes with often unspoken assumptions about “white” individualism or “black” communal aggression.
Ultimately, our research challenges psychiatry to think deeply about potentially untenable situations in which mental health practitioners become the persons most empowered to make decisions about gun ownership—and most liable for failures to predict gun violence—if these situations are not accompanied by larger reforms that address the social, structural, and indeed psychological implications of gun violence in the US.
Our findings appear in the February 2015 issue of the American Journal of Public Health.1 By way of a summary, the following 4 assumptions are examined.
Assumption 1: mental illness causes gun violence
The focus on mental illness in the wake of recent mass shootings in the US reflects a decades-long history of psychiatric and legal debates about guns, gun violence, and mental competence. Psychiatric articles in the 1960s deliberated ways to assess whether mental patients were “of sound mind enough” to possess firearms.6 Following the 1999 mass shooting at Columbine High School, psychiatrist Peter Breggin decried the toxic combination of mental illness, guns, and psychotropic medications that contributed to the perpetrators’ actions. After the 2012 shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, psychiatrist E. Fuller Torrey claimed that “about half of . . . mass killings are being done by people with severe mental illness, mostly schizophrenia, and if they were being treated they would have been preventable.”7
Gun Violence, Stigma, and Mental Illness: Clinical Implications: Page 2 of 4
Yet surprisingly little population-level evidence supports the notion that individuals with mental illness are more likely than anyone else to commit gun crimes. According to psychiatrist Paul Appelbaum,8 fewer than 3% to 5% of American crimes involve people with mental illness, and the percentages of crimes that involve guns are lower than the national average for persons without a diagnosis of mental illness. Databases that track gun homicides, such as the National Center for Health Statistics, similarly show that fewer than 5% of the 120,000 gun-related killings in the US between 2001 and 2010 were perpetrated by people with mental illness.9
Moreover, a growing body of research suggests that mass shootings represent anecdotal distortions of, rather than representations of, the actions of “mentally ill” people as an aggregate group. By most estimates, there were fewer than 100 mass shootings reported in the US—defined as crimes “when four or more people are shot in an event, or related series of events”—between 1982 and 2012.10 Rates of reported mass shootings rose in 2013 and 2014.
Scholars who study violence prevention contend that mass shootings occur far too infrequently to allow for statistical modeling and predictability—factors that lie at the heart of effective public health interventions. Psychologist Jeffrey Swanson11 argues that mass shootings denote “rare acts of violence” that have little predictive or preventive validity in relation to the bigger picture of the 32,000 fatalities and 74,000 injuries caused on average by gun violence and gun suicide each year in the US.
Links between mental illness and other types of violence are similarly contentious among researchers who study such trends. Study findings suggest that subgroups of persons with severe or untreated mental illness might be at increased risk for violence during periods surrounding psychotic episodes or psychiatric hospitalizations.12 At the same time, a number of seminal studies asserting links between violence and mental illness have been critiqued for overstating connections between serious mental illness and violent acts.13
Media reports often assume a binary between mild and severe mental illness, and they connect the latter form to unpredictability and lack of self-control. However, this distinction is called into question by mental health research. To be sure, a number of the most common psychiatric diagnoses, including depressive, anxiety, and attention-deficit disorders, have no correlation with violence whatsoever. Community studies find that serious mental illness without substance abuse is also “statistically unrelated” to community violence. At the aggregate level, the vast majority of people with psychiatric disorders do not commit violent acts—only about 4% of violence in the US is attributable to persons with mental illness.14
This is not to suggest that researchers know nothing about predictive factors for gun violence. However, credible studies suggest that a number of risk factors more strongly correlate with gun violence than mental illness alone. For instance, alcohol and drug use increase the risk of violent crime by as much as 7-fold, even among persons with no history of mental illness—a concerning statistic in the face of recent legislation that allows persons in certain states to bring loaded handguns into bars and nightclubs. According to Van Dorn and colleagues,15 male sex and a history of childhood abuse and binge drinking are all predictive risk factors for serious violence. Belying Lott’s16 argument that “more guns” lead to “less crime,” Miller and colleagues17 found that homicide was more common in areas in which household firearms ownership was higher. The rate of interpersonal conflicts resolved by fatal shootings jumped by 200% after Florida passed “stand your ground” in 2005.18 The availability of guns is also considered a more predictive factor than is psychiatric diagnosis in many of the 19,000 completed suicides by gun each year in the US.
Some persons with mental illness undoubtedly commit violent acts. Yet growing evidence suggests that mass shootings on which gun legislation is often based represent statistical aberrations that reveal more about particularly horrible instances than they do about population-level events. To use Swanson’s11 phrasing, basing gun-crime prevention efforts on the mental health histories of mass shooters risks building “common evidence” from “uncommon things.” This type of approach loses the opportunity to build common evidence from common things—such as the types of evidence that clinicians of many medical specialties might catalogue, in alliance with communities, about substance abuse, domestic violence, availability of firearms, suicidality, social networks, economic stress, and other factors.
Assumption 2: psychiatric diagnosis can predict gun crime before it happens
Legislation in a number of states mandates that psychiatrists assess their patients for the potential to commit violent gun crime. History suggests, however, that psychiatrists are inefficient gatekeepers in this regard. Data that support the predictive value of psychiatric diagnosis in matters of gun violence are thin at best. Psychiatric diagnosis is largely an observational tool, not an extrapolative one. Largely for this reason, research dating back to the 1970s suggests that psychiatrists using clinical judgment have difficulty in predicting which patients will commit a violent crime.
The lack of prognostic specificity is in large part a matter of simple math. Psychiatric diagnosis is in and of itself not predictive of violence, and the overwhelming majority of psychiatric patients do not commit crimes.
In this sense, population-based literature on guns and mental illness suggests that legislatures risk drawing the wrong lessons from gun crimes and mass shootings if their responses focus on asking psychiatrists to predict future events. Although rooted in valid concerns about public safety, legislation that expands mental health criteria for revoking gun rights puts psychiatrists in potentially untenable positions, not because they are poor judges of character, but because the urgent political and social conditions psychiatrists are asked to diagnose are at times at odds with the capabilities of their diagnostic tools and prognostic technologies.
Assumption 3: look out for dangerous loners
Mass shootings in the US are often framed as the work of loners—unstable, angry white men who never should have had access to firearms.19 “Gunman a Loner Who Felt No Pain” read a headline in the wake of the Newtown shooting. And to be sure, a number of other recent shooters undoubtedly led troubled, solitary lives.
It is important to note, however, that the seemingly self-evident images of the mentally disturbed, gun-obsessed, white male loner are relatively recent phenomena. In the 1960s and 1970s, by contrast, many of the men labeled as violent and mentally ill were also, it turned out, African American. And, when the potential assailants were black, American psychiatric and popular culture frequently blamed “black culture” or black activist politics—not individual, lone shooters—for the threats such men were imagined to pose.2
For instance, anxieties about race and politics shaped many 1960s-era American political associations between schizophrenia and gun violence. FBI profilers spuriously gave diagnoses of militant forms of schizophrenia to many “pro-gun” black political leaders as a way of highlighting the insanity of their political activism. According to declassified documents, the FBI diagnosed “pre-psychotic paranoid schizophrenia” in Malcolm X while highlighting his attempts to obtain firearms and his “plots” to overthrow the government.2 The FBI also gave Robert Williams, the head of the Monroe, North Carolina, chapter of the NAACP, the diagnosis of “schizophrenic, armed, and dangerous” during his flight from trumped-up gun charges in the early 1960s.20 Malcolm X, Robert Williams, and other leaders of African American political groups were far from schizophrenic. But fears about their political sentiments, guns, and sanity mobilized substantial response.
During this era, US psychiatry also spoke out in favor of gun control—articles in the American Journal of Psychiatry urged psychiatrists to address “the urgent social issue” of firearms in response to “the threat of civil disorder”—while Congress began serious debate about gun control legislation leading to the Gun Control Act of 1968.6
Recent history suggests that cultural politics underlie anxieties about whether guns and mental illness represent individual or communal etiologies. In the 1960s and 1970s, widespread concerns about black “cultural” and political violence fomented calls for widespread reforms in gun ownership. As this played out, politicians, FBI profilers, and psychiatric authors argued for the right to use mental health criteria to limit gun access. However, in the present day, the actions of “lone” white male shooters go hand in hand with calls to expand gun rights, or limit gun rights only for the severely mentally ill. Indeed it would seem political suicide for a legislator or doctor to hint at restricting the gun rights of white Americans, private citizens, or men, although these groups are frequently linked to high-profile mass shootings.21
Assumption 4: gun control “won’t prevent” another Tucson, Aurora, Newtown, or Navy Yard
The mantra that gun control “would not have prevented Newtown” is frequently cited by opponents of such efforts. This contention generally assumes that because none of the recent mass shooters in Tucson, Aurora, Newtown, or Isla Vista used weapons purchased through unregulated private sale or gun shows, gun control in itself would be ineffective in stopping gun crime, and that gun purchase restrictions or background checks are in any case rendered moot when shooters have mental illness.
No one wants another tragedy like Newtown—on this point all sides of the gun debate agree. Moreover, it is widely acknowledged by persons on all sides of that debate that there is no guarantee that the types of restrictions voted down by the US Senate in April 2013, based largely on background checks, would prevent the next mass crime. Yet, as discussed above, many scholars who study violence prevention hold that mass shootings occur too infrequently to allow for statistical modeling, and as such serve as poor jumping off points for effective public health interventions.
The focus on individual crimes or the psychologies of individual shooters obfuscates attention to community-level everyday violence and the widespread symptoms produced by living in an environment engulfed by fear of guns and shootings. Far from the national glare, this everyday violence disproportionally affects lower-income areas and communities of color, and is held to be the cause of widespread anxiety disorders and traumatic stress symptoms as a result.22
Given this terrain, it is increasingly the case that when violence prevention experts talk about ebbing gun crime linked to mental illness, they do not mean that mental health practitioners will avert the next random act of violence such as Newtown, although of course stopping mass crime remains a vital goal. Instead, they contend that the insanity of urban gun violence all too often reflects the larger madness of not investing more resources to support social and economic infrastructures and support systems.
Conclusion: implications for clinicians
Questioning the associations between guns and mental illness in no way detracts from the dire need to stem gun crime. Yet as the fractious US debate about gun rights plays out in ever-more divisive ways, it seems incumbent to find common ground beyond assumptions about whether particular assailants meet criteria for specific mental illnesses, or whether mental health experts can predict violence before it occurs. Of course, understanding a person’s mental state is vital to understanding his actions. At the same time, our research suggests that focusing legislative policy and popular discourse so centrally on mental illness is rife with potential problems if, as seems increasingly the case, those policies are not embedded in larger societal strategies and structural-level interventions.
Research also suggests that agendas that hold mental health workers accountable for identifying dangerous assailants puts these workers in potentially untenable positions because the legal duties they are asked to perform misalign with the predictive value of their expertise. In this sense, instead of accepting the expanded authority provided by current gun legislation, mental health workers and organizations might be bet-ter served by identifying and promoting areas of common cause between clinic and community, or between the social/community and psychological/individual dimensions of gun violence.23
Connections between loaded handguns and alcohol; the mental health effects of gun violence in low-income communities; or the relationships between gun violence and family, social, or socioeconomic net- works are but a few of the topics in which mental health expertise might productively join community and legislative discourses to promote more effective medical and moral arguments for sensible gun policy than currently arise amongst the partisan rancor.
Put another way, perhaps psychiatric expertise might be put to better use by enhancing understanding of the complex anxieties, social and economic formations, and blind assumptions that make people fear each other in the first place. Psychiatry could help society interrogate what guns mean to everyday people, and why people feel they need guns or reject guns out of hand. By addressing gun discord as symptomatic of deeper concerns, psychiatry could, ideally, promote more meaningful public conversations about the impact of guns on civic life. And, it could join with public health researchers, community activists, law enforcement officers, or business leaders to identify, promote meaningful conversation about, and empathically address the underlying structural and infrastructural issues that foster real or imagined notions of mortal fear in our minds, our streets, and our society.
Disclosures:
Dr Metzl is Frederick B. Rentschler II Professor of Sociology and Medicine, Health, and Society; Director of the Center for Medicine, Health, and Society; and Professor of Psychiatry at Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tenn. He reports no conflicts of interest concerning the subject matter of this article.
References:
1. Metzl JM, MacLeish KT. Mental illness, mass shootings, and the politics of American firearms. Am J Public Health. 2015;105:240-249.
2. Metzl JM. The Protest Psychosis: How Schizophrenia Became a Black Disease. Boston: Beacon Press; 2011.
3. MacLeish KT. Making War at Fort Hood: Life and Uncertainty in a Military Community. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press; 2013.
4. Metzl JM, MacLeish KT. Triggering the debate: faulty associations between violence and mental illness underlie US gun control efforts. Risk Regul. 2013;25:8-10.
5. North A. When officers die and protesters get the blame. New York Times. December 23, 2014. http://op-talk.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/12/23/when- officers-die-and-protests-get-the-blame/?smid= tw-share. Accessed February 10, 2015.
6. Rotenberg LA, Sadoff RL. Who should have a gun? Some preliminary psychiatric thoughts. Am J Psychiatry. 1968:125:841-843.
7. CBS News. Preview: Imminent Danger. 60 Minutes. September 27, 2013. http://www.cbsnews.com/videos/preview-imminent-danger. Accessed July 23, 2014.
8. Appelbaum PS. Violence and mental disorders: data and public policy. Am J Psychiatry. 2006;163: 1319-1321.
9. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Leading Causes of Death Reports, National and Regional 1999-2010. February 19, 2013. http://webappa.cdc.gov/sasweb/ncipc/leadcaus10_us.html. Accessed February 3, 2015.
10. Follman M, Aronsen G, Pan D. A guide to mass shootings in America. Mother Jones. May 24, 2014. http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2012/07/mass-shootings-map?page=2. Accessed February 3, 2015.
11. Swanson JW. Explaining rare acts of violence: the limits of evidence from population research. Psychiatr Serv. 2011;62:1369-1371.
12. Keers R, Ullrich S, Destavola BL, Coid JW. Association of violence with emergence of persecutory delusions in untreated schizophrenia. Am J Psychiatry. 2014;171:332-339.
13. Grohol JM. Violence and mental illness: simplifying complex data relationships. Psych Central. http://psychcentral.com/blog/archives/2007/05/02/ violence-and-mental-illness-simplifying-complex-data-relationships. Accessed July 1, 2014.
14. Fazel S, Grann M. The population impact of severe mental illness on violent crime. Am J Psychiatry. 2006;163:1397-1403.
15. Van Dorn R, Volavka J, Johnson N. Mental disorder and violence: is there a relationship beyond substance use? Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2012;47:487-503.
16. Lott JR Jr. More Guns, Less Crime: Understanding Crime and Gun Control Laws. 3rd ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 2010.
17. Miller M, Azrael D, Hemenway D. Rates of household firearm ownership and homicide across US regions and states, 1988-1997. Am J Public Health. 2002;92:1988-1993.
18. The Editorial Board. Craven statehouse behavior. New York Times. March 14, 2014. http://www. nytimes.com/2014/03/15/opinion/craven-statehouse- behavior.html. Accessed February 3, 2015.
19. Metzl JM. When shootings happen, gender has to be part of the conversation. MSNBC. June 9, 2014. http://on.msnbc.com/TmbHlK. Accessed February 3, 2015.
20. FBI Hunts NAACP Leader. NY Amsterdam News. September 23, 1961.
21. Peters JW. Senate balks at Obama pick for surgeon general. New York Times. March 14, 2014. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/15/us/senate-balks-at-obama-pick-for-surg.... Accessed February 3, 2015.
22. Ruiz R. Life, death, and PTSD in Oakland: how violence and poverty are traumatizing the city’s youth. East Bay Express. December 11, 2013. http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/life-death-and-ptsd-in-oakland/Con.... Accessed February 3, 2015.
23. Hiday VA. The social context of mental illness and violence. J Health Soc Behav. 1995;36:122-137.
WHY DID THIS PERSON SHOOT A DOZEN INNOCENT STRANGERS? I NOTE THAT NONE OF THESE ARTICLES GOES INTO THE MORBID LOVE OF DEADLY WEAPONS THAT I HAVE SEEN IN SOME PEOPLE, MEN ALL. THAT, TO ME, SHOULD BE ON ANY LIST OF PREDICTIONS OF WHO WILL DO ONE OF THESE ACTS OF MAYHEM.
https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/couch-crisis/moving-beyond-motives-mass-shootings
Moving Beyond “Motives” in Mass Shootings
James L. Knoll IV, MDRonald W. Pies, MD
Jan 14, 2019
Volume: 36 Issue: 1
PHOTOGRAPH – A HAND HOLDING A PISTOL
Couch in Crisis, Forensic Psychiatry, Trauma And Violence
COMMENTARY
Dr Knoll is Director of Forensic Psychiatry and Associate Professor of Psychiatry at SUNY Upstate Medical University in Syracuse, NY. He is Editor in Chief Emeritus of Psychiatric Times (2010 to 2014). Dr Pies is Professor in the psychiatry departments of SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY and Tufts University School of Medicine, Boston. He is Editor in Chief Emeritus of Psychiatric Times (2007 to 2010).
As psychiatrists, our stock-in-trade is understanding our patients’ motives—and in general, understanding what makes people “tick.” So, it may seem surprising that when it comes to mass shootings, such as the horrific Thousand Oaks bar massacre, we feel frustrated by the media’s obsession with the shooter’s “motives.” The same goes for investigators of such attacks, who seem fixated on determining the shooter’s “motive.”
To be sure: after such tragedies, it’s simply human nature to ask, “Why did the shooter do it?” And even in the most heinous and difficult to fathom crimes, there is motive. The popular myth that the perpetrator of a mass shooting “just snapped” has been debunked.1 Furthermore, the determination of “motive” is often important in criminal law. Essentially, motive (from the Latin word motivum, meaning “moving cause”) is what moves a person to commit a certain act. In US criminal law, there is no requirement to prove motive to reach a verdict. However, motive may be shown by the prosecution in order to prove that a defendant had a plausible reason to commit the crime.
Technically, motive is distinct from intent, although the two are often intertwined. (Motive has been defined as “the reason that nudges the will and prods the mind to indulge the criminal intent.”2) Thus, a person who knowingly puts a loaded gun to someone’s temple and fires it clearly had the intent to kill or grievously wound the person, but may have done so for a number of motives (eg, revenge, jealousy, racial animus).3 Motive becomes critical in, for example, the prosecution of hate crimes and acts of terrorism.4
Notwithstanding the legitimate role of “motive,” we believe that the ritualized hunt for the shooter’s motive is usually an exercise in fruitless speculation and wasted resources. When pursued by the media, this quest almost always lacks the necessary data to reach a sound determination. Moreover, these exercises rarely yield any useful or actionable information that would help reduce the likelihood of future mass shootings. Almost invariably, we learn little more than what we have known for many years—that mass shooters are typically (though not always) angry, aggrieved, emotionally unstable, or socially isolated males who are seeking retribution or revenge for perceived mistreatment, rejection, or humiliation.5
AS A SOCIETY, we must do better than this. We need to focus on:
1 Recognizing the major risk factors that raise the risk of violence in general;
2 Identifying and reporting observable “red flag” behaviors that point toward imminent, directed violence;
3 Reducing the likelihood that would-be killers can easily get hold of lethal weapons.
PAGE 2 OF 4
Is there a “profile” for mass shooters?
The most important risk factor for future violence in general is a previous history of violence.
Other prominent risk factors include, but are not limited to6,7:
• A history of substance abuse
• A history of having been abused or bullied
• Witnessing violence between parents
• A preoccupation with weapons or death; poor control of anger
• Social isolation
Unfortunately, these risk factors are far too prevalent in the general population to be of practical use in identifying would-be shooters and may not apply to mass shooters. For example, there is often no history of serious past violence in these individuals. Furthermore, neither the Secret Service nor the FBI has found a specific psychological profile or checklist of personality traits that can be used to predict who will become a mass shooter.8
And yet, almost invariably, there is uninformed speculation in the media regarding the role of “mental illness” in mass shootings. First, it bears repeating that there is only a weak correlation between violence and mental illness per se.9 However, untreated mental illness is a significant risk factor for violence; ie, “. . . a small number of seriously mentally ill individuals do become violent when they are not treated . . .”10 With regard to mass shooters specifically, there is little documented clinical evidence linking these perpetrators to major mental illnesses like schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Indeed, no research has reliably established that most mass murderers and shooters are psychotic or suffering from a serious mental illness.5
In fact, a recent FBI report on 63 active shooters (2000-2013) found that only 25% (n = 16) of subjects had ever had a mental illness diagnosis; and of those, only 3 had a diagnosis of a psychotic disorder.11 The FBI report pointedly notes that, “. . . formally diagnosed mental illness is not a very specific predictor of violence of any type, let alone targeted violence;” and, further, that “declarations that all active shooters must simply be mentally ill are misleading and unhelpful.” On the other hand, some evidence suggests that many mass shooters have been preoccupied with feelings of social persecution and fantasies of revenge for some type of perceived injustice.11,12
While the FBI report did not directly assess the shooters’ motives, it did identify various grievances in 79% of the active shooters, mainly in the realm of interpersonal or employment actions perceived to be directed against the shooter (total of 49%). The report also identified “precipitating events” in 44% of the shooters who had an identifiable grievance (eg, an adverse ruling in a legal matter, a “romantic rejection,” job loss). However, the report implied that while these precipitants may have accelerated the timing of the shooting, they did not “set the course.” In any case, neither the identified grievances nor the putative precipitants are specific enough to be useful predictors of a shooting; after all, millions of people probably experience the sort of grievances, rejections, and losses noted in the report.
One important limitation of the FBI report was the absence of formal psychological autopsies. These involve collecting all available information on the deceased via structured interviews of family members, relatives, or friends, and attending health care personnel, as well as collecting data from psychiatric records and other documents.
Page 3 of 4
Watching for worrisome behaviors
Rather than speculating on the shooters’ motives, the FBI report emphasizes the observable, pre-attack behaviors of would-be shooters, and how alert citizens can communicate their concerns to appropriate authorities. Warning signs include, among others, “leakage of violent intent” to others; making threats; and acting aggressively. (“Leakage” occurs when a person intentionally or unintentionally reveals clues to a third-party about thoughts, attitudes or intentions suggesting the intent to commit a violent act.11)
The FBI found that, over time, the majority of perpetrators demonstrated at least 4 to 5 concerning behaviors that were observable to others, such as problematic interpersonal interactions, or communicating their violent intent (leakage)—either through verbal or physical behavior. Those under age 18 demonstrated such behaviors to school peers or teachers, while those over 18 demonstrated the behaviors to spouses or domestic partners. This phenomenon of leaking violent intent is consistent with findings by the US Secret Service that found that over three-quarters of perpetrators made concerning communications and/or elicited concern from others before carrying out their attacks.13
It is in the area of paying attention to warning signs and appropriate reporting to authorities that we may make the biggest gains in preventing mass shootings. Indeed, the FBI report suggests that by means of recognizing such red flags we may be able to head off potential shootings. Specifically, in 13 states, initiating an “extreme risk protection order” allows a judge to temporarily restrict a dangerous individual’s access to firearms, possibly preventing an imminent shooting.14
The following Case Vignette is an example of “what went right” in averting a potential mass shooting. It involves a 22-year-old international student, here on a temporary visa.
CASE VIGNETTE
Mr Z had attempted to buy an AR-15—the semiautomatic weapon of choice for most mass shooters—at a local gun shop. For several reasons—including Mr Z’s inquiring about high-capacity shotguns for hunting—the gun shop owner became suspicious and contacted the sheriff’s office. In doing so, the gun store owner became the hero who appropriately alerted law enforcement. A series of discoveries uncovered Mr Z’s history of alcohol abuse, depression, suicidal thinking, anger problems, and feeling that he might lose control or act violently. This led authorities at the University to fill out the paperwork for New York’s SAFE Act, which bans the sale of most semi-automatic weapons, and prevents people from buying a gun if a mental health professional determines that individuals might harm themselves or others.
Subsequently, fellow students shared screenshots of messages they had seen Mr Z post in a social media group. These revealed that Mr Z felt compelled to buy a gun and a bulletproof vest, and to practice shooting. Police obtained a search warrant for Mr Z’s apartment, where they found high-powered optics, scopes, ammunition, targets from shooting ranges, receipts from shooting ranges, and similar equipment. Ultimately, Mr Z’s visa was revoked, and he was deported. Further investigation uncovered a series of texts between Mr Z and his girlfriend, in which he openly talked about wanting to shoot people.
Moving Beyond “Motives” in Mass Shootings: Page 4 of 4
Moving away from motives to preemption and prevention
We hope that cases such as this, in concert with the FBI’s recommendations, will shift the focus of the press and other parties from sensationalizing motives to observing and reporting ominous behaviors. We would include suicidal threats or behaviors in this category, since almost half of the shooters in the FBI study had suicidal ideation or engaged in suicide-related behaviors at some time prior to the attack.11
Through collaboration between the public and responsible authorities, we stand a chance of preempting at least some planned shootings. Indeed, one study of thwarted mass homicide plots found that friends, family members, and acquaintances of threateners—as well as the general public—all played an important role in discovering and thwarting homicidal plots.15 To be sure, there is a great deal of room for improvement in this area. For example, the FBI report found that only about 41% of persons reported their concerns about potential shooters to law enforcement authorities.
While solid, evidence-based methods of preventing mass shootings are still lacking, we believe that progress will come through work on a number of fronts. First, better reporting of ominous behaviors and careful use of extreme risk protection orders may avert at least some mass shootings. Second, the use of Threat Assessment and Management (TAM) teams in our schools may also help preempt planned attacks. TAM teams are interdisciplinary groups of professionals that include law enforcement, mental health providers, and other security stakeholders, collaborating in a structured effort to accurately assess and mitigate the risk of violence.16
Finally, we believe—albeit speculatively—that the media can contribute to a reduction in mass shootings by refusing to publicize and sensationalize mass shooters by dwelling on their supremely resentful, narcissistic motives. There is reason to believe that such notoriety may encourage copy-cat killers, bent on outdoing the previous shooter.17,18 Surely, proactively uncovering homicidal plots and removing the lethal means of carrying them out makes far more sense than retroactively speculating on a shooter’s motives.
This article was originally published on 11/16/18 and has since been updated.
Disclosures:
The authors report no conflicts of interest concerning the subject matter of this article.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)